The keys to my success on POF were as follows:
1. Make an excellent profile. Have about 600+ words talking about yourself. Say something interesting. Have decent pictures of yourself doing interesting things.
2. Be nice online. Show interest because interested is interesting.
3. Don't take it too seriously. Make it cheap. Trust me, 4 dates a week being going for appetizers or ice cream is pretty cheap. For the cost of one pooning session you can easily go on 8 to 10 dates. Note these are first dates, so it's not too hardcore or anything. If you don't drink that makes it more difficult, but you can go for dinner and a walk. Walking is good as it give you a chance to talk to a person and get to know them a bit.
4. Let them come to you. It's a whole lot easier to be chased than chase. I went for the hotties for awhile and then I got tired of the rejection rates. I then waited until someone attractive looked me up. I then pursued them. Far more effective, but you must have a profile that draws lots of hits and be reasonably attractive to pull this one off. Considering women sent messages to me (about 3 or 4 a week) on a consistent basis, I had a good enough profile for my purposes.
5. Be persistent. Keep on going out on dates. Yeah, I got laid a few times, had a few bj's and so on and met lots of nice interesting women (and a few hotties to boot). However, even when things petered out because she or I lost interest (or I failed to play my cards right... There was this one internet video chat chick who I let get away... Sigh, such stupidity!!!!) I kept going back to the well, because I was confident that there would be more fish next week.
6. Be reasonable. There are some fucking hot women on POF. There used to be a rating system on pics and I'd cruise those now and again. Like I said, some fucking hot women on there. Heck, some of them actually lived close to me. However, the model types won't date me. I'm not a millionaire, I'm not Brad Pitt. However, I'm happy to try my luck with the 7 and 7.5's that I was able to actually go out with and actually got an 7/9/10 on the L/A/S scale for SP services. That's the general view of things in the looks department. For me, she's about a 9 in the looks department but my tastes aren't shared by the majority of men.
..