RCMP assault - charges recommended - Video...

its only 1 kick, its not like they went all Rodney King on his ass.
 
This meathead.

Only one officer in this video is accused of inappropriate contact.
 
Do we know what happened before hand? I rather doubt that after a routine and calm traffic stop the Constable sudenly "lost it" and threw the person he was arresting to the ground and kicked him in the head. That is the problem with videos such as this, they capture a moment in time without context.

I'm not saying the person should have been kicked in the head, I am saying that charges rather than internal discipline may well be an over reaction.
 
I don't what it is with he water out there, but there are 4 separate investigations regarding the RCMP out west, including three murders. The Crown department that onvestigates the incident is also under scutiny. This is not news though. Just another gotcha thread form Nuttyboi. At least when he's on the internet trolling for gotcha's like this, he's not in the streets causing shit.
 
Do we know what happened before hand? I rather doubt that after a routine and calm traffic stop the Constable sudenly "lost it" and threw the person he was arresting to the ground and kicked him in the head. That is the problem with videos such as this, they capture a moment in time without context.

I'm not saying the person should have been kicked in the head, I am saying that charges rather than internal discipline may well be an over reaction.

Not surprised to see some looking for a way to excuse this type of nonsense.
Before videos these actions were even more common and the cops ALWAYS looked the other way. It's about time the bad apples are finally getting nailed.
 
It's about time the bad apples are finally getting nailed.
Yes indeed they should, but is there a discipline scale or does everything beyond the slightest infraction of the rules no matter how provoked result in criminal charges? And as I already said what was the background was there provocation or not, certainly that should make a difference.
 
Do we know what happened before hand? I rather doubt that after a routine and calm traffic stop the Constable sudenly "lost it" and threw the person he was arresting to the ground and kicked him in the head. That is the problem with videos such as this, they capture a moment in time without context.

I'm not saying the person should have been kicked in the head, I am saying that charges rather than internal discipline may well be an over reaction.

Why does it matter what happened beforehand? The suspect was complying with the officers orders. How do you justify the kick? The story is out, there the suspect was dissharging his shotgun at a golf course to scare away geese... (part of his job). And the this RCMP officer went all Robocop on him. No need for police officers like this. He should also be forced to fully reimburse the BC medical system for any medical treatment out of his own pay.
 
This meathead.

Only one officer in this video is accused of inappropriate contact.

I think there problems go a lot deeper. Firstly there have been many incidents like this, secondly, WHY are the police STILL persisting with obviously FALSE charges against this guy... it is FUCKING ABSURD!!! Kelowna had a big rally (well by Kelowna standards) today in support of Buddy Tavares the victim. I say BRAVO KELWONA and SHAME ON THE RC effin MP.
 
Why does it matter what happened beforehand? The suspect was complying with the officers orders.
That goes to exactly the sort of thing I was writing of. So the subject was being compliant and friendly and indeed the Constable did sudenly "loose it."

The above does indeed go towards why charges would be justified.

What basicly I'm saying is that the totality of the evidence needs to be looked at, not merely a video which may or may not give the "whole story."
 
I don't what it is with he water out there, but there are 4 separate investigations regarding the RCMP out west, including three murders. The Crown department that onvestigates the incident is also under scutiny. This is not news though. Just another gotcha thread form Nuttyboi. At least when he's on the internet trolling for gotcha's like this, he's not in the streets causing shit.


Not news? Both the Globe and Star have it on their front pages... so I guess you no claim to know more about what is news then the two largest newspapers in Canada..lol.. I suppose when there is video of a cop kicking a man in his face while he is on his knees, even a cop lover like Blackrock cannot find a way to defend that other then attack the messenger.
 
What basicly I'm saying is that the totality of the evidence needs to be looked at, not merely a video which may or may not give the "whole story."

There is no previous story which would justify a police officer giving a kick to the head of someone complying. Police officers are not given free reign to assault someone who insulted them, hit them or threatened them. They are paid to act in a professional manner, not to hand out beatings to those they deem 'bad'. They must stay within the law.

It will be interesting to see what happens with this investigation, the RCMP has a history of letting their own off lately, but this one will be tough to get away with.
 
Give me one scenario that could have justified these actions? Here's a news flash for ya, you have no moral compass.

b d


Do we know what happened before hand? I rather doubt that after a routine and calm traffic stop the Constable sudenly "lost it" and threw the person he was arresting to the ground and kicked him in the head. That is the problem with videos such as this, they capture a moment in time without context.

I'm not saying the person should have been kicked in the head, I am saying that charges rather than internal discipline may well be an over reaction.
 
Not news? Both the Globe and Star have it on their front pages... so I guess you no claim to know more about what is news then the two largest newspapers in Canada..lol.. I suppose when there is video of a cop kicking a man in his face while he is on his knees, even a cop lover like Blackrock cannot find a way to defend that other then attack the messenger.

Again you're inability to understand english is highlighted. I'm not talking about this particular story, but rather the type of story. The particular story has been on around for a couple of days and in the 24 hr news cycle that's getting old and on both counts, it's not new or news. Ever heard of a slow news day.

It's just the attention this post gets you, that you're really interested in, since you didn't seem to be too upset about the RCMP officers who killed two people in BC and are under investigation.

At no time in my previous point did I defend him and you make it so easy for a number of members to point out you're full of it so often when you make it so obvious, almost daily.
 
Give me one scenario that could have justified these actions? Here's a news flash for ya, you have no moral compass. b d
LHOL, that’s nice to know. There will be a great many people truly shocked to learn this news flash of yours.

However as to your question there are several issues involved here 1) the moral (you might say, as you do that this is never justified) others might say not so fast 2) the legal a) was the action legally justified b) should the action result in criminal charges or instead in internal discipline.

In this instance from the additional information provided by Nottiboi it would seem that it was unjustified. However, we might have had the issue of resistance and what force is justified by it, further, what if the suspect had just driven through a town at 200 km/h and had stuck and killed two children, it might not be legal to kick the suspect in the head, but we might understand why the constable did it (and then we go back to 2) I hope you enjoy your world of black and white, if is much harder for those of us who deal daily with many, many shades of Grey.

As I've mentioned by now several times the issue I thought I was originally addressing is that video clips taken in isolation without knowlege of the surounding events are a fools paradise, unless you wish to live in a black and white world of half truths.
 
There is no previous story which would justify a police officer giving a kick to the head of someone complying. Police officers are not given free reign to assault someone who insulted them, hit them or threatened them. They are paid to act in a professional manner, not to hand out beatings to those they deem 'bad'. They must stay within the law.
Hmm, that seemingly does go to exactly what I wrote in the first two lines

"That goes to exactly the sort of thing I was writing of. So the subject was being compliant and friendly and indeed the Constable did sudenly "loose it."

The above does indeed go towards why charges would be justified.
"



The third line goes to posting video clips rather than reporting the story as it is known - like it or not video can lie and least when it comes to the whole story.