In all honesty? I may be laughed off the thread for this but size really does not matter, it is all in how you use what you have. There are obviously some exceptions to this rule, but, I have had a range of sizes, from barely 3" hard to almost 12" and truly, they all feel great because the owner knows what to do with what he has. A lot of women love that cervix pounding we get from the really big guys, but for others of us it just plain hurts. The majority of our nerve endings are within 3 " of the opening.
Girth is more important than length in my humble opinion but overall BIG is not necessarily better.