Sometimes it works

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
Just wanted to pass along that sometimes these widely disparaged social programs work.

I have a young friend who bounced on and off welfare, and in and out of subsidized (by welfare) housing, which she worked crap jobs and tried to finish her highschool--years after everyone else graduated. Eventually she completed one of those alternative education programs for young adults and did get her highschool diploma.

Then she bounced around on and off welfare a few more times, alternating working as a waitress, and collecting a welfare check, for another year, until some government run youth employment program placed her in a summer job with one of Canada's big corporations. The government paid part of the bill is my understanding.

They liked her, she landed first a part time and then a full time job, and she's just received her third consecutive promotion there in two years. I doubt she'll ever see another welfare check and while she certainly isn't rich she's earning a regular paycheck that is rapidly closing on the Canadian average, she's paid off her debt, and thinking about saving a down payment for a home.
 
Last edited:
That is great for her and I am glad her hard work has payed off. I am curious as to how long it took her to get where she is now from her first time she was on welfare, if you dont mind.
 
That is great for her and I am glad her hard work has payed off. I am curious as to how long it took her to get where she is now from her first time she was on welfare, if you dont mind.

About 2 years. She was on welfare when she got the summer job about 2 years ago. Then she got part time work at that company, and worked part time elsewhere. Then full time at the company doing the same thing. Now promoted twice since that fulltime job. All in about two years.

But certainly the moment her life turned around was when she got that summer job where I gather her salary was paid by some program. I think it was the first time in her life that she had a job that had the potential to be a career, and that's what motivated her to try harder there than I guess she's tried in her dead end jobs she had before that. Who knows.

Even before that, though, another key bit was completing highschool, which she did while on and off welfare through some sort of special program. She couldn't have the job she has now if she hadn't done that.
 
Tell my android phone. Please. You will find idiotic American spelling in a lot of my posts now because my phone only has American words. Fucking Google.

Type it correctly and it asks if you want to save any word it doesn't know (at least my phone does).
 
That is great news Fuji. I note, as I'm sure does everyone else that she worked quite hard to better herself.
 
That is great news Fuji. I note, as I'm sure does everyone else that she worked quite hard to better herself.

She did, once she had the opportunity to do so. Before that I can't say that... she was one of my most reliable party friends, if I ever felt bored and wanted to spend all night in an after hours or doing whatever, she was always game. Now she's always busy with her got-my-shit-together-now life lol. Which of course is much better for her than spending the night in an after hours with me :)

What I can see is that when she wasn't given any opportunities she just slacked off, but when she was finally given a chance to do something she felt would improve her life (and given it by some welfare program really) she jumped on it and worked hard.
 
Most people need to feel valued, and that want they are doing has a "point" especially intelligent people. IMO intelligent people who are down on their luck are in a tough place, they KNOW they can do better, but without motivation and opportunity the just get bummed out depressed and slack off figuring what is the point. Glad she broke the cycle.
 
fuji, I commend your friend for using the system to better herself. Unfortunately, her case isn't the norm within the welfare system. Too many able bodied individuals use it as a handout because they are too damn lazy to get off their butts in the morning.
 
What is welfare in Ontario these days? $500-$600 a month?


fuji, I commend your friend for using the system to better herself. Unfortunately, her case isn't the norm within the welfare system. Too many able bodied individuals use it as a handout because they are too damn lazy to get off their butts in the morning.
 
Some families go through generations on welfare..they see how easy it is to stay home and get paid.

I knew someone that got $1800/month, what I was making at that time working 40 hrs. She ended up starting to work because they were cutting it down. As long as they can free-load they will...why would they work if they didn't have to.

I have another friend that has a pawn shop, they re-new their pawn or pay in full to get it back when they get their cheque...and then in 2 weeks they're back to re-pawn it or to pawn other items.
At home they have dogs, cats, booze, cigarettes, lottery tickets...if they can't afford it why do they have those frivilous things.
 
Great story. Nice to hear a good story about how the system does work ,you only hear the bad side of the system being abused. Good for her. Congrats.
 
Just wanted to pass along that sometimes these widely disparaged social programs work.

I have a young friend who bounced on and off welfare, and in and out of subsidized (by welfare) housing, which she worked crap jobs and tried to finish her highschool--years after everyone else graduated. Eventually she completed one of those alternative education programs for young adults and did get her highschool diploma.

Then she bounced around on and off welfare a few more times, alternating working as a waitress, and collecting a welfare check, for another year, until some government run youth employment program placed her in a summer job with one of Canada's big corporations. The government paid part of the bill is my understanding.

They liked her, she landed first a part time and then a full time job, and she's just received her third consecutive promotion there in two years. I doubt she'll ever see another welfare check and while she certainly isn't rich she's earning a regular paycheck that is rapidly closing on the Canadian average, she's paid off her debt, and thinking about saving a down payment for a home.

Nice story and very good for her. Kudos.

How many welfare recipients don't make it though?
 
Nice story and very good for her. Kudos.

How many welfare recipients don't make it though?

How many have their situation made worse.
 
And....

She bought a condo. Tiny. Not the greatest location. But it's what she can afford. So now from subsidized housing and welfare to homeowner. It really does work sometimes.
 
And....

She bought a condo. Tiny. Not the greatest location. But it's what she can afford. So now from subsidized housing and welfare to homeowner. It really does work sometimes.

I think everybody knows that "sometimes" welfare programs work.

But the real question is does it work often enough to justify the expense.
 
I think everybody knows that "sometimes" welfare programs work.

But the real question is does it work often enough to justify the expense.

Well, if you look at the research instead of going with soundbites and anecdotes from the conservatives, it seems to work most of the time. Most people who spend some time on welfare during their lives don't spend very much time on it (in the U.S., the average was 2 years, before Clinton's welfare reform introduced lifetime limits).
 
Well, if you look at the research instead of going with soundbites and anecdotes from the conservatives, it seems to work most of the time. Most people who spend some time on welfare during their lives don't spend very much time on it (in the U.S., the average was 2 years, before Clinton's welfare reform introduced lifetime limits).

Do you think we see similar results in Canada?