5 drinks in a sitting is binge drinking?

You guys seem to think this is a moral judgment....it's a medical opinion or review.

So if you can find better science that says it's not "binge drinking"...more power to you.


Yeah. I think the real point is that the doctors are saying that having 5 drinks in two hours can be risky.
 
this is typical alcoholics anon bs. an arbitrary number of drinks over an unknown time period with an unspecified frequency is binge drinking! really. the word binge is being mis-used. too much over too short a time. wow. scientific. i coulda told them that. for free.
 
Yeah. I think the real point is that the doctors are saying that having 5 drinks in two hours can be risky.

I think that's the real point right there-- "Regularly drinking 5+ drinks in two hours can impact brain development in youth and teens, and can have negative heath consequences in adults". That is fair, and far less sensational. Coming up with a 'scientific definition' of 'binge drinking' that isn't based on the onset of the traditional symptoms of a binge, as based on weight AND gender, is daft and just gives 'The Sun' fodder. (Hint, any definition of 'Binge' that isn't in table form is daft.)

As far as the person that said, "They're coming for our fast food next!". THEY SHOULD! Canada tried willpower. It didn't work. We're proudly very slightly less fat than Americans. Go Canada! The cost of diabetes, joint replacements, heart attack and stroke, and a long list of other things is set to explode. There's a whole web of sensible policy that could be lifted from continental Western Europe and the Scandinavian countries, and tailored to Canada-- There really needs to be changes at primary and secondary schools, in grocery and convenience stores, and at any 'chain' establishment that serves food and drink. No silver bullet, but a web of policy.

I think that's the contrast-- One is a far wiser and more cost effective use of scarce resources that far better seves the public good. The other is not. Figure out which is which.
 
Its difficult to look at alcohol consumption objectively. Whenever a researcher makes recommendations or classifications relating to alcohol consumption people react defensively. People feel like they are being judged and react swiftly with how good they are when they drink. It seems like a sore spot to me, otherwise why would be care what the research said?
I think its a very interesting point how common and accepted alcohol consumption is in society. Why do we feel the need/want to consume so much alcohol each weekend? Many posters here said that they don't need alcohol to have fun, hey just have one to be sociable. If someone says they don't get drunk when they go out drinking, are safe to drive home and doesn't hurt anyone then why drink alcohol at all? Why not water or soda? Its not to save money or savour the taste.

Its become a social crutch. If you disagree try to go 2 weeks without a drink. I tried it once. It was surprisingly difficult to do for so many reasons and it made me think about why I drank. I still drink today. I really enjoy my wine, and can drink a bottle in one night if I wanted to no problem. There's no judgement here, but think about why you're drinking and if you could stop tomorrow. You might be surprised by your reaction.

Another important point to consider is that since binge drinking is so common among youth, our health care system is going to have to deal with a lot of alcohol related health issues. And that affects all Canadians, just like the diabetes situation now.
 
Its difficult to look at alcohol consumption objectively. Whenever a researcher makes recommendations or classifications relating to alcohol consumption people react defensively. People feel like they are being judged and react swiftly with how good they are when they drink. It seems like a sore spot to me, otherwise why would be care what the research said?

True. Beyond a doubt true.

But, this is labelling that is designed to 'Grab a headline' more than and objective system based on weight and gender, that provides us with a pretty little table. 'Regular consumption of 5 or more drinks in teenagers considered harmful' is both not sensational and less of an abuse of the English language.

Its become a social crutch. If you disagree try to go 2 weeks without a drink.

I'm on day 21, but the math is easy at this time of year. :) Not planning on day 22 if I can help it. It's Friday!!! That's not exactly an irregular gap for me. Oh, and yes it is a social crutch, but is that so bad as long as you don't need alcohol to function in all / most / many social situations (or in general)? As I rule I don't drink to get sober, and I don't apologize when I get drunk.

Another important point to consider is that since binge drinking is so common among youth, our health care system is going to have to deal with a lot of alcohol related health issues. And that affects all Canadians, just like the diabetes situation now.

Yes. It's true, and it's not that public education on the issue is a bad thing, but there is a laundry list of things that are bigger and / or dramatically growing problems. (Obesity is the one that is massive and glaring, but there is a short laundry list of public health / social issues issues that are 'bigger' problems.) Personally I have a strong dislike of using sensationalism to skew public debate.
 
It wouldn't surprise me to find that this study was funded by MADD. I agree that drinking and driving should not be tolerated but these lunatics want everyone to stop drinking, period.

Majority of people going to bars and drinking their faces off are so much healthier these days due to the simple fact there's no more second hand smoke.

What, no comment from Al Cohol? I figured he'd be all over this thread!

24 beers in a case... 24 hours in a day... Coincidence? I don't think so!
 
It wouldn't surprise me to find that this study was funded by MADD. I agree that drinking and driving should not be tolerated but these lunatics want everyone to stop drinking, period.

The issue with MADD, and every other 'single issue' organization where the leadership draws an income is that they just can't 'declare victory and go home'. They'd be jobless. So it has to be ever onward until the funding dries up.
 
I think its a very interesting point how common and accepted alcohol consumption is in society. Why do we feel the need/want to consume so much alcohol each weekend? Many posters here said that they don't need alcohol to have fun, hey just have one to be sociable. If someone says they don't get drunk when they go out drinking, are safe to drive home and doesn't hurt anyone then why drink alcohol at all? Why not water or soda? Its not to save money or savour the taste.

Kelli, that's you.

I have gone months without drinking and found it very easy to do and I don't need to drink to socialise, but that's me.

Why do people drink? Probably for the same reasons why they have sex, because it makes them feel good. Also, suggesting that someone drinks pop is bad, that stuff will kill you too. The chances of type 2 diabetes is increased by a bad diet and pop can contribute to that.

When I choose not to drink, I have water and I'm fine with it, but as I said, "That's me."
 
Its difficult to look at alcohol consumption objectively. Whenever a researcher makes recommendations or classifications relating to alcohol consumption people react defensively. People feel like they are being judged and react swiftly with how good they are when they drink. It seems like a sore spot to me, otherwise why would be care what the research said?

Perhaps people still remember the nonsense called prohibition in the 1920s and the unintended consequences (Al Capone, anybody?).

For generations those do-good er are bunches of funny people who never fail to make the situation much worse.

I think its a very interesting point how common and accepted alcohol consumption is in society. Why do we feel the need/want to consume so much alcohol each weekend? Many posters here said that they don't need alcohol to have fun, hey just have one to be sociable. If someone says they don't get drunk when they go out drinking, are safe to drive home and doesn't hurt anyone then why drink alcohol at all? Why not water or soda? Its not to save money or savour the taste.

Either one is fine, as long as it's in moderation. Too much of a good thing will backfire in the long run.

Having said that, as mentioned before, globally people are getting contagion called "American disease", aka overeating and overconsumption for the sake of it.

Its become a social crutch. If you disagree try to go 2 weeks without a drink. I tried it once. It was surprisingly difficult to do for so many reasons and it made me think about why I drank. I still drink today. I really enjoy my wine, and can drink a bottle in one night if I wanted to no problem. There's no judgement here, but think about why you're drinking and if you could stop tomorrow. You might be surprised by your reaction.

LOL, I drink moderately, below the low-risk limit for my health.

Plus, as usual quality is always the priority, not quantity.

Another important point to consider is that since binge drinking is so common among youth, our health care system is going to have to deal with a lot of alcohol related health issues. And that affects all Canadians, just like the diabetes situation now.

You could always hedge by punting your money in DEO, PM and NVO. :)
 
Perhaps people still remember the nonsense called prohibition in the 1920s and the unintended consequences (Al Capone, anybody?).

For generations those do-good er are bunches of funny people who never fail to make the situation much worse.



Either one is fine, as long as it's in moderation. Too much of a good thing will backfire in the long run.

Having said that, as mentioned before, globally people are getting contagion called "American disease", aka overeating and overconsumption for the sake of it.



LOL, I drink moderately, below the low-risk limit for my health.

Plus, as usual quality is always the priority, not quantity.



You could always hedge by punting your money in DEO, PM and NVO. :)

I agree that prohibition was complete and utter nonsense. People should have the right to choose if they want to consume alcohol or not. I'm not against alcohol consumption. My point is that a little self-analysis concerning your vice can be very beneficial. Moderation is important, whether its food, drink, etc...
Cheers!
 
Also, suggesting that someone drinks pop is bad, that stuff will kill you too. The chances of type 2 diabetes is increased by a bad diet and pop can contribute to that.

When I choose not to drink, I have water and I'm fine with it, but as I said, "That's me."

I should have been clearer and said diet soda.