What do you think of Bridgette DePape's protest

What do you think of DePape protest?

  • Shit disturbing twit

    Votes: 55 62.5%
  • Couragous self sacrifiing and admirable

    Votes: 33 37.5%

  • Total voters
    88
I didn't object to the notion that 40% leads to a majority, I like first past the post better than the alternatives. I objected to your assertion that it was a "decisive" result. It was not. Over 60% voted against the government.
A more than comfortable majority, the Liberal Party practically eliminated in Parliament. I call that decisive.
 
Sure it can be in a Parliamentary democracy if the Liberals had won you would have said so.

No, it is not great even when the libs win because it is still not a democratic result. It is less offensive to Canadians as a whole, because when you add the NDP votes it is a majority, so you have typically about 20% of the electorate wishing the govt was MORE left. Now you have a very right wing govt ruling over a nation that voted 60% left..
 
If the liberals and ndp merge the problem will be solved, we don't need different rules.

That would shift the whole system to the left, the conservatives would move left to capture those liberals not willing to negotiate with socialists and we would wind up with competitive elections where each party got near half the vote.
 
Flat earth/restrict the vote to tax payers. That's got to receive an award for the biggest stretch in logic in this forum and that saying a lot. So find someone who agrees with you, maybe two, now or in the past, ever . I doubt very much you can.

Hey, backwards thinkers have been around since the beginning of humanity and still exist to this day, as you've helped prove. Just pointing that out. Not that big a stretch, really.
 
So people in public housing don't vote? You're just flat wrong, they do. And voting based on income is a retarded idea that would disenfranchise millions of people and ultimately lead to some sort of violence.

I never said voting should be based on income. I said it should be based on being a taxpayer, and ideally it would be proportional to the amount of tax one pays. Just as a shareholder of a company is given one vote per share, the taxpayer should be given one vote per x number of $$$ they contribute to us all. Seems this most fair of methods is despised by so many for some reason.
 
She said no such thing. the fact is, a majority of Canadians voted against Harper. If you are gonna say ..eh! it's our system. It may be a system, but how can you call a system that delivers a majority govt that was NOT the preference of 60% of voters a "DEMOCRACY"? By that stretch Bahrain is a democracy.. since about 40% of people support the leader.

Actually the majority of voters did not vote against HArper, they voted for their choice of candidate, there is a difference there evn if you chose not to notice it. The number of votes is not a deciding factor it is the number od seats, if i recall only two governments in memory had absolute majorities, Mulroney and Diefenbaker both with over the 50% of votes cast, so you are screaming about a difference that is really not a difference in this instance. The difference would have been if the Tories had recieved an absolute majority.
 
Getting support of 40% is now "decisive"?

Yes when that vote delivers more than 155 seats in our parliment. That has been the way our democratic process works under Canadian law, if you don't like it leave. Only two elections have produced absolute majorities that I recall, Mulroney and John Deifenbaker, so actually winning a majority numerically is the odd occurance.
 
Yes she did, and since the majority of Canadians want to retain the current system. . .

When have Canadians ever been offered a different system? Most Canadians have no idea Harper got only 40% of the vote. Her protest is an attempt to start the debate and highlight the fact that Harper DOES NOT really have the mandate he claims to have.
 
Yes when that vote delivers more than 155 seats in our parliment. That has been the way our democratic process works under Canadian law, if you don't like it leave. Only two elections have produced absolute majorities that I recall, Mulroney and John Deifenbaker, so actually winning a majority numerically is the odd occurance.

Only a coward would leave a country because he/she did not like the system. True patriots fight to make their country better. Please explain to me why you are so opposed to a system that would reflect the choice of Canadians more accurately?
 
Hey, backwards thinkers have been around since the beginning of humanity and still exist to this day, as you've helped prove. Just pointing that out. Not that big a stretch, really.

Backward thinkers?

I still noticed you haven't come up with the an example of somebody, somewhere, or some government who has done this at anytime. Since it's such a uniques idea and in you mind such an excellent idea, why don't you contact the Canadian Government and tell them of your insight and your solution. It doesn't seem to make any sense to anyone here on TERB as no one has backed up your idea and there are some pretty smart people here. Their silence might also tell us you're nutts.
 
Backward thinkers?

I still noticed you haven't come up with the an example of somebody, somewhere, or some government who has done this at anytime. Since it's such a uniques idea and in you mind such an excellent idea, why don't you contact the Canadian Government and tell them of your insight and your solution. It doesn't seem to make any sense to anyone here on TERB as no one has backed up your idea and there are some pretty smart people here. Their silence might also tell us you're nutts.

You keep proving my point. In your opinion the idea is only valid if others are already doing it. That is backwards thinking. I really don't know how else I can explain this so I give up. You win. No as yet un-tested ideas can possibly be any good.

You actually haven't given me a good reason why the idea is so bad, other than nobody else is already doing it.

I think trying new things is a sign of intelligence and progress, but that must just be me. I can tell you one thing; I would never be arrogant enough to assume that people who have chosen not to participate in this discussion automatically agree with me. That would be nutty.
 
You keep proving my point. In your opinion the idea is only valid if others are already doing it. That is backwards thinking. I really don't know how else I can explain this so I give up. You win. No as yet un-tested ideas can possibly be any good.

You actually haven't given me a good reason why the idea is so bad, other than nobody else is already doing it.

I think trying new things is a sign of intelligence and progress, but that must just be me. I can tell you one thing; I would never be arrogant enough to assume that people who have chosen not to participate in this discussion automatically agree with me. That would be nutty.

I've already given you reasons why it won't work or be accepted in earlier post, not much use in repeating myself. You are also keeping this amazing idea to yourself and not telling our leaders so maybe even you see the problems and don't want to be dealt with by them. I suspect they will look at you with that glazed look of disbelief
 
I've already given you reasons why it won't work or be accepted in earlier post, not much use in repeating myself. You are also keeping this amazing idea to yourself and not telling our leaders so maybe even you see the problems and don't want to be dealt with by them. I suspect they will look at you with that glazed look of disbelief

No. You've given me reasons why you don't accept it, not why it won't work. I didn't know posting on terb counts as "keeping it to myself", I thought I was sharing the idea with you and few others.

As we are now running around in circles I'll say...

Good day sir.
 
No. You've given me reasons why you don't accept it, not why it won't work. I didn't know posting on terb counts as "keeping it to myself", I thought I was sharing the idea with you and few others.

As we are now running around in circles I'll say...

Good day sir.

No shit Sherlock.
 
I never said voting should be based on income. I said it should be based on being a taxpayer, and ideally it would be proportional to the amount of tax one pays. ....

So the people who pay more tax get more votes but that is not the same thing as more income?

(actually in our tax system, it might mean that the middle class - those without the fancy accountants - get more say)
 
Only a coward would leave a country because he/she did not like the system. True patriots fight to make their country better. Please explain to me why you are so opposed to a system that would reflect the choice of Canadians more accurately?

Here's a question. Can you give an example of a democracy that is to your liking (other than any one that elects the candidate you like)?