Wrong Thing To Say?

drlove

Ph.D. in Pussyology
Oct 14, 2001
4,895
329
83
The doctor is in
Here's a situation I'd like to run by you:

Back in November, my then girlfriend and I had a fantastic weekend together. It started out a bit shaky, since even though things had been going really well by all accounts after two months of dating (the relationship was really intense) she confessed that she still wasn't 100% sure about us being a long term thing. I was a bit surprised to hear that, but we had a long talk and we both felt better afterwards. Then we had sex and went to sleep.

The next morning, everything was fantastic. She started talking about the great Christmas we were going to have together, I was going to meet her parents, she was making long term plans for us for next summer etc.. Naturally, I assumed that she had resolved any qualms / trepidations she may have had about us as a couple. Then on Sunday, she came over to my place - another great time.

Now, she had just come out of the washroom and was getting ready to leave. While she was putting on her shoes, she touched the wall with her still wet hand, which left a mark / smudge on my wall. I didn't say anything since I didn't want to make a big deal about it, and I figured I'd just wipe it off later. Two things:

1) I had just moved into a brand new condo at the time, and the paint was still fresh and not fully cured yet.

2) The paint happened to be eggshell, which caused the smudge to worsen when I tried to wipe it off. I discovered that the only way to fix it would be to paint over it.

Not wanting to have marks all over my walls every time she came over, I decided to say something. I figured I had a bit of leeway here, since she and I were going to be a long term thing. So, the next evening as we were talking on the phone, I casually and very politely brought up the subject about the wall / paint, explained my reasoning and asked her if she could be mindful of it in the future to prevent a recurrence.

Well, she completely flipped. Apparently she had an ex who used to chastise her about such things, and she subsequently accused me of doing the same, which of course was not my intent at all. She ended up not talking to me for a week because of this, and things just went downhill from there, eventually leading to our break up.

Personally, I think she completely over reacted. To qualify the situation, I should add that she suffers from Borderline Personality Disorder. Not sure if that played a part in her reaction or not. So, I'm just wondering, was that really such a bad thing to say to her? I totally was not expecting her to react the way she did. :confused:

Thoughts?
 
Wrong thing to say. You should have waited until the next moment when she was putting on her shoes and just said, "Oh sorry mind you don't touch the wall, I just painted it". By bringing it up in advance over the phone you made a huge deal out of it. It's pretty normal to touch walls while you are putting on your shoes, after all... how is she supposed to know your paint hasn't cured? It was not even a mistake on her part. It was originally a mistake on YOUR part for not warning her that the wall had been painted recently when she was putting on her shoes, she did a perfectly normal thing.

Was it really such a bad thing to say? No. It was stupid. You shouldn't have said it. But if that by itself is the deal breaker... well then you dodged a bullet because we all say stupid things sometimes and it won't be the last time you do either. HOPEFULLY it will just blow over and you will learn not to make a big deal out of nothing in the future.
 
I was thinking the same thing as Fuji. Mentioning it on the phone makes a bigger deal than it really is. Face to face she can see the smudge and you can likely joke about it. On the phone all she hears is you did this wrong and then reacts.
 
Here's a situation I'd like to run by you:

Back in November, my then girlfriend and I had a fantastic weekend together. It started out a bit shaky, since even though things had been going really well by all accounts after two months of dating (the relationship was really intense) she confessed that she still wasn't 100% sure about us being a long term thing. I was a bit surprised to hear that, but we had a long talk and we both felt better afterwards. Then we had sex and went to sleep.

The next morning, everything was fantastic. She started talking about the great Christmas we were going to have together, I was going to meet her parents, she was making long term plans for us for next summer etc.. Naturally, I assumed that she had resolved any qualms / trepidations she may have had about us as a couple. Then on Sunday, she came over to my place - another great time.

Now, she had just come out of the washroom and was getting ready to leave. While she was putting on her shoes, she touched the wall with her still wet hand, which left a mark / smudge on my wall. I didn't say anything since I didn't want to make a big deal about it, and I figured I'd just wipe it off later. Two things:

1) I had just moved into a brand new condo at the time, and the paint was still fresh and not fully cured yet.

2) The paint happened to be eggshell, which caused the smudge to worsen when I tried to wipe it off. I discovered that the only way to fix it would be to paint over it.

Not wanting to have marks all over my walls every time she came over, I decided to say something. I figured I had a bit of leeway here, since she and I were going to be a long term thing. So, the next evening as we were talking on the phone, I casually and very politely brought up the subject about the wall / paint, explained my reasoning and asked her if she could be mindful of it in the future to prevent a recurrence.

Well, she completely flipped. Apparently she had an ex who used to chastise her about such things, and she subsequently accused me of doing the same, which of course was not my intent at all. She ended up not talking to me for a week because of this, and things just went downhill from there, eventually leading to our break up.

Personally, I think she completely over reacted. To qualify the situation, I should add that she suffers from Borderline Personality Disorder. Not sure if that played a part in her reaction or not. So, I'm just wondering, was that really such a bad thing to say to her? I totally was not expecting her to react the way she did. :confused:

Thoughts?

Wow, I thought I was anal with not wanting perfumes, makeup and strong smells. It's a wall and paint, we touch them all the time. Just like we walk on floors and use sinks and tiolets. We can't keep everything pristine forever. I have eggshell in my bedroom-lots of hand prints from girls. I just see them as fond memories, not imperfections
 
It's probably a good thing she didn't catch you leaving the toilet seat up or skidders in your gitch! Can you imagine the drama!

Who painted your place? they should have left some touch up paint. Even better, washable paint should have been used. Home Depot, Lowe's, Benjamin Moore, Canadian Tire sell it.

Ok, she had BPD and you have OCD! LOL
 
Also, she has Borderline Personality Disorder and you where not expecting her reaction?? You make a big deal over a paint smudge when you know she has unstable emotions?? Seriously!!
 
shit bro, I called a girl a name jokingly and she got mad and didn't talk to me for a week either. Then we started going out again and I txted her/called her too much (only for a day since I was bored) and then she called me clingy and hasn't talked to me since. From what I know... don't try and understand girls. They will fuck with your mind and emotions for fun until you are depressed and end up fucked in the head.
 
Next time she came to your place you should have put her over your knee, lifted her skirt, pulled down her panties and given her a hard spanking.
Then strip off her clothes, give her a can of paint and a brush and have her fix the smudge.
 
Moot question. She got pissed off and you wound up breaking up. So....wrong thing to say.

Unless she's so nuts that you're better off without her, in which case the long view would be that it was the right thing to say.
 
Wrong thing to say. You should have waited until the next moment when she was putting on her shoes and just said, "Oh sorry mind you don't touch the wall, I just painted it". By bringing it up in advance over the phone you made a huge deal out of it. It's pretty normal to touch walls while you are putting on your shoes, after all... how is she supposed to know your paint hasn't cured? It was not even a mistake on her part. It was originally a mistake on YOUR part for not warning her that the wall had been painted recently when she was putting on her shoes, she did a perfectly normal thing.

Was it really such a bad thing to say? No. It was stupid. You shouldn't have said it. But if that by itself is the deal breaker... well then you dodged a bullet because we all say stupid things sometimes and it won't be the last time you do either. HOPEFULLY it will just blow over and you will learn not to make a big deal out of nothing in the future.

Yeah, you're right. In hindsight I should have kept my mouth shut. At the time though, I didn't see it as a big deal. Still, I feel her reaction wasn't warranted e.g. (not speaking to me for a week). That's a bit excessive. Then, she returns and acts like nothing's wrong. She tells me that she "disappeared" for awhile and was talking to one of her exes. I felt as though she was trying to get me going, so naturally I didn't take the bait, which frustrated her. Then, the following week, I was really busy and wasn't able to see her. While I felt bad about that, she was partly to blame since she ignored me the week before when I had all kinds of time and was going to cook her a romantic dinner.

In any case, we had made tentative plans to see one another that friday (last weekend in November) In my mind, we were going out during the evening. However, I got a call from her at noon time telling me to expect her between 1:30 and 2:00 in the afternoon. That caught me by surprise, since I had made plans to pay my mom a visit. I explained this to my girlfriend, who reluctantly agreed to postpone our date until that evening. Not wanting to be a jerk, I compromised a bit more and called her in the late afternoon (between 4:30 and 5:00pm.) I had seven different date ideas lined up, all of which she turned down saying that she was sleepy / tired. I suggested that I could come over to her place and hang out, but no... all I got from her was "No...I'm sleepy... tired" Then to my surprise, she offers to come pick me up after she got ready (I didn't have my car). I said ok, even though I was wondering why she would even bother since she said she was tired. Then 45 minutes later she calls and says she's not coming to pick me up after all since it was raining and dark out. Then she asks if I'd take a $30.00 cab ride out to see her. Normally, had she been more receptive I would have been there in a flash, but judging from her behavior I felt it would just be a waste of time, so I declined. That pretty much torpedoed it since by the following week it was all over.
 
Yes, maybe you said something wrong, but don't talking with you for a week because of it?
If I love someone, it's completely impossible for me. I can be angry max 5 minutes long and after I forget everything.
My smart grandma told me: Never go to sleep without a smile and say some kindly words to your loved one.
I think she watched too much Sex and the City in the past.(As Brian Griffin said from the Family Guy: "You know the show about three whore and their mother":)
Too much ego is never helpful in any relationship.
 
Girls can be messy, that's from my own experience but you can't expect everyone to be clean like you. One day it's hand prints on the wall, the next it's her make up in the bathroom sink. You have accept women they way they are. I am sure you are not perfect yourself however, she did overreacted in this situation and their was nothing wrong with bringing up the subject. The fact she reacted the way she did gives you a warning signs of possible problems down the road.
 
Regarding Iris and Brandon's comments - true. There were some other things that were "off" about her. Like wanting to spend every minute of the waking day with me... I mean literally 24/7. There were times I didn't see home for days - I was either at work, or I was with her. Then she accused me of cheating on her with a blonde woman because of a "dream" she had, refused to wear my bathrobe because "other women have worn it", believed that the general manager and vice president of my condo corporation were hitting on her, became jealous of the fact that I had female friends to the point where she mimicked pouring acid on my LF's head with the use of a teddy bear and an unopened bottle of water, and wanted me to be jealous for no reason (apparently this makes her feel wanted, needed etc..), talked about getting married and having kids a month into the relationship etc.. She reminded me of the girl in the movie "How To Lose A Guy In 10 Days".
 
I don't think you were wrong in what you said but I tend to only discuss stuff that I feel is important in person. I keep the phone stuff to a minimum. I can't stand fighting over the phone and avoid it at all costs.
 
DrLove, one lives and learns.

Very true. As an aside, I made an honest effort to repair the damage and get the relationship back on track. All I got in return from her was childish behavior, and having her accuse me of things that never even happened e.g ( lying about my occupation and investments?!?! - that was a figment of her imagination, but it seemed as though she really believed it!)
 
"she confessed that she still wasn't 100% sure about us being a long term thing" that's womanese for your out. Like all men, you are trying to be logical and justify what was a formality, she's no longer interested in you.

You should of backed off when she told you that and don't give her any satisfaction, but you're a doormat so you tried to hang onto the inevitable, kudos on the pity sex. It doesn't it really matter how she tells you it's over cos it's dead.