How DUI death stats are compiled ....what do you think ?

nottyboi

Well-known member
May 14, 2008
27,857
5,514
113
"According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), A motor vehicle crash is considered to be alcohol-related if at least one driver or non-occupant (such as a pedestrian or pedalcyclist) involved in the crash is determined to have had a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .01 gram per deciliter (g/dL) or higher. Thus, any fatality that occurs in an alcohol-related crash is considered an alcohol-related fatality. The term 'alcohol-related' does not indicate that a crash or fatality was caused by the presence of alcohol."

So I wonder how realistic some of these stats are. Seems to me they are totally useless. So if a bone dry sober driver hits a pedestrian that drank one beer 3 hours ago it is an ALCOHOL RELATED traffic fatality... what a JOKE!!!
 
Actually, the police run people over and then classify it as a DUI to protect the guilty police and it's all a big coverup, right?
 
So what's your point?

They have a metric and they explain it. What's the problem?

How widely is that metric explained to the public? Clearly YOU did not know about it. If you miss the point you are pretty dumb, but that is self evident.
 
I must be dumb then.

What is the issue with tabulating the number of alcohol related vehicle crashes?

If they used the metric you described but called it "alcohol caused" I could see that it might be misleading. However, if one of the participants had been drinking, alcohol actually is related so there's no problem with that metric in my view.

What makes you think, by the way, that I didn't know about this before this thread? YOU are the one that posted it as though it was some sort of news...I'm just responding to an inane post (yours).
 
Actually, the police run people over and then classify it as a DUI to protect the guilty police and it's all a big coverup, right?

ha ha I see the cops on the board are starting to get antsy... slow day at the gestapo office? lol
 
I must be dumb then.

What is the issue with tabulating the number of alcohol related vehicle crashes?

If they used the metric you described but called it "alcohol caused" I could see that it might be misleading. However, if one of the participants had been drinking, alcohol actually is related so there's no problem with that metric in my view.

What makes you think, by the way, that I didn't know about this before this thread? YOU are the one that posted it as though it was some sort of news...I'm just responding to an inane post (yours).


How is it related? Related means it was a factor in the causation, since they say that may or may not be the case, it is a meaningless stat. Yet is trumped out by the Gestapo whenever they ask for tougher drinking and driving laws. This justifies even more idiots in blue gorging at the public trough and ruins the lives of more and more people who are engaging in activity that has not conclusively proven to be harmful. Yes you are pretty dumb. I suppose you would know that if you were a police officer since you would have to include it in your report.
 
I have taught stats at the university level... so I am happy to say with some credibility, that you are as dumb as a stump.

On top of your near daily hard on for cops, are you now saying that drinking and driving has not been conclusively proven to be harmful? Seriously? Are you truly this stupid?

Is it true you are really tboy? When people first suggested this I did not think so... but given you both exhibit the same deranged debating skills... I am not so sure any more.

Wow for a university prof you are pretty dumb. I was not saying drinking and driving has not been proven to be harmful. At some point it IS harmful, but what is that point. What data do we have to justify dropping the BAC to 0.05 from 0.08? What about a comment on causation El Professori? Can you say something is related if it has no impact on causation? Maybe that is one for the English dept rather then Stats.
 
Wow for a university prof you are pretty dumb. I was not saying drinking and driving has not been proven to be harmful. At some point it IS harmful, but what is that point. What data do we have to justify dropping the BAC to 0.05 from 0.08?

The only data we need to prove this is just watching our politicians cave to special interest groups.
 
To put it in perspective, for a 180 pound man, if you had 3 beers in 1 hour you'd have a BAC of .05. Have 3 more beers in the next hour and that jumps to over .10.
 
This isn't really news to many people. They often say alcohol or speed was a factor in a collision. But was it the deciding factor? Who knows, but they'll damn well use it for their stats!

I have a feeling most people think alcohol related accidents indicate the presence of an individual with >.08 g/dL. Explaining that to the general public would decimate their statistics though. I think everyone knows damn well they choose to deceive the public in this way.

You can argue they are doing nothing wrong, but really it's a lie of omission.
 
Personally, I'd rather take my chances with somebody who had one or two beers than some idiot who insisted on texting while driving.
 
ha ha I see the cops on the board are starting to get antsy... slow day at the gestapo office? lol

Another Gestapo reference, especially after you said they're not really, after you claimed they were, earlier this evening. Do you remember what you post at all? Of course, you didn't mean.
 
ha ha I see the cops on the board are starting to get antsy... slow day at the gestapo office? lol

LOL nottyboi apparently thinks I'm a cop. Actually, I prefer 'jack-booted thug'. We have an image to maintain here in State Security when we're out nightsticking the locals and violating their rights...
 
LOL nottyboi apparently thinks I'm a cop. Actually, I prefer 'jack-booted thug'. We have an image to maintain here in State Security when we're out nightsticking the locals and violating their rights...

You know that you're not that special. He thinks anyone on the BB that disagrees with his views as cops. Move over, it's getting crowded.