David Chen Amendment

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
Looks like there might be an amendment to the criminal code to give shopowners greater powers to apprehend shoplifters. Watch for the police association to fight this amendment tooth and nail as they will consider this an infringement on "their turf".

True story. My neighbour saw someone spraying grafitti on his garage door. He called the police. The advice was "do not approach the culprit and wait for the police to show up". The police never did show up. However, it was probably a good idea not to confront the culprit and get stabbed.
 
It IS good advice not to approach. Just because you might have a legal right to, doesn't mean that you SHOULD. Some things just aren't worth risking your life over.
 
It is unfortunate that many police decision-makers consider it more important to protect their turf than to protect the public.
 
Looks like there might be an amendment to the criminal code to give shopowners greater powers to apprehend shoplifters. Watch for the police association to fight this amendment tooth and nail as they will consider this an infringement on "their turf".

True story. My neighbour saw someone spraying grafitti on his garage door. He called the police. The advice was "do not approach the culprit and wait for the police to show up". The police never did show up. However, it was probably a good idea not to confront the culprit and get stabbed.

Personally, I think the police do some things well but...when it comes to protecting myself or my property I would rather do it myself. I think the laws in Canada should be changed to allow property owners the right to use deadly force to apprend someone breaking into an occupied family residence, and whatever force is necessary to protect private property. Warning signs should be posted notifying potential criminals what to expect!
 
once someone commits a crime, any citizen (not just the victim) should be allowed to kill them. criminal offences are offences against society and therefore there should be no restrictions on who can take out these criminals. if I see someone coming out of my neighbours house - i should be able to gun them down with my non-registered long gun.
 
Personally, I think the police do some things well but...when it comes to protecting myself or my property I would rather do it myself. I think the laws in Canada should be changed to allow property owners the right to use deadly force to apprend someone breaking into an occupied family residence, and whatever force is necessary to protect private property. Warning signs should be posted notifying potential criminals what to expect!
Great idea. I'll leave my ferrari in the driveway with the door ajar and the dome light on, and hide in the bushes with my uzi. Just a little bit of social cleansing. All in an honest day's work. You can thank me later.
 
I'd be more worried about shopkeepers (and their hired guns) being overzealous. there's a reason why their rights are restricted now.
 
They may be able to give merchants a bit more power to protect their property but it is a slippery slope. It is always a huge risk for the average merchant to physically restrain a thief and any relaxation of the laws governing what merchants are allowed to do will probably lead to more injuries to the merchants than to the shoplifters.
 
It is always a huge risk for the average merchant to physically restrain a thief and any relaxation of the laws governing what merchants are allowed to do will probably lead to more injuries to the merchants than to the shoplifters.

Right now, merchants are a sitting duck. Remember what happened to Barbara Turnbull. Might be a different story if the thieves know that the merchants will shoot back.
 
I'd be more worried about shopkeepers (and their hired guns) being overzealous. there's a reason why their rights are restricted now.

If the shopkeeper's "hired gun" is a paid duty officer, does he (or she) retain all the power and weaponry of a real police officer?
 
I would oppose any change in the law that removes the requirement that the arresting citizen physically witness the crime. We don't want the mall cops playing detective. It's one thing to perform a citizens arrest when you witness a crime. It's another to go conducting private investigations with some sort of pseudo power of arrest.
 

The police monopoly continues. No wonder these guys double their income with paid duty money.

Same with garbage collectors. Only official garbage persons are legally allowed to pick up garbage and that is why what the garbage volunteers were doing during the strike was illegal.
 
If the shopkeeper's "hired gun" is a paid duty officer, does he (or she) retain all the power and weaponry of a real police officer?
If he's pay duty, he's still an on duty cop.

It is unfortunate that many police decision-makers consider it more important to protect their turf than to protect the public.
I'm glad that you think having some shop keeper with little knowledge of the law (or in this case one who's english was poor enough to require a translator) having the power to use force to arrest someone they think committed a crime. This may sound like a good idea until a) a owner kills someone or b) the person resists and kills the owner.

A police officer or even a trained security guard is one thing. Letting any random joe use to do this is another.
 
In all likelihood the proposal will never result in legislation being tabled and if any legislation is actually tabled it will die on the order paper and the issue will be forgotten. A shopkeeper can already make a citizen's arrest. Chucking a suspect in the back of your van and punching his lights out will remain a no-no.
 
I'm glad that you think having some shop keeper with little knowledge of the law (or in this case one who's english was poor enough to require a translator) having the power to use force to arrest someone they think committed a crime. This may sound like a good idea until a) a owner kills someone or b) the person resists and kills the owner.

A police officer or even a trained security guard is one thing. Letting any random joe use to do this is another.

I did not say any of that, all I said was that I felt that the police were more interested in protecting their turf than they were in what was best for society at large. I feel that their positions tend to be self-serving.

As far as shop-keepers arresting people, I believe that property rights are very important, evidently more than many people do. From what I know of the facts of this case, I feel that what the shop-keeper did should be legal. A better solution would be that habitual offenders were permanently locked up, so that the shop-keeper would not have been put in that position.
 
True story. My neighbour saw someone spraying grafitti on his garage door. He called the police. The advice was "do not approach the culprit and wait for the police to show up". The police never did show up. However, it was probably a good idea not to confront the culprit and get stabbed.

It is near impossible to get charged for graffiti. The kid either has to be sufficiently inexperienced that they do not know how to avoid arrest, or such a compulsive repeat offender that they are incapable stopping themselves.
 
Great idea. I'll leave my ferrari in the driveway with the door ajar and the dome light on, and hide in the bushes with my uzi. Just a little bit of social cleansing. All in an honest day's work. You can thank me later.

Lots more fun than sitting in the cold, wet bush hunting moose! What's the daily tag limit?
 
Lots more fun than sitting in the cold, wet bush hunting moose! What's the daily tag limit?

Without the uzi, and just making a citizens arrest, you probably could do the car-baiting thing now. The current law allows you to apprehend someone you catch red handed in the act. Just be sure the car is disabled somehow so they don't speed off before you can arrest them.