Idol top 3...

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,817
5,495
113
All were pretty good, Haley was AWESOME, her dad RIPS!!! And it was a real gutsy song choice. She is a real star.
 
to my mind she won the first two rounds, but stumbled a bit (pardon the pun) on the third. "You Oughta Know" is supposed to be a very angry song and she did not bring the anger two it.

But the other two just make me ill.
 
to my mind she won the first two rounds, but stumbled a bit (pardon the pun) on the third. "You Oughta Know" is supposed to be a very angry song and she did not bring the anger two it.

But the other two just make me ill.

My thoughts exactly. I'm a huge Zeppelin fan and when Seacrest announced her song, I figured she would slaughter it, but she knocked it outta the park. It was nice seeing her with her Dad, who appears to have been a big influence in her life. If you missed it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0okocc12j0

She looked damn fine too!
 
"You Oughta Know" is supposed to be a very angry song and she did not bring the anger two it.

They changed the line "Would she go down on you in a theatre" to "Would she go out with you to a theatre". But for 16 year old Scott, they chose the song "She Believes in Me", a song about a struggling singer returning home to his woman who is already in bed ("and I hold her tight"), although they did not make him sing the verse in which he goes back downstairs to "fumble with a melody or two" and she says "to wake me up when I am through."
 
My thoughts exactly. I'm a huge Zeppelin fan and when Seacrest announced her song, I figured she would slaughter it, but she knocked it outta the park. It was nice seeing her with her Dad, who appears to have been a big influence in her life. If you missed it:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0okocc12j0

She looked damn fine too!

Yeah the Reinharts were just awesome. I think the last song choice was an attempt to sabotage her, but she was so awesome on the chorus that she very well may have foiled them.

Studio version of Haley's Zeppelin song - just kicks ASS!! :

 
Not surprised, but the season is over for me, no interest in anything that happens from this point.
 
I think you guys are thinking too much with your dicks, lmao. All 3 are amazing singers in their own right, anyone could have been sent home, the difference is razor thin in talent. Too bad you have no interest in seeing the final between two country singers, they are unbelievable at the tender ages of 16 and just turned 17. I predict Scotty's career will explode up the country charts anytime soon and will win many, many CMA's, move over Carrie, here comes Scotty. There is a huge country fan base in the US.

Haley won't starve, she'll do just fine, think Adam Lambert, didn't win but way more successful than the winner, actually who the hell did win that year?????
 
I think you guys are thinking too much with your dicks, lmao. All 3 are amazing singers in their own right, anyone could have been sent home, the difference is razor thin in talent. Too bad you have no interest in seeing the final between two country singers, they are unbelievable at the tender ages of 16 and just turned 17. I predict Scotty's career will explode up the country charts anytime soon and will win many, many CMA's, move over Carrie, here comes Scotty. There is a huge country fan base in the US.

Haley won't starve, she'll do just fine, think Adam Lambert, didn't win but way more successful than the winner, actually who the hell did win that year?????

I know that, but I am not a country fan. and since Hayley was the only contestant I was interested in listening to for a while, there is no real reason to watch from here on. It was not just Hayleys looks, although I think she is a hottie. She is a great singer and, frankly, has the coolest personality by far.

Studio version of Hayleys Earth Song below, it is just AWESOME, better then MJ
 
Initially I thought Hayley was just a pretty girl with a great voice and others were coaching her artistry. But the incredible duet of "moanin" with Casey was actully Hayleys idea, and she is really into Jazz..IMHO she is good enough to craft her own genere, I hope I like her first album, 'cos I LOVE her voice.
 
Not surprised, but the season is over for me, no interest in anything that happens from this point.

I agree! From now, I losted my interest.Yes, the other two are great singers too, but the show become "America got country singers" now.It's just boring and lifeless. ( Casey,Pia,Durbin and now Hailey are left?) Yes I'm not a country fan and I never watched the American Country Music Awards
(except the Steven Tyler @ Carrie Underwood duo and that was fantastic) but I like many country song anyway. I just like to get more salt and two different style of singers in the finale.
 
I was also hoping Haley would win, but as others have said, she'll do just fine without the title.
I happen to like country music so now I hope Scotty wins as he really does have chops for it.
As you can clearly see, there are a ton of country fans in the US. If you ever drive around or through the US, just play the radio for a while and flip stations. You'd be amazed at how many country stations there are.
 
My mom watches this program religiously. I checked it out the other day, very interesting, I know that many stars have come from it. I have both of Daughtry's albums and I believe that's where he made his big break didn't he?

Yes Daughtry was voted off i believe in 4th place and has gone on to sell many more records than the ones that continued on to the final.
i'm not even sure anyone can remember who the top 3 were that year lol

I was disappointed to see Haley go. she and James Durbin were my picks. although the most talented are now off the show, i think it shows the strength of this season. i think more will have successful recording careers than any previous season. Pia, Casey, Haley,James, Lauren and Scotty all have a good chance to succeed.


Here is Haley with her goodbye to American Idol and a kick ass version of Benny and the Jets
 
Yes Daughtry was voted off i believe in 4th place and has gone on to sell many more records than the ones that continued on to the final.
i'm not even sure anyone can remember who the top 3 were that year lol

I was disappointed to see Haley go. she and James Durbin were my picks. although the most talented are now off the show, i think it shows the strength of this season. i think more will have successful recording careers than any previous season. Pia, Casey, Haley,James, Lauren and Scotty all have a good chance to succeed.


Here is Haley with her goodbye to American Idol and a kick ass version of Benny and the Jets

It was a real classy departure. She is a pretty cool chick.
 
Does anyone think her singing "Randy and Jlo have you seen them yet.. oh they are so spaced out" was a slam?....I doubt it, but she is a feisty one, which I do love about her.
 
nottyboi, we get it. You think Haley's hot and you'd love to throw it in her ass.

You'd have to be a raving homo to NOT want to do that.. DUH!!! But the fact she is cool and talented makers her 10x hotter.