American Muslim Ads

Rockslinger

Banned
Apr 24, 2005
32,764
0
0
As we approach the anniversary of 9/11, I saw a couple of the new American Muslim ads rejecting violence and affirming their loyalty to the United States of America. Maybe there is hope after all.
 
Rockslinger, I haven't heard the advertisements yet, but I did hear an interview about them last night on the NPR news. Based upon that interview, my criticism is that the issue isn't that we are Americans who are Moslems. I honestly don't believe anyone denies that from a legal perspective.

The problem is that I do not hear them saying "your [the folks who fly airliners into buildings] theology is wrong! The Quran does not support that viewpoint. (Your perspective on this is frankly heretical)"
 
I agree with Aardvark. There are no issues with Muslim Americans (and Canadians) who have embraced our secular culture while holding dear the tenets of their faith. Those are good people!! The problem children are those who hate, most of whom live on the other side of the planet. If the aim of the ads is to prevent retaliatory violence against Muslim Americans or to improve our impressions of the vast majority of the Muslim world who are non-violent and normal human beings, then great. But if they are intended to try and convince us that we shouldn't be worried about what some people are doing in the name of Islam, then they are flawed.
 
I agree that American Muslims need to do a lot more convincing. Firstly, to condemned those who choose violence. Secondly, to re-assure their non-Muslim fellow Americans that they mean no harm. I think that these ads do address the second issue to some degree. Anyway, how ever small, it is progress and a step in the right direction.

Old Irish proverb: "A journey of 10,000 miles starts with a single step."
 
There are no issues with Muslim Americans (and Canadians) who have embraced our secular culture while holding dear the tenets of their faith.
This is, unfortunately, not at all true. There are many americans who have serious issues with the muslim faith...even (perhaps more so) if they don't know the first thing about it. If it was, there would be no objection to the building of a mosque near the ground-zero site. After all, those building the mosque are peaceful, law abiding, americans. Certainly no one would object if a church was proposed on that site. There is a very strong anti-muslim sentiment, especially in the U.S., which is prejudicial and bigoted. I'm not sure that advertisements are the solution but to deny that there is a problem is inaccurate or disingenuous.
 
There is a very strong anti-muslim sentiment, especially in the U.S., which is prejudicial and bigoted.

Why is that? There must be a valid reason for that? People in the U.S. don't have an anti-Amish sentment. Is that because the Amish might be a bit weird but they don't go around killing people?
 
Why is that? There must be a valid reason for that? People in the U.S. don't have an anti-Amish sentment. Is that because the Amish might be a bit weird but they don't go around killing people?
You've answered your own question.

Many Americans (and clearly some Canadians as well) are too closed minded to understand that when a Muslim commits a crime, it is the individual and not his (or her) entire religion who is the criminal.

There are white supremacists who commit acts of terror in the name of white racial purity. However, since the majority of Canadians and Americans are also white they immediately realize that the criminals are whack jobs and do not really represent all (or even very many) white-skinned people. When Christian clergy are found guilty of hideous abuse crimes (as happens periodically) the majority of Canadians and Americans (who happen to be Christian of of Christian origin) easily recognize that the abusers are guilty because of their own criminal ways and not because they are christian.

However, when someone claiming to be a Muslim commits a crime, there are many (such as the quoted individual above) who automatically assume that all one billion Muslims in this world are complicit in the crime of a few isolate whack jobs who happen to claim to be Muslim. This is a wrong assumption.

The 9/11 terrorists and others like them have as much in common with the Vast majority of Muslims as the KKK has with most Christians. We don't assume Christians are all murderous racists just because a member of the KKK kills an innocent black victim in the American south. Why then do some people assume that all Muslims are terrorists? Since they are NOT, the fault lies in those making the false assumption and not in the peaceful majority of Muslims.
 
Why is that? There must be a valid reason for that? People in the U.S. don't have an anti-Amish sentment. Is that because the Amish might be a bit weird but they don't go around killing people?


Negative sentiment towards a particular people usually go
both ways. The Mennonite being the otherwordly religion it is
naturally has no enemies and show hatred to nobody.
Although most Islamic countries are formally in alliance
with the U.S. in reality a large segment of the
Islamic population in the Middle East hate the U.S. It is just
human nature to have issue with your enemy. I am sure the
Japanese Americans were not generally well-liked in the war
years.
 
Many Americans (and clearly some Canadians as well) are too closed minded to understand that when a Muslim commits a crime, it is the individual and not his (or her) entire religion who is the criminal.
Which, Blue-Spheroid, goes back to my point about these ads. Do they address this issue, I say they do not. Because addressing the above has to do with saying these people (Islamic Fundamentalists/Terrorists) do not speak for us, and further we have something forceful to say about denouncing their behaviour, rather than merely saying we are not all the same.

To use your example, you routinely hear Christian Denominations denouncing criminal acts committed by Christians, they don’t content themselves with merely saying 'we aren't like them.'
 
Re: 'There is a very strong anti-muslim sentiment, especially in the U.S., which is prejudicial and bigoted.' - Why is that? There must be a valid reason for that?
The valid reason is that the extreme racist Fox news has miss-quoted facts and slanted racist bullshit to be sucked up by the more intellectually challenged - purely for election purposes. Innocent Muslims have now been targeted by paranoid nut jobs who actually believe this Fox tripe.

I liked the 'Is it too soon and insensitive to build Catholic churches beside school yards ?' comment by John Oliver.
 
I liked the 'Is it too soon and insensitive to build Catholic churches beside school yards ?' comment by John Oliver.
I have not seen this advertisement. But merely from your description of it, it seems counterproductive. Who is it going to appeal to besides the already convinced?

Is dragging the Roman Catholic Clergy child abuse scandal into the discussion going to change the minds of those who say 'they say they are different from the folks who flew the planes into the towers, but they refuse to denounce them'.
 
I liked the 'Is it too soon and insensitive to build Catholic churches beside school yards ?' comment by John Oliver.
If you want to use the Roman Catholic example look at JFK's famous September 12, 1960 statement to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association “I do not speak for my church on public matters, and the church does not speak for me." It was indeed what he thought, and what most American Roman Catholics thought at the time, however, it was not the Vatican Position. Yet he publicly stated it. This is the sort of thing that Muslims need to do as well.
 
If you want to use the Roman Catholic example look at JFK's famous September 12, 1960 statement to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association “I do not speak for my church on public matters, and the church does not speak for me." It was indeed what he thought, and what most American Roman Catholics thought at the time, however, it was not the Vatican Position. Yet he publicly stated it. This is the sort of thing that Muslims need to do as well.

Agreed.

There should always be a separation of church and state.

Another scary phenomenon involving religion is the amount of right-wing Christian loons in the military.

http://www.harpers.org/archive/2009/05/0082488
 
Which, Blue-Spheroid, goes back to my point about these ads. Do they address this issue, I say they do not. ...
I think there is no way they can address the issue - the issue being people's tendancy towards xenophobia. The US (like Canada) has a significant amount of their population outside of multicultural urban centers and most people don't no any Muslims so it is quite easy for them to buy into Glen Beck and crowds power games and believe that all Muslims want to destroy the West.
 
If you want to use the Roman Catholic example look at JFK's famous September 12, 1960 statement to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association “I do not speak for my church on public matters, and the church does not speak for me." It was indeed what he thought, and what most American Roman Catholics thought at the time, however, it was not the Vatican Position. Yet he publicly stated it. This is the sort of thing that Muslims need to do as well.

Except Islam does not have the central authority that Catholicism has (despite Saudi attempts to spread Wahabism). Therefore there is no central voice for Islam to go speak for people, just an infinite number of clerics and their local followers, quite often with their own interpretations.
 
Except Islam does not have the central authority that Catholicism has (despite Saudi attempts to spread Wahabism).
This indeed I know Basketcase.

My point is that these advertisments need to tackle head on the issue of: we have nuts in our religion, we do not agree with them. We agree with the larger society in North America.

The problem is they don't do this.
 
I think there is no way they can address the issue - the issue being people's tendancy towards xenophobia.
Respectfully I believe that they can. However, they have to be forthright about the issue of Islamic Fundamentalism and Terrorism and not dance all around it trying to ignore the elephant in the living room. The problem is they behave towards the issue somewhat like Senator Goldwater’s “Eleventh Commandment”.
 
I think it's pretty sad that people think they have to.
Sad or not it is what needs to be done. You could say the same thing about many religious minorities Christian and non-Christian throughout American and to only a slightly lesser degree Canadian History.