Years ago when the gun registry was proposed. the Association of Chiefs of Police of Canada was against it. The registry would be a nightmare to administer, it would be very costly and not be effective at all. Every cop would have to call in to see if there is a gun on premises on every occasion. The gun registered at the premises may not be there or the occupant may have moved, or the occupant that registered the gun may not be on premises and another individual may have access to the gun. There may be a gun on premises and not be registered. So the gun registry does not actually tell the police that there is a gun or not on premises. Police have to be alert all the time.
Well if the position of police chiefs and police organizations who are trying to save the lives of fellow officers is of concern to you, you will be happy to note they all support the gun registry. Just Google 'police chiefs support gun registry' and you will find article after article with police organizations across the country are asking not to dismantle it. Sample:
Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police, the Canadian Police Association, the Canadian Association of Police Boards joined to urge the government not to get rid of the tool.
“The knowledge of who possesses firearms helps us to prevent tragic events virtually every day in this country,” said William Blair, Toronto police chief and president of the Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police.
The scenario you describe as ' they must call in to find out if there is a gun registered on the premise' as if they see this as an encumbrance is nuts. That is one of the strengths of the registry they believe saves THEIR lives. If they go to a premises for a domestic dispute, burglary call, etc - they want to know if there is a gun registered in there. Any intelligence about the situation helps them.
I find that the cost of the gun registry is a red herring in that anyone I know complaining about it do not want a gun registry no matter what the cost. That is why they talk about trashing it rather than fixing it.
Odd that we register our cars, we have licenses to determine if we are fit to drive them in the interest of public safety (ditto airplanes, boats), yet a the concept of registering a device intended to kill meets such pigheaded resistance.