Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

And I'm saying Hamas has few viable military targets to attack. The kidnapping resulted in a terrible loss on Gaza. It resulted in Israel invading, bombing civilian infrastucture and killed 100 or so Palestinians. Is that your idea of a meaningful success? My point is proven. Yours is not.

Then maybe the should stop attacking Isreal all together.
 
Then maybe the should stop attacking Isreal all together.

And I've also said that maybe Palestinians should just lay down and obey. But would that just result in conditions that they may not wish to endure?
 
The military and the infrastructure necessary to sustain it were what was bombed.

As for the UN Sanctions, they were a nice try, and it was worth trying, but they were carried on for YEARS longer than they should have been. I have always advocated that Iraq should have been invaded much, much earlier. If it was going to happen sooner or later, sooner's better than later as the way it was done merely lengthened the suffering of civilians.

However there's a huge gulf between the sanctions being tried too long and a war crime--never attribute to malice what can be attributed to stupidity.
If I punched you on the nose and you fell and fractured your skull and died could I get off with an assault wrap because I was too stupid to know that a punch to the nose can cause death?

I don't buy that you can get away with bombing water and sewage treatment plants prior to sanctions and get away with claiming that you were too stupid to know that this would amount to a direct attack on civilians.
 
It depends on the context of fairness. What of the fairness in war on civilians? All civilians? Is the large disproportionate number of killed Pal. civilians compared to Israel, an unfairness you have no problem with?

I dispute that a disproportionate number of civilians have been killed. The number is proportionate with the military advantage achieved. You have to be careful using this term "disproportionate" because it has a specific legal meaning. If you mean something different I suggest you choose a different word.

All civilian lives are equal no matter which side they're on.

Agreed.

Killing many to save a few is not treating civilian lives equally.

It's not a numbers game. There's a principle involved, and the principle is NOT "eye for an eye". Israel has an absolute right to defend itself from rocket attacks and terrorist attacks.

Israel targets Hamas with the full knowledge that large numbers of civilians will be killed.

Yes, but Israel also fairly consistently chooses means of attack that minimize the number of civilians who will be killed, achieving its objectives with the minimum loss of life possible.

Hamas engineers the situation so that the minimum is a high number--the fault there lies with Hamas.

If Hamas were to stop using civilians as human shields the number of casualties would fall dramatically.
 
I don't buy that you can get away with bombing water and sewage treatment plants prior to sanctions and get away with claiming that you were too stupid to know that this would amount to a direct attack on civilians.

I don't believe that water and sewage treatment plants were bombed. I think you're confused. The electrical grid was bombed, and a consequence of the electrical grid being bombed was that water and sewage treatment plants that relied on electricity stopped working.

The electrical grid was bombed to disrupt enemy communications which relied on electricity as well. That it affected water and sewage treatment was unfortunate. The blockading powers did take steps to remedy that, shipping in fresh water for the Iraqi population--not ideal but it shows that the intention was to target the electrical grid and not the population.
 
I dispute that a disproportionate number of civilians have been killed. The number is proportionate with the military advantage achieved.

4:1

So you are saying killing four times the number of civilians to armed militants is 'correct and proper'?
That's the number from operation cast lead.

Is Hamas allowed the same ratio?


Israel has an absolute right to defend itself from rocket attacks and terrorist attacks.

Does Hamas (as gov't of Gaza) have an absolute right to defend itself from rocket attacks and terrorist attacks?
 
4:1

So you are saying killing four times the number of civilians to armed militants is 'correct and proper'?

Yes.

Is Hamas allowed the same ratio?

Yes.

Does Hamas (as gov't of Gaza) have an absolute right to defend itself from rocket attacks and terrorist attacks?

Yes.

Note this does not mean it is acceptable for ANYONE to target civilians.
 
So then, by your arguments (not mine, I think all killing is bad), you should have no issues with Hamas' attacks.

According to B'tselem, between 2000 and 2010 there were 738 Israeli civilians and 342 Israeli security forces killed by Palestinians, so Hamas' ratio's are way more efficient, at nearly 2:1 than Israel's 4 civilians killed to every militant during operation cast lead. That includes any deaths by Hamas rockets. So any arguments that Hamas targets civilians more than Israel are clearly bullshit.

Also, according to the same site, of the 6286 Palestinian's killed by Israeli's between 2000 and 2010, almost one quarter, or 1312 were minors.
238 were assassinated (or politely, 'targeted killings'), and 408 were killed for being too close to someone Israel wanted to assassinate.


About half of those killed, or 2982, were Palestinian's who had nothing to do with any of the hostilities.

Israel killed more Palestinian children, at about 1300 than Palestian's killed Israeli's, civilian and security combined.

So once again, Israel kills more civilians than Hamas and to say that Hamas targets civilians is a misdirection at best.
Hamas targets civilians less then Israel does.


http://www.btselem.org/english/Statistics/Casualties.asp
 
So then, by your arguments (not mine, I think all killing is bad), you should have no issues with Hamas' attacks.

According to B'tselem, between 2000 and 2010 there were 738 Israeli civilians and 342 Israeli security forces killed by Palestinians, so Hamas' ratio's are way more efficient, at nearly 2:1 than Israel's 4 civilians killed to every militant during operation cast lead. That includes any deaths by Hamas rockets. So any arguments that Hamas targets civilians more than Israel are clearly bullshit.

Also, according to the same site, of the 6286 Palestinian's killed by Israeli's between 2000 and 2010, almost one quarter, or 1312 were minors.
238 were assassinated (or politely, 'targeted killings'), and 408 were killed for being too close to someone Israel wanted to assassinate.


About half of those killed, or 2982, were Palestinian's who had nothing to do with any of the hostilities.

Israel killed more Palestinian children, at about 1300 than Palestian's killed Israeli's, civilian and security combined.

So once again, Israel kills more civilians than Hamas and to say that Hamas targets civilians is a misdirection at best.
Hamas targets civilians less then Israel does.


http://www.btselem.org/english/Statistics/Casualties.asp

You know every time I read one of your posts I reall can not believe that you can be that ignorant, but you manage to stoop to new lows every time.

You are of the opinion that because a large number of youths and children were killed in Isreali attacks that Isreal targets children more than Hamas does.

At least that is what I think is your argument, Lord only knows for sure.

1) Hamas fires rockets indescriminantly into Isreali territory with trageting based on population centers. The fact that in your opinion that is the best they can do because of the lack of armaments is besides the point.

2) Palestinian casualties were caused by ISreali forces engaging Hamas militia fighters in civilian areas as well as schools and hospitals. If you did not know the difference let me put it in a simpler form for you.

Isreali soldiers put themselves between the bad guys and their civilians, terrorists put the civilians between them and the Isrealis.

There is a considerable difference.
 
Nope. Hamas targets civilians. That's terrorism, you worm.

That's not what they say.
They say they aim their rockets at military posts, its just that they're not very good rockets. And they try to kill settlers, who they say are militia.


But the results show either
a) Israel's army is more inept then Hamas, because Israel has much, much better weapons then Hamas so they should be able to target fewer civilians
b) Israel's army is morally inferior to Hamas, because they don't seem to care that they kill way more civilians then Hamas

Or perhaps its the much more nefarious
c) Israel's army is closer to being terrorists, because they try to kill way more civilians



Me, I think shooting rockets is as morally repugnant as killing kids throwing stones.
I'm still just trying to figure out why you think Israel's killings are more 'correct and proper' then Hamas.
It looks all the same to me.
 
That's not what they say.

Who cares what they say? That's clearly what they DO.

They say they aim their rockets at military posts, its just that they're not very good rockets. And they try to kill settlers, who they say are militia.

Was the pregnant woman a military post? They often aim their rockets in a direction where there are no military posts, and then when the hit a school and kill some children they celebrate in the streets. If they didn't mean to kill civilians they wouldn't celebrate when they succeed in doing that--they'd apologize.

I'm still just trying to figure out why you think Israel's killings are more 'correct and proper' then Hamas.

Because Israel chooses legitimate military targets and attempts to minimize the civilian casualties, while Hamas chooses illegal civilian targets and attempts to maximize the civilian casualties.

It looks all the same to me.

Only because you are a disgusting worm who justifies terrorism and supports terrorism. I think you should renounce terrorism and denounce the illegal terrorist murder of that pregnant woman, instead of trying to justify it.
 
I dispute that a disproportionate number of civilians have been killed. The number is proportionate with the military advantage achieved. You have to be careful using this term "disproportionate" because it has a specific legal meaning. If you mean something different I suggest you choose a different word.
No, I mean the word for what it is in its legal terms. The number is not proportionate to the military advantage achieved. That's what most of the human rights agences have been crying about. There is little regard for the number of Pal. civilian deaths.


Agreed.

It's not a numbers game. There's a principle involved, and the principle is NOT "eye for an eye". Israel has an absolute right to defend itself from rocket attacks and terrorist attacks.
You're agreeing that all civilian lives are equal, but you argue the opposite. Gaza is occupied by Israel. A belligerent occupation I agree, but still Israel is legally restrained by the laws of the 4th Geneva Convention and therefore has a responsiblity to protect the civilians of the occupied territory. No, not just Jewish Israeli civilians but all its civilians. There is to be no distinction of one group of civilians from another. So saying 'killing the many to save the few' has nothing to do with "an eye for an eye". As an occupying power, Israel has a legal obligation to protect the civilians of the occupied territory whether they're nationals or not. Which throws a wrench in Israel's 'killing the many to save a few' self defence concept. All its civilians must be treated equally.


Yes, but Israel also fairly consistently chooses means of attack that minimize the number of civilians who will be killed, achieving its objectives with the minimum loss of life possible.
This is only an opinion that is not consistent with the results. The number of civilian deaths is huge and Israel seldom reveals details of its military operations to answer why. So the justification of Israel's objectives/civilian casuality ratio can not be proven to show Israel operates to minimize a loss of civilian life.
Hamas engineers the situation so that the minimum is a high number--the fault there lies with Hamas.

If Hamas were to stop using civilians as human shields the number of casualties would fall dramatically.
And Israel had nothing to do with engineering how tightly packed Gaza is? Its all Hamas's fault? Hmmm. And remember Amnesty Int. claims that Israeli soldiers also used Pal. civilians as sheilds.
 
Who cares what they say? That's clearly what they DO.

On this point, I have to say I agree. Its what they do.
And based on that, Israel kills proportionally more civilians than Hamas does therefore Israel is more 'terrorist' according to your rules then Hamas.


Only because you are a disgusting worm who justifies terrorism and supports terrorism. I think you should renounce terrorism and denounce the illegal terrorist murder of that pregnant woman, instead of trying to justify it.

Never once have I ever suggested that I support terrorism.
That, like most of the things you say, is a lie.
So, here, I fully renounce terrorism, I think Israel should stop its terrorist practices and Hamas should stop theirs.
Happy?


But here's the funny thing.
I've been trying to follow your logic because I think you are the one that justifies terrorism and supports terrorism. From believing that starving a population is ok, that there is an 'acceptable amount' of stunting do to malnutrition from Israel's policies in Gaza to supporting mock air raids over Lebanon and shelling of villages, to the killing of teenage and senior citizens trying to bring food and aid to a population suffering from war crimes, to justification and denial of charges of war crimes from the Goldstone report, to justifying ethnic cleansing and apartheid policies and for generally stating that Israel is above all laws, from UNIFIL rules, to rules of war, to the Geneva convention and to the resolutions of the UN.

You are a supporter of terrorism.
A warmonger.
A supporter of ethnic cleansing.
A supporter of murder.
 
I don't believe that water and sewage treatment plants were bombed. I think you're confused. The electrical grid was bombed, and a consequence of the electrical grid being bombed was that water and sewage treatment plants that relied on electricity stopped working.

The electrical grid was bombed to disrupt enemy communications which relied on electricity as well. That it affected water and sewage treatment was unfortunate. The blockading powers did take steps to remedy that, shipping in fresh water for the Iraqi population--not ideal but it shows that the intention was to target the electrical grid and not the population.
You can rationalize any attack on civilians by simply making up a military target.

Assuming that you are attacking a bonafide military target, what number of civilian collateral damage is acceptable? Would it be okay to nuke a million Iraqi civilians if you also killed one Iraqi soldier?
 
No, I mean the word for what it is in its legal terms. The number is not proportionate to the military advantage achieved.

I think it is.

That's what most of the human rights agences have been crying about. There is little regard for the number of Pal. civilian deaths.

Untrue, IDF routinely picks tactics designed to minimize casualties. The problem is that Hamas routinely picks tactics designed to maximize them.

There have been far too many civilian casualties but you are pointing the finger the wrong way.

You're agreeing that all civilian lives are equal, but you argue the opposite. Gaza is occupied by Israel. A belligerent occupation I agree, but still Israel is legally restrained by the laws of the 4th Geneva Convention and therefore has a responsiblity to protect the civilians of the occupied territory.

Gaza isn't occupied by Israel. Israel retains some responsibility owing to closure, but it's really not the same thing as an occupation: If IDF entered Gaza, say to ensure someone's safety, Hamas would shoot at them. So, no, it's not an occupation at this point.

I agree that Israel has some obligations but I disagree that you can apply the full occupation standard to a situation in which Israeli forces can't even safely enter the territory.

So saying 'killing the many to save the few' has nothing to do with "an eye for an eye".

I never said killing the many to save the few, I don't think that's what's going on. Israel kills as few people as it can to achieve specific objectives.
 
You can rationalize any attack on civilians by simply making up a military target.

Nevertheless no water treatment or sewage treatment facility was bombed so far as I know.

Assuming that you are attacking a bonafide military target, what number of civilian collateral damage is acceptable? Would it be okay to nuke a million Iraqi civilians if you also killed one Iraqi soldier?

You're attempting to apply some sort of body count ratio and that's no the correct way to think about the issue, at least not the way spelled out in the laws on the subject.

The proper questions are these:

1. Is it militarily necessary to kill that soldier?

2. Is there another way of killing him that would carry fewer casualties?

Without other information I'd have to say it's probably not militarily necessary to kill some random soldier, and there's likely another way to do it if it is.
 
And based on that, Israel kills proportionally more civilians than Hamas does therefore Israel is more 'terrorist' according to your rules then Hamas.

Nope.

Never once have I ever suggested that I support terrorism.

You have repeatedly tried to justify it. You say things like, Hamas has no other alternative, and all settlers are valid military targets. You're a disgusting worm who justifies terrorism.

I've been trying to follow your logic

I don't think you're capable of following logic.

From believing that starving a population is ok

I don't believe that.

that there is an 'acceptable amount' of stunting

It's the WHO that believes that, you provided the link to the report that said so, remember?

to supporting mock air raids over Lebanon

I do support that: It was a reasonable and essentially non-violent way to demonstrate to Lebanon the likely futile consequences of continuing with its acts of war.

and shelling of villages

Correction, shelling an army post in a village.

This is why I call you a propaganda clown: Even after you know the truth of a situation you continue misrepresenting it.

to the killing of teenage and senior citizens trying to bring food and aid to a population

Nope, I only support the killing of militants who attack soldiers.

the Goldstone report

The Goldstone report has no credibility whatsoever and should be ignored by thinking people.

to justifying ethnic cleansing

I've never done that.

and apartheid policies and for generally stating that Israel is above all laws

I've never said that.

from UNIFIL rules, to rules of war, to the Geneva convention and to the resolutions of the UN.

Nope, though you have repeatedly shown you fail at understanding those rules. You haven't got the first foggiest clue about any of those things. You really know nothing.