Why you should not talk to cops...

The big rule for dealing with the police is: 'polite minimal compliance while asserting your rights'. Don't ramble on. Don't let them in. Don't provide ID unless you're statutorily compelled to. Don't pop your trunk without a clear reason. Politely scold them if they go for your glove box or try to flip open your smokes. For the love of god keep it simple and never incriminate yourself, even if the cop has a 90% idea of what's going on. The flip side of that is be polite, respect their authority, and hope for the best.
 
The big rule for dealing with the police is: 'polite minimal compliance while asserting your rights'. Don't ramble on. Don't let them in. Don't provide ID unless you're statutorily compelled to. Don't pop your trunk without a clear reason. Politely scold them if they go for your glove box or try to flip open your smokes. For the love of god keep it simple and never incriminate yourself, even if the cop has a 90% idea of what's going on. The flip side of that is be polite, respect their authority, and hope for the best.

That pretty well sums it up. Although, my piece is behind a false speaker grill in the drivers side door, but a side from that, you pretty much hit on the head.
 
It should go without saying, but all this applies when there is a violation of law involved. Obviously if there is no self incrimination: you are in a motor vehicle collision and the police are speaking to you or you call the police because your house has been burglarized why on earth are you going to refuse to talk to them, unless in the first instance you committed a motor vehicle violation, ran a red light were speeding etc. . . .
 
LOL, even Peckrwood saw eye to eye on the same issue with right wing neo-con teaching in an institution founded by Rush Limbaugh mentor/Rabbi. :p
Oh Professor Duane, is indeed correct. I merely find it amusing in light of the criticism of Monica Goodling, former Deputy Director of Public Affairs at the U.S. Department of Justice here on TERB, including criticism that she was a graduate of Regent.
 
They don't listen to what you say, they write down what they WANT to hear.

I once was involved in a fraud investigatgion - cop took my statement and gave it to me to sign - no resemblance to what I said at all - refused to sign.

Same company fraud investigation number 2 -- Senior executive (who had worked in Attorney General's Office) instructed me to make the case (my thought was what the f*&**K) got a conviction no problems

Same company fraud investigation number 3 -- New head honcho - let police handle it -- no results - no interest in case --- now I understood why previous guy told me to make case.