Prostitution ruling expected this month

moviefan

Court jester
Mar 28, 2004
2,525
0
0
Here's a brief report from the National Post:


Prostitution ruling expected this month

Postmedia News · Wednesday, Sept. 1, 2010

An Ontario Superior Court judge is expected to rule in September on a challenge by three sex-trade activists, who are seeking to repeal Criminal Code provisions that make it illegal to run a bawdy house, communicate for the purposes of prostitution and live off the avails of prostitution. They argue that these laws put lives at risk because they drive prostitutes onto the streets and limit their ability to talk to prospective clients to determine if they might be dangerous. Critics of decriminalization say repealing the laws will normalize prostitution, potentially lead to sex tourism and more violence against women. Whatever the judge decides, the case likely will be argued all the way to the Supreme Court.
 
Keep up the good work:) till prostitution is legally accepted in Canada like it is in Amsterdam! High time legalize it and tax them too.
It would be the biggest revenue for CRA even bigger than LCBO in future Lol
 
Wonder who the lawyer is handling the case for the sex workers. To take any case to the Supreme Court would normally take huge bucks. Rare to find a lawyer willing to work for free - unless he/she is getting paid in trade.
 
Are you suggesting they might do it pro bono?
 
Keep up the good work:) till prostitution is legally accepted in Canada like it is in Amsterdam! High time legalize it and tax them too.
It would be the biggest revenue for CRA even bigger than LCBO in future Lol

Being part European myself (parents) and having a few friends who visited Amsterdam and loved it, I agree with you 100%.
Amsterdam has it totally right.
 
Keep up the good work:) till prostitution is legally accepted in Canada like it is in Amsterdam! High time legalize it and tax them too.
It would be the biggest revenue for CRA even bigger than LCBO in future Lol

Taxing it might increase prices, but if it is decriminalized, there will more competition which should stabilize prices. There will also be less stigma associated with income reporting (which is like outing yourself).
 
Being part European myself (parents) and having a few friends who visited Amsterdam and loved it, I agree with you 100%.
Amsterdam has it totally right.

Having visited the RLD's in Amsterdam and in Hamburg, I know the Europeans have it absolutely right. The girls have STD checks regularly and pay taxes. The police are also there to protect them.

AS they don't have streetwalkers in shady areas, the Robert Pikton's of this world would have very little luck picking up prostitutes' in those jurisdictions.
 
My understanding is that SPOC wants to decriminalize prostitution, not legalize it. They do not want the government to step in as they would for any other industry and regulate it. And they seem to want to allow street walking.
 
If a Judge has the option of ruling against something and letting it go to appealing at a higher court, a Judge will rule agaisnt it imo.
 
If a Judge has the option of ruling against something and letting it go to appealing at a higher court, a Judge will rule agaisnt it imo.
With all due respect, that may be your opinion but it is not how things work.

The judge is bound to come to the "right" conclusion to the best of her or his ability. Whether or not it goes to appeal is of no concern, except in cases where prior decisions bind him or her to a certain result that one or both of the parties wish to have tested in an appellate court.

Perry
 
Are you suggesting they might do it pro bono?

I think it would be caller pro boner in this case.....

But I think I am against unrestricted bawdy houses. I think it is a matter for bylaws rather then the criminal code. So they should be licensed. Maybe locate them in office areas where they will be away from residents. I am not crazy about going to apartments...prefer hotels.
 
Having visited the RLD's in Amsterdam and in Hamburg, I know the Europeans have it absolutely right. The girls have STD checks regularly and pay taxes. The police are also there to protect them.

AS they don't have streetwalkers in shady areas, the Robert Pikton's of this world would have very little luck picking up prostitutes' in those jurisdictions.
Even though I support legalization this isnt completely true.
Amsterdam still has some street-walkers, they just dont have as many as North-American cities
 
Prostitution will NEVER be legal here in Canada we have the 2nd highest population of "Bible Thumpers" and "Polictical Correctors", even Holland is trying to reduce the red light foot print

Gotta love Bible thumpers, it's too bad because the women in the industry should be well protected. This industry will go on regardless, so they may as well do something about it and help those in it.
It's good business for everyone, those who own, those who work, those who want the services.
 
Interesting considering they just changed the laws to include Keeping Bawdy House - as organized crime- 5 years jail time min (I think) making it easier than ever to bust incalls etc. Maybe this is why they snuck the new law through.
 
Interesting considering they just changed the laws to include Keeping Bawdy House - as organized crime- 5 years jail time min (I think) making it easier than ever to bust incalls etc. Maybe this is why they snuck the new law through.

As I understand it, what they did was deem that law a 'serious offence' which makes it easier to use wiretapping as a LE weapon of choice. I believe the longer jail terms also result from calling it a 'serious offence'.

However, if 'keeping a bawdy house', etc. is decriminalized, then the 'serious offence' label is inapplicable.
 
Be careful what you wish for. I have been to Amsterdam and it ain't as good as the hype. LEs there protect prostitutes, not customers. rip offs, bad attitude, high rates, reduced service levels are common place. Good for tourism and safety of prostitutes, but bad for hobbysts.
 
As I understand it, what they did was deem that law a 'serious offence' which makes it easier to use wiretapping as a LE weapon of choice. I believe the longer jail terms also result from calling it a 'serious offence'.

However, if 'keeping a bawdy house', etc. is decriminalized, then the 'serious offence' label is inapplicable.

If I understand correctly, the "serious offence" tag only comes into play when dealing with a "criminal organization."