grammer question

Why not go with "Mating cranes' big flapping wings cast long shadows" - and by the way, "Jabberwocky" is NOT onomatopoeia! It is a poem consisting of PORTMANTEAU words.
 
Personally, I'd go with Mating cranes: big flapping wings casting lost shadows.

I'd drop big because it's in the previous sentence with the evocative big country sky, go with "Mating cranes flapping wings, casting lost shadows."

I'd also shorten and change the next phrase a bit to "Teardrop questions cry in my head, dripping from the watercolours of a mad artist ...

But there's nothing wrong with yours, it reads well.
 
Why not go with "Mating cranes' big flapping wings cast long shadows" - and by the way, "Jabberwocky" is NOT onomatopoeia! It is a poem consisting of PORTMANTEAU words.

You're right...Jabberwocky is not onomatopoeia. I was just correcting his spelling because he spelled it omniopea. lol Not quite sure if they're portmanteau words either though. I thought portmanteau words were words like smog (from smoke and fog) or motel (motor hotel). (?) But I can't remember... I always thought the words in Jabberwocky were totally made up but were given proper grammatical suffixes to make them sound like real words. I know "brillig" means 4 p.m. I remember that from an old final Jeopardy question. lol

I would love to discuss dangling participles and conjugate a few verbs with you any time, MissCroft ! :D

Alright then! :-)


Chloe
 
Mating cranes, big flapping wings cast lost shadows.

Is it a complete sentence? You betcha!

Is it gramatically correct? That is, does it follow the rules for the construction of a sentence? Yup. As has been pointed out, there are many sentences which might exemplify poor grammar but are gramatically correct nonetheless.

In this case, it's a complex sentence, but it's just fine. It's not a sentence I would expect a fifteen-year-old kid to parse particularly well, but that's probably not your audience.

"Mating cranes cast lost shadows." "Big flapping wings cast lost shadows." Your sentence, as I read it, is merely the combination of these two complete thoughts.

The question back to you is more about your audience: will they spend more time than you'd want them to parsing the sentence and getting lost in the nuances it contains? Or do you want to offer them a bit of a challenge? If you're writing for a broad audience you may want to rephrase it.
 
My spelling sucks as well as my grammar sucking.

No worry...not just you. There are lots of guys in this board who made mistakes with "to and too", "their and there", "then and than" ,"hobbyist and hobbiest" and "your and you are".
 
Last edited:
Mating cranes, big flapping wings cast lost shadows.
If the complete thought is that 'the wings of tall birds make long moving shadows when they fuck', then you need to make the phrase "Mating cranes" posessive using an apostrophe. So: Mating cranes', big flapping wings cast lost shadows. The apostrophe comes after the 's' because it's more than one crane who own the wings involved.

If you said the sentence aloud, you wouldn't pause after cranes, so the comma is unecessary. So: Mating cranes' big flapping wings cast lost shadows.
 
I would saw that that sentence conveys the idea that mating cranes AND their big flapping wings cast lost shadoes (or 'mating cranes with their big flapping wings' etc.).
 
Now this is real grammar checking. Not the technobable from before.

Is it a sentence? yes; is it a good one? at first look, no, its awkward - but that seems to be it's purpose.
You may want to use casting, if it doesn't change the meaning you want.

Mating cranes' big flapping wings casting lost shadows. or

Mating cranes. Big flapping wings . Casting lost shadows.
Use three sentence fragments instead? That's real grammar checking.
 
Why not go with "Mating cranes' big flapping wings cast long shadows" - and by the way, "Jabberwocky" is NOT onomatopoeia! It is a poem consisting of PORTMANTEAU words.

Look at the poem

The words are made up yet you still get a distinct feel for what they mean which makes them onomatopoetic IMHO
 
Use three sentence fragments instead? That's real grammar checking.

I agree with North Pole

there are no rules in grammer only suggestions


Each of his suggestions puts a different slant on the meaning
 
the sun shines brightly on my sword
the blood, mine enemies
the vengeance, my own
the bodies, silently await the cranes

"The bodies await the casting of long shadows"

makes it more mysterious and supernatural
 
On the contrary; grammar is all about rules. In communication there are only suggestions.
 
I'd drop big because it's in the previous sentence with the evocative big country sky, go with "Mating cranes flapping wings, casting lost shadows."

I'd also shorten and change the next phrase a bit to "Teardrop questions cry in my head, dripping from the watercolours of a mad artist ...

But there's nothing wrong with yours, it reads well.

Thankyou Brill

I like that idea but I think it should be "tear dropped" not "teardrop" but not sure

But the watercolors are meant to describe the changing scene of the "foreign sky" as atonement nears

"Against the foreign sky watercolors form, pastels of red flamed with purples, blues and yellows, soft as a prayer’s echo; ripped with greens and blacks as hard as diamond as though dripped from the canvas of a mad artist."
 
Last edited: