Car Accident Advice

Ontario is a no fault province, the insurance company cares a) if you had an accident b) were convicted
Both will raise your rates

Not quite.

The insurance companies talk it out and assign blame.

If you got rear ended, you are 100% free and clear and your rates will not go up. (Ask me how I know.)
 
Not quite.

The insurance companies talk it out and assign blame.

If you got rear ended, you are 100% free and clear and your rates will not go up. (Ask me how I know.)


How do you know?
Please tell me.
 
Not quite.

The insurance companies talk it out and assign blame.

If you got rear ended, you are 100% free and clear and your rates will not go up. (Ask me how I know.)

this is correct. rear end collisions are considered at fault from the driver that hits the car in front.

take it through insurance. file a police report and tell them you were rear ended. the police will take pics and investigate the other driver.

your insurance company will ask you to take your car to an appraiser. the appraiser will send the report to your insurance company. your insurance company will then investigate it with the other drivers insurance company.

if the other driver has valid insurance you can get your car fixed and YOU WON'T TO PAY THE DEDUCTIBLE since the accident will be deemed at fault against the other driver.

the accident will not go against your record since the rear ender was deemed at fault.

the only way your insurance company can invoke the no fault portion is if the other driver doesn't have valid insurance.

make sure you get clearance from your insurance company before you get your car fixed an make sure you don't have to pay the deductible. once they say you don't have to pay the deductible, then the insurance company would have checked and validated your claim.

make sure you file a police report to validate your claim with the insurance company because they'll want the police report number when you put in the claim.
 
Despite the good intentions of many of the posters here there is a lot of poor information and a lot of good information.

Let me tell you how I know. I have been practising this area of law for almost 20 years.

"No fault" only means that you are entitled to certain benefits if you are injured, no matter who is at fault.

"No fault" has never impacted how we deal with property damage claims in any significant way.

Read the regulation I posted above.

If there is a collision, the insurers involved go to the fault determination charts listed in the reg I posted above to figure out who was at fault.

In this case the accident would be attributed 100% to the driver behind and 0% to the driver in front. The driver in front, is therefore entitled to have his damages paid for by his own insurer, without any change in his rating.

Next we will discuss loss transfer...
 
^^^ What about "Diminished Value"

My car was sidesswiped while parked on the street as I was spending the night at my then GF's house.

I was assigned 0 responsibility, my car was repaired. The damage was a scrapped fender and a creased rear door. They put an entirely new factory door on the car. (The body shop went to bat for me.) But if I go to sell the car, it will be viewed by the buying public as "damaged goods" if the accident is revealed. (I'm not sure if the used car kit reveals accidents.)

The damage was minor, a new factory rear door was installed, but the fact is - the car's value is diminished.
 
^^^ What about "Diminished Value"

My car was sidesswiped while parked on the street as I was spending the night at my then GF's house.

I was assigned 0 responsibility, my car was repaired. The damage was a scrapped fender and a creased rear door. They put an entirely new factory door on the car. (The body shop went to bat for me.) But if I go to sell the car, it will be viewed by the buying public as "damaged goods" if the accident is revealed. (I'm not sure if the used car kit reveals accidents.)

The damage was minor, a new factory rear door was installed, but the fact is - the car's value is diminished.

Based on the way the product is currently designed you are SOL.
 
Absolutely right

This is abslutely right. If some one doesn't want you to go through insurance because it will add an at fault accident to their record and wants to pay cash. Don't do it. Report the claim to police and your insurer.

There is a section of your policy that is normally not subject to deductible and will not be held against you in your rating.

"No fault" means that your insurer deals with your repairs no matter who's at fault. Responsability for the claim will still matter in your rating


this is correct. rear end collisions are considered at fault from the driver that hits the car in front.

take it through insurance. file a police report and tell them you were rear ended. the police will take pics and investigate the other driver.

your insurance company will ask you to take your car to an appraiser. the appraiser will send the report to your insurance company. your insurance company will then investigate it with the other drivers insurance company.

if the other driver has valid insurance you can get your car fixed and YOU WON'T TO PAY THE DEDUCTIBLE since the accident will be deemed at fault against the other driver.

the accident will not go against your record since the rear ender was deemed at fault.

the only way your insurance company can invoke the no fault portion is if the other driver doesn't have valid insurance.

make sure you get clearance from your insurance company before you get your car fixed an make sure you don't have to pay the deductible. once they say you don't have to pay the deductible, then the insurance company would have checked and validated your claim.

make sure you file a police report to validate your claim with the insurance company because they'll want the police report number when you put in the claim.
 
Diminished Value is a fact of life. However, again, given the many, many times I've been rear-ended and hit in a lot, here is what I know.

how the fuck are you parking that you get hit so much? I have never been hit in over forty years of driving. do you park like a slut?
 
Cassidy,

If you weren't at fault as you claim, your rates will not go up.

You can call anonymously and find out for yourself. Just take it through insurance and that Bimbo's rates will rise.

You were nice enough to help her out, and she fucked you over ( well actually herself , and you with the hassle).
 
It is covered at an additional price in some places in North america. But the insurance product in Ontario is already the most generous and most expensive
 
I'll say this again: despite the fact it's not your fault, I would do your best to NOT report this to your insurance company. Doing so will make it very expensive - or impossible - to switch insurers in the future.
 
Double bullshit. I've had no fault accidents - been rear ended and 100% not at fault - and while my rates didn't increase it's basically impossible to get insurance quotes. When you call for a quote one of the first questions you're asked is 'any accidents in the past x years?'. I say 'yes but I was 100% not at fault'. The response is either flat out 'we can't insure you' (e.g State Farm) or an astronomical quote.

The question is "Any At Fault Accidents" and your answer would then be "NO".

Regardless of how you are asked, youre answer is "No At Fault Accidents".
 
The only thing here which I believe has not been mentioned is you are supposed to report accidents above a certain $ threashold to an accident reporting centre within 24 hrs. Not sure how the insurance companies deal with claims that come much later that were not reported? I think the issue then becomes her story vs yours and no police report to verify. Can any insurance people on here comment?
 
I know a person that got rear ended 3 times within two years, zero fault assigned to her each time, didn't have to pay deductible and premiums did not rise. However, at policy renewal time her insurer dropped her. No other speeding or accident issues.
 
I know a person that got rear ended 3 times within two years, zero fault assigned to her each time, didn't have to pay deductible and premiums did not rise. However, at policy renewal time her insurer dropped her. No other speeding or accident issues.

As much as I enjoy ancedotal evidence, Ontario's current consumer protection and insurance legislation do not allow this. Is this an old event?
 
take it through insurance. file a police report and tell them you were rear ended. the police will take pics and investigate the other driver.
You might wish to check this with someone such as RLD. Where I am police will not investigate so called "stale collisions".
 
This makes sense. In the United States, insurance companies pay cash directly to the insured so that they can fix their car if they want. If they can live with the damage, then they can pocket the cash.

What happens is that some people get into accidents on purpose. Knowing that anyone who rear ends you is at fault, some people will slam on the brakes, claiming some excuse. Then they either settle with the person who rear ended them, or collect from their insurance company.

Insurance companies therefore keep a track of the frequencies of accidents. Being rear ended three times in a row is a sure sign that something might be wrong (though it could be a fluke).

I know a person that got rear ended 3 times within two years, zero fault assigned to her each time, didn't have to pay deductible and premiums did not rise. However, at policy renewal time her insurer dropped her. No other speeding or accident issues.
 
The question is "Any At Fault Accidents" and your answer would then be "NO".

Regardless of how you are asked, youre answer is "No At Fault Accidents".

Actually the question I am always asked is "any claims in the past x years". My response is yes, but I had no fault in any of the claims. The result is an insane premium or outright refusal. They don't care if it was my fault or not. The issue is that I have made a claim, any claim.