Why no inflation when ....

Yoga Face

New member
Jun 30, 2009
6,307
19
0
If the government prints money is means new money is chasing the same amount of goods hence the prices go up

If it borrows from the banks no new money has been created as American dollars are just changing hands so no inflation

But when it borrows from another country that brings in new money which should cause inflation correct ?

the USA has borrowed trillions from China so why no inflation ?
 
If the government prints money is means new money is chasing the same amount of goods hence the prices go up

If it borrows from the banks no new money has been created as American dollars are just changing hands so no inflation

But when it borrows from another country that brings in new money which should cause inflation correct ?

the USA has borrowed trillions from China so why no inflation ?

Way more complicated than that...but one of the reasons that massive US borrowing has not fueled inflation is that there is also massive demand for the US dollar in other countries.
 
Way more complicated than that...but one of the reasons that massive US borrowing has not fueled inflation is that there is also massive demand for the US dollar in other countries.

But conceptually I am correct no?

If a government borrows from within its own country there is no inflation becuase no new money has been intoduced but but when it borrows from another country that is the same as printing money as new money has been introduced

If so why does it not the Fed just print money instead of borrowing from China ?

IE borrow form itself
 
Government borrowing money means cash is taken out of the system and replaced with a bond. That reduces the amount of cash in circulation. Whether the borrower is China or an American citizen the result is that there are fewer American dollars in circulation after the government borrowing is conducted.
 
Government borrowing money means cash is taken out of the system and replaced with a bond. That reduces the amount of cash in circulation. Whether the borrower is China or an American citizen the result is that there are fewer American dollars in circulation after the government borrowing is conducted.



???????????? I think you read my question wrong

If the USA borrows from China (it does not borrow Yen but credit)

Credit from outside ones own country has the same effect as more money in the system does it not ? as there is now more purchasing power in the USA but the same amount of goods so they should have inflation


So why does not the Fed just make up its own credit ? as the inflationary pressures would be equal as if they borrowed from China

If they want to ease this infationary pressure in the future they can take the credit out of the system via taxes

the key here is they would not have to pay interest if they borrow from themselves


I must be wrong on this or they would do it

I just wonder where my logic fails

this would devalue the dollar but that is OK because thier goods become cheaper
 
Last edited:
If the government prints money is means new money is chasing the same amount of goods hence the prices go up

If it borrows from the banks no new money has been created as American dollars are just changing hands so no inflation

But when it borrows from another country that brings in new money which should cause inflation correct ?

the USA has borrowed trillions from China so why no inflation ?

Actually inflation is roaring in China because that's where the dollars are ending up. On a broader level though, professional economists can correct me but here goes: inflation is only one part of the story.

Basically by starting Quantitative Easing 2 (QE2), the american government has started the printing press to buy it's own bonds. The Tbill auctions leading up to QE2 were poorly received thus requiring QE2. Nobody knows what the balance sheet of the Fed looks like so nobody really knows how deep in the hole the US has fallen.

What this means is there is more US dollars floating in the global financial system. We haven't seen it yet but China has. It means that the US dollar is going to be worth less, over the next few years, as they struggle to support their expenditures.

So what China is doing now is using their store of US dollars to buy hard assets - i.e. base metals, coal, oil, agricultural land - everything that they need. That way they don't have to give a damn where the US dollar goes since they already have all they need on hand. By that time, inflation would have been unleashed on a global scale already.
 
Also, don't forgt the long-term deflationary effect of productivity growth. As productivity increases, the result is greater SUPPLY of goods and services for a given amount of inputs, which is going to all else being equal goingto push down inflation. Emerging economies worldwide are seeing strong productivity growth, which has helped to push down the cost of everything they produce.
 
Macro-economics is really confusing, in part because it happens on such a vast scale that micro-economics seems not to apply. For you or me, on a micro-economic scale, continually borrowing money would not be an option, because the bank would cut us off.

This doesn't apply to the U.S. China wants to sell goods to the U.S., and to do so prices it prices its exports low. In practice, a country can't control all of its exporters, and order them to make the exports cheap. What a country can do, is control its currency. A low currency means that everyone will want to purchase your exports. China prices its currency low, and the government stashes away sackfuls of U.S. dollars. This is a deliberate strategy: The only way to get a low currency is for the government to buy and keep a foreign currency (US $), and print an excess amount of your own currency (Chinese Yuan).

For the U.S., this creates a problem. On a sufficiently large scale, there is not enough money in its own economy. The U.S. needs more money in its economy because its currency is simply flowing out to other people/places/countries which are hoarding it. The solution is to either borrow money, or print money. The U.S. borrows money through T-Bills, and prints money through Quantitative Easing. Normally, this should cause inflation. Also, for most people and countries, it should also trigger a banking crisis and/or trigger a currency revaluation. To a certain extent, a banking crisis has already happened, and the U.S. dollar is dropping with respect to other currencies. However, the really big currency realignment crisis has not happened, because China is still deliberately holding its currency low.

Why is China holding on to U.S. dollars?

This is the biggest con in history. Essentially, China, Saudi Arabia, and many other very rich governments are corrupt. It is better for them to hold a U.S. dollar, than to hold their own currencies (which they have been manipulating.) Further, for their nest eggs (in U.S. $) to be worth anything, the U.S. dollar must maintain its high value. Hence, these countries must keep borrowing U.S. $, to ensure their leaders bank accounts retain value. The U.S. is taking full advantage of these corrupt ego-centric leaders. It just keeps purchasing cheap stuff from China with borrowed (and printed) money.

"How much cheap stuff can the U.S. purchase from China before it is cut off?" The answer is an awful lot of cheap stuff.
 
..............................................................................
Why is China holding on to U.S. dollars?

This is the biggest con in history. Essentially, China, Saudi Arabia, and many other very rich governments are corrupt. It is better for them to hold a U.S. dollar, than to hold their own currencies (which they have been manipulating.) Further, for their nest eggs (in U.S. $) to be worth anything, the U.S. dollar must maintain its high value. Hence, these countries must keep borrowing U.S. $, to ensure their leaders bank accounts retain value. The U.S. is taking full advantage of these corrupt ego-centric leaders. It just keeps purchasing cheap stuff from China with borrowed (and printed) money.

"How much cheap stuff can the U.S. purchase from China before it is cut off?" The answer is an awful lot of cheap stuff.

I kind of wonder if QEII was in some way a pre-emptive economic war waged to prevent any
major sell-off of U.S. treasuries. By ensuring a meltdown of the U.S. currency upon China
dumping its USD reserves QEII might have forced China to continue buying U.S. treasuries
to preserve the worth of its reserve. One scenario wherein a major sell-off of the USD
could transpire is for China being forced by an energy crunch and/or global food crisis
to give up using USD in trading with other major exporters of oil and grains. If fully played
out such scenario could be likened to dumping a nuclear bomb into the global economy.
 
But conceptually I am correct no?

If a government borrows from within its own country there is no inflation becuase no new money has been intoduced but but when it borrows from another country that is the same as printing money as new money has been introduced

If so why does it not the Fed just print money instead of borrowing from China ?

IE borrow form itself

Well that is what is actually happening, but it is generally frowned upon. The Fed is supposed to be "independant" so the way they do it... is the govt sells bonds, the big US banks buy the bonds, and the Fed buys the bonds from the banks. This keeps the phoney "arms length" appearance intact although it is pretty much the same as what Zimbabwe does. Just with more smoke and mirrors. This way the US bond auctions do not fail, and interst rates do not spike as they would without this sleight of hand.
 
I kind of wonder if QEII was in some way a pre-emptive economic war waged to prevent any
major sell-off of U.S. treasuries. By ensuring a meltdown of the U.S. currency upon China
dumping its USD reserves QEII might have forced China to continue buying U.S. treasuries
to preserve the worth of its reserve. One scenario wherein a major sell-off of the USD
could transpire is for China being forced by an energy crunch and/or global food crisis
to give up using USD in trading with other major exporters of oil and grains. If fully played
out such scenario could be likened to dumping a nuclear bomb into the global economy.

China cannot sell of US treasuries without first unpegging it's currency. If it did precipitate a collapse of the US$, then what? It's exports would collapse and the trillions of $ in treasuries would plunge in value. Also the real fact of the matter is there is still a HUGE SURPLUS of manufactured goods and labour. So with demand so depressed and supply abundant, it is really hard to increase prices
 
The other thing going on...why the US is trying to curb deflation (or re-flate the economy), is that money supply on the private side is still shrinking. The big increase in money supply in the US in the last decade was consumer borrowing fueled by rising real estate...and with easy access to mortgages/lines of credit against these assets there was an enormous increase in money supply. Think of it personally...if you have a house worth 500K and you have it paid for it is just a number. But if you borrow $490,000 against it and then go out and spend you have increased the money supply by some multiple of that. But when this bubble bursts the opposite happens. And a lot of credit gets wiped out and there is nothing to replace it. Hence deflationary pressure in the US.
 
so why no inflation ?

There has been considerable inflation the past couple of years. The Governments just fudge the figures.

Between price increases and product size shrinkage, food inflation has been huge.