Hamas has resumed direct terrorist activities

Civilian lifes are equal. However the value of human life differs greatly from both sides. If an Israeli man gunned down a group of palestinian people 1. He would be either shot on sight my israeli military police or 2. Sentenced to hard jail time by the Israeli legal system. This should be the same process for the palestinians.
I agree. For the people of Gaza, life is cheap. Its hell there.
 
There may not be a celebration but where is the remorse for the disproportional number of civilian Pal. deaths caused by Israel?...

Israel has numerous peace and human rights groups that actively lobby and publicize events they don't agree with. There are some Palestinian peace groups as well but they don't seem to represent as large a portion of the Palestinian electorate, especially in Gaza.

Israel has also shown the willingness to prosecute murder of Palestinians. When Baruch Goldstein murdered Palestinian civilians, he was arrested as were other followers of his nutty leader. The Israeli government also banned their political party declaring it a terrorist group.

On the other hand, this recent murder of Israeli civilians has received open praise from the Hamas leadership as well as vows from them that more terrorism will occur. If the perpetrators of this crime are killed, they will be celebrated as martyrs. If they survive, they will be permanently venerated as heroes with an income from Hamas. The terrorist group that has so often committed these acts was not banned but elected to the legislature.

Yes, dead civilians are dead civilians but intentional murder of civilians is more of a problem than accidental killings. One is far easier to stop.
 
Yes, dead civilians are dead civilians but intentional murder of civilians is more of a problem than accidental killings. One is far easier to stop.
Whoa! Accidental killings they are not. Israel knew hitting Hamas targets would cause high civilian causalities.
 
Whoa! Accidental killings they are not. Israel knew hitting Hamas targets would cause high civilian causalities.

Still doesn't change things.

When Hamas launches it's attacks, civilians are the targets and the intent is purely to kill Israeli Jews. When Israel launches attacks, civilians are not the target, just a consequence of the tactics Hamas uses.

Israel has repeatedly done things to try and minimize civilian casualties though they are not always successful. Hamas on the other hand does what it can to maximize civilian casualties, hoping that Israel will respond and the attempts of reasonable minds to try for peace will be derailed once again.
 
Whoa! Accidental killings they are not. Israel knew hitting Hamas targets would cause high civilian causalities.

Attacking and destrpying rocket launchers, mortars etc that have attacked your personal is perfectly legal under any system of "laws of war". If anything the terrorist groups that are placing the offensive systems in civilian areas or in non combat areas ( hospitals schools ) are the ones that are at fault. The civilian population has to say enough no more to the terrorist factions when they do this.

I would ahve a lot more sympathy for the palistinian terrorist groups if they were to actually attack hard targets, airfields, police staitions, barracks , infrastructure targets etc and launched from areas that did not endanger the people that they are trying to "free"
 
No, I don't think so. Israel has every right to stop a rocket attack, and if the rockets are being launched from the midsts of civilians, that sucks, but there's no other way to stop the rocket attacks than to hit the launcher where it is.

I find Hamas entirely to blame for the placement of the rocket launcher in that case, not Israel.

There have been a LOT of confrontations and a LOT of conflicts and like in any war there have been cases of over-zealous Israeli commanders exceeding their authority and going beyond what is called for. The case of white phosphorous shells being used against military targets that were near to civilians is an example of that. You'll note that Israel disciplined the officer who ordered that strike--it was not in line with their general policy.

The question is what's the general policy? Is the general policy in line with acceptable standards? Is it just a few rogue individuals who cross the line?

In the case of Israel they are largely abiding by acceptable international standards with respect to the use of violence, and the exceptions seem to be exceptions, and Israel seems to be capable of self-policing the exceptions well enough, maybe not as harshly as you'd like, but they do act.

In the case of Hamas they are intentionally and knowingly breaching them and rather than disciplining the gunmen who killed the pregnant woman in even some lenient way they actually did the opposite and celebrated those gunmen as heros. So contrast that: Israel disciplined the officer who ordered the WP shells to be used, however leniently, while Hamas celebrated as heroes those who murdered the pregnant woman.

I see quite a difference there.

So convenient, firstly, it is a tiny place, you cannot really find places away from civilains to launch rockets. So that arguement is typically ignorent and self-serving. Secondly, after making arguments like this your MASSIVE hypocrisy is further highlighted when you whine about Hamas attacking Israeli civilian targets. Based on the fact that most Israelis are reservists or members of the IDF, there is really no place in Israel that is a military free zone. Heck even the synagogues are packed with military personnel. So if someone attacked Israel in retaliation for one of their many attacks, and wiped it out with nukes... according to your logic that would be FAIR PLAY??? Bwa haha hahahahaa
 
Why would hitting hamas targets cause civilian casualities? Because Hamas do not value human life and set up shop in high populated areas so if there is ever an attack on a Hamas base people can film the horrible images of civilians and send it into Al Jizzera as fast as possible.

I know hitting Hamas targets causes civilian deaths. So does Israel. Israel hits them anyway as an act of desperation. And MANY civilians die. I'm pointing out that targeting civilians is an act of desperation, on both sides, but unfortunately Pal. civilian deaths are far greater.
 
.... Based on the fact that most Israelis are reservists or members of the IDF, there is really no place in Israel that is a military free zone. Heck even the synagogues are packed with military personnel....

Typical terror appologist crap. People are only military targets when they are performing duties of a military - such as launching rockets. When not serving, Israelis civilians like the pregnant woman Hamas shot are are civilians and only pathetic scum would try to justify them as valid targets.
 
Still doesn't change things.

When Hamas launches it's attacks, civilians are the targets and the intent is purely to kill Israeli Jews. When Israel launches attacks, civilians are not the target, just a consequence of the tactics Hamas uses.

Israel has repeatedly done things to try and minimize civilian casualties though they are not always successful. Hamas on the other hand does what it can to maximize civilian casualties, hoping that Israel will respond and the attempts of reasonable minds to try for peace will be derailed once again.

And all civilian lives are equal. Aren't they? Israel however has maximized civilian deaths if you look at the numbers. That's poor policing.
 
I know hitting Hamas targets causes civilian deaths. So does Israel. Israel hits them anyway as an act of desperation. And MANY civilians die. I'm pointing out that targeting civilians is an act of desperation, on both sides, but unfortunately Pal. civilian deaths are far greater.

Desperation as a justification is fine but it is important to look at what alternatives each side has before stating they have no other choice?

The alternative for Israel is they could turn the other cheek. Hamas has stated many times that Israel's withdrawal from Gaza was a victory of military resistance and likely would only be encouraged by Israel's lack of response so that doesn't seem like much of an option to me.
The alternative for Hamas is to join the peace talks and try to work towards a productive peace. Of course this would conflict with the stated goal of Hamas to get a Middle East without Israel.
 
Attacking and destrpying rocket launchers, mortars etc that have attacked your personal is perfectly legal under any system of "laws of war". If anything the terrorist groups that are placing the offensive systems in civilian areas or in non combat areas ( hospitals schools ) are the ones that are at fault. The civilian population has to say enough no more to the terrorist factions when they do this.

I would ahve a lot more sympathy for the palistinian terrorist groups if they were to actually attack hard targets, airfields, police staitions, barracks , infrastructure targets etc and launched from areas that did not endanger the people that they are trying to "free"
Hamas can't target Israeli airfields, etc. directly. Their military is nothing to the strength of Israel. Their horrid small acts are done in desperation as their only means to fight.
 
Desperation as a justification is fine but it is important to look at what alternatives each side has before stating they have no other choice?

The alternative for Israel is they could turn the other cheek. Hamas has stated many times that Israel's withdrawal from Gaza was a victory of military resistance and likely would only be encouraged by Israel's lack of response so that doesn't seem like much of an option to me.
The alternative for Hamas is to join the peace talks and try to work towards a productive peace. Of course this would conflict with the stated goal of Hamas to get a Middle East without Israel.
I wish there was another choice. Unfortunately Hamas got into power because the people of Gaza saw little choice.
 
I wish there was another choice. Unfortunately Hamas got into power because the people of Gaza saw little choice.

Or they though that Hamas couldn't be worse than the obviously corrupt Fatah. They were wrong.


As to Palestinian public opinion, here are a few views.

From the Palestinian center fro Public opinion, Jan. 1, 2010

Q 2. Whom, do you think, should be held responsible for not putting an end to the conflict between Hamas and Fatah?
1. Hamas 40.8
2. Fatah 12.5
3. Both of them 42.6
4. I don’t know 4.1

Q 12. Who, in your opinion, should be held accountable for the daily human-life losses as a result of the collapses of the underground tunnels at the Palestinian-Egyptian borders?
1. Hamas 52.1
2. Egypt 22.4
3. The Palestinian Authority in Ramallah 7.6
4. Don’t know 17.9

Q 15. Who, according to your opinion, is benefiting most from the underground tunnels excavated at the Egyptian-Palestinian borders?
1. Hamas 49.7
2. The deposed government 15.3
3. The people 26.4
4. Don’t know 8.6

Q 17. Are you in favor of a long truce with Israel or in favor of a peace deal?
1. Truce 24.8
2. Peace deal 67.0
3. Don’t know 8.2

Q 19. Are you satisfied or dissatisfied with the performance of the deposed Prime Minister, Mr. Ismael Haniyyeh?
1. Strongly satisfied 13.9
2. Somewhat satisfied 17.7
3. Somewhat dissatisfied 20.9
4. Strongly dissatisfied 36.8
5. Don’t know 10.7

Q 20. If there would be soon new presidential elections for the Palestinian Authority, in which Mr. Mahmoud Abbas would run for Fateh and Mr. Ismael Haniyyeh for Hamas, for whom would you vote?
1. For Mr. Mahmoud Abbas 45.3

2. For Mr. Ismael Haniyyeh 17.7
3. I wouldn’t participate in the elections 28.5
4. I don’t know / no opinion 8.4

Q 21. If Mr. Mahmoud Abbas would run in the presidential elections versus Mr. Salam Fayyad, for whom would you cast your vote?
1. For Mr. Mahmoud Abbas 42.1

2. For Mr. Salam Fayyad 8.5
3. I wouldn’t participate in the elections 36.1
4. I don’t know / no opinion 13.2

Q 23. Do you support the stay of Mr. Mahmoud Abbas in his office as President of the Palestinian Authority after the scheduled January 24th, 2010 or the handing-over of his office to Mr. Aziz Adduwaik, chairman of the Palestinian Legislative Council, until new presidential elections are held?
1. I support the handing over of the office to Mr. Aziz Adduwaik 21.4
2. I support the stay of Mr. Abbas in his office 53.6
3. Don’t know 25.0
http://www.pcpo.ps/polls.htm
 
Typical terror appologist crap. People are only military targets when they are performing duties of a military - such as launching rockets. When not serving, Israelis civilians like the pregnant woman Hamas shot are are civilians and only pathetic scum would try to justify them as valid targets.

I am not justifying it, I think it is all sick and appalling. I am just applying Fuji's logic to the situation. You people are trying to apply slivers of logic to a war... one idiot with an ak-47 makes it ok to incinerate a village full of children and other innocents.. WTF is that sickness.?? 3 dead Israeli soldiers and one kidnapping makes it ok to cause BILLIONS of $$ in damage to Lebanon and kill hundreds of civilians? WTF. It's clear as day, as long as Israel is the perpetrator you guys cannot see ANY wrong.
 
Or they though that Hamas couldn't be worse than the obviously corrupt Fatah. They were wrong.


As to Palestinian public opinion, here are a few views.

From the Palestinian center fro Public opinion, Jan. 1, 2010


http://www.pcpo.ps/polls.htm

Not sure if the Aug/2010 poll means anything when a Hamas majority government is in question. 14% are in favor of a Hamas majority but only 39 sites polled were in Gaza while 117 were in the West bank. It would be nice however if Hamas could be tossed out on their ear.
 
Hamas can't target Israeli airfields, etc. directly. Their military is nothing to the strength of Israel. Their horrid small acts are done in desperation as their only means to fight.

Then why fight if there is the possibility of peace? Attacking Israel will not bring a Paleastinian state closer yet Hamas and many other Palestinian factions would rather do this in the impossible hope that Israel will go away. Have the Palestinian militants gotten themselves to deep in their message of hatred to realize that their violence will not bring a better life for Palestinians (or do they care more for their own comfortable lives in a position of power)?
 
Then why fight if there is the possibility of peace? Attacking Israel will not bring a Paleastinian state closer yet Hamas and many other Palestinian factions would rather do this in the impossible hope that Israel will go away. Have the Palestinian militants gotten themselves to deep in their message of hatred to realize that their violence will not bring a better life for Palestinians (or do they care more for their own comfortable lives in a position of power)?

Netanyahu excluded Hamas fromt peace talks here. So Hamas has been excluded from the possibility of peace by Israel in a game of politics. These attacks are their only chance at negating what they feel, and probably rightly, are peace negotiations that do not represent the will of the majority of Palestinians. So this was brought on by Israeli policies.
 
Then why fight if there is the possibility of peace? Attacking Israel will not bring a Paleastinian state closer yet Hamas and many other Palestinian factions would rather do this in the impossible hope that Israel will go away. Have the Palestinian militants gotten themselves to deep in their message of hatred to realize that their violence will not bring a better life for Palestinians (or do they care more for their own comfortable lives in a position of power)?

I'm not sure if laying down and obeying would bring a better life for Palestinians. With peace would come conditions that they may not want.
 
Netanyahu excluded Hamas fromt peace talks here. ....

Why do you keep on with this joke? Hamas 'excluded' themselves from the talks because they will accept no peace deal that includes Israel's existence.

(unless in your eyes Israel shouldn't insist on existing)
 
I'm not sure if laying down and obeying would bring a better life for Palestinians. With peace would come conditions that they may not want.

Better peace than will come from violence.

Netanyahu has said that both sides will have to make painful concessions. Hopefully both sides actually will.