This sounds ridiculous but I try to apply logic to it. How long has she known me? How long have we been exclusive? How much do we TRULY and DEEPLY have in common (not hobbies or a shared like of farmer's markets or zombie movies, but world views and senses of humour). Does she want to be with me and seek me out, or am I just a convenient partner? Does she seem to respect me or am I just the guy in her life? Throw in the intangibles that may or may not matter, like finances and sex and family and relative ages and looks, mix it all together and see if it makes sense. If it seems like she's someone who, all things considered, it makes sense she could love me, then I accept it at face value. Comes down to gut feel though. If you don't know her well enough to be sure she's being honest about her feelings, I might have some misgivings.
The real hard question is......do I love her?? Lol.