eBay question

Cobster

New member
Apr 29, 2002
10,420
0
0
I won an bid on something and my buying records is perfect and the seller's is 100% perfect with 33 transactions.

He called me today asking that I give him a positive review immediately once he gives me the tracking number of the package. He said he needs 100 positive reviews in order for eBay to release his funds.

This is the first time I've ever heard of eBay withholding funds from someone with a condition like this. Has anyone ever heard of this?

Now I'm worried that if I don't go along with this, he'll either damage the goods, or do something else. Not sure what to do here. Was thinking of contacting eBay and making a case (or opening one as a precursor to any potential problems.

Fuckin' redneck eBayer giving me trouble. lol

He said I have his word, but ya right, come on now.
 
I can't imagine ebay holding the funds until he receives 100 feed backs.they may hold the funds for a given time but not indefinitely.
I would not leave feedback until you receive the item
 
tell him when you get your shit in good order you will give him the pos feedback. that is the way things work.
 
I think he is full of crap.

I would contact ebay, and report the seller. Have you paid for the item already ?

I wouldn't give him positive feedback. The only time you do so is when you receive the item and if it is in good order then you give him feedback.. If not I would give him the negative feedback and report the seller. Pay with paypal and make sure it it paid with a CC, as you can always reverse the charges with the CC company rather than paypal..
 
Rub, I was thinking more like an empty box. lol

Apparently it's a PayPal thing.

As one guy said in this forum "low feedback and high dollar amounts seem to be the reasons"
http://www.diymobileaudio.com/forum...nds-now-time-drop-credit-card-info-folks.html

http://timheuer.com/blog/archive/2009/01/09/paypal-screws-sellers-by-holding-payments.aspx

Pretty stupid practice in a way, but I suppose I understand why they do it.
What I don't like is the pressure from this guy that he needs the funds released badly, wtf? It's a couple of hundred dollars dude, get a job? Sell your wife?


Thanks for your input guys.
 
Giving a positive review before you receive the goods is sort of like paying a SP $200 before she even takes off her clothes.
No guy is that stupid is he? LOL
 
EBay does not do that.
Sometimes PayPal holds funds until they can be verified by a bank but it has nothing to do with reviews.
Methinks your dealer is full of crap and has ulterior motives.
 
I do a lot of buying on Ebay. Personally, his request is alarming. I don't even care if his Ebay story is true (doubtful).

Once I receive the product I provide the feedback.

Right now I am being gouged on shipping by a large Ebay seller. He has provided my feedback but is concern he is going to get bad feedback from me and would like to cancel the transaction. Feedback is what little hammer the buyer has so don't give it up.
 
EBay does not do that.
Sometimes PayPal holds funds until they can be verified by a bank but it has nothing to do with reviews.
Methinks your dealer is full of crap and has ulterior motives.

lol Northern, agreed.

DJ, that's why I told him to ship the goods to a friend's place overnight (he's paying the extra shipping).
My friend will open the package and if it's all good, told him I'd drop him the review, rather than having to wait 4 days (regular shipping).

We'll see how it goes down. Hopefully well. lol
 
EBay does not do that.
Sometimes PayPal holds funds until they can be verified by a bank but it has nothing to do with reviews.
Methinks your dealer is full of crap and has ulterior motives.
Agree 100%. EBay does not control the Pay-pal funds and thus cannot withhold them.
 
I meant to say PayPal, not eBay, I figured since eBay owns PayPal it's synonymous. :P lol
 
Giving a positive review before you receive the goods is sort of like paying a SP $200 before she even takes off her clothes.
No guy is that stupid is he? LOL

Umm isn't it how you are supposed to pay an SP?
 
put it in terms that would work here. sp asks you to write a review about her that is awesome before you even touch her. then if the service is shit you are not allowed to change the review.
 
Umm isn't it how you are supposed to pay an SP?

Yeah, and you're supposed to pay on ebay before they ship too. I think a better analogy would be reviewing an SP before she takes her clothes off.

Wait that's not even an analogy, that would be the same dumb thing.

DON'T DO IT!
 
review his call to you on EBAY

after all you are just being honest
 
Well, let us know if the item ever comes, and in good shape.
You've been more accommodating than I would have been.

If he needs the money that badly, he should have listed earlier.

That second link you posted suggests that paypal may actually be doing weird shit like this.

Something about him set off a red flag.

33 legitimate feedbacks is just about the point where scammers like to be, before starting in on few big money scams on a number of people simultaneously, then clean out their own paypal balance account, and close their Paypal linked bank account, and disappear to start again later. Maybe Paypal has learned to recognize these patterns after a while.

You sent the money, paypal is waiting to see if the transaction is satisfactory, which will be immediately after you get, and inspect the item. Assuming the item is okay, he'll get the money released in a few days.

What's the problem?

If the item never comes, paypal will refund the money to you. Impossible if he's a fly-by-nighter who subsequently cleans out his paypal account and shuts down his bank account.

As a buyer, you are totally protected under normal circumstances.

He's a new seller in all likelihood. If he's honest, let him pay his dues, or get out of the game.
 
Absolutely!

Sounds like the guy may be setting you up for sending you a box of bricks and then using your positive feedback to prove you got the goods in good order.

And like the other guy said, pay with your credit card through a PayPal account. Double payment protection plus the eBay guarantee.

Get ready to take a pic of your item when it arrives and e-mail it to him and yourself and eBay and Paypal if it is NOT what it was supposed to be.


What i'm the "Other guy" lol... loll
 
Thankfully everything went down smoothly. Got the item and it's "new" as promised.
I still don't like what PayPal is doing but I suppose it's to protect the buyer (and themselves, from having to deal with getting money back).
 
Thankfully everything went down smoothly. Got the item and it's "new" as promised.
I still don't like what PayPal is doing but I suppose it's to protect the buyer (and themselves, from having to deal with getting money back).

If it all worked out I hope you leave him a good review with a nice comment like "Good seller, fast service, item just as promised". Sounds like he's starting out and could use your feedback.

Still was the right thing to hold it off, but since he delivered, give him a big thumbs up.