Omar Khadr is fracked

Fuji, we are all aware of your views regarding this matter. It is also apparent that what you don't know about the U.S. system of Military Justice would fill a large book.

Except this is a BRAND NEW BOOK. Get real, so many legal minds have expressed the opinion that this process is an utter scam. It is a HUGE shame on our country and a massive humiliation that we are the only lapdogs that could not protect our citizen from this kangaroo court. Canada's status as a subservient 2nd rate US ally has been sealed by Harpo who is our elected trained seal.....
 
Except this is a BRAND NEW BOOK. Get real, so many legal minds have expressed the opinion that this process is an utter scam. It is a HUGE shame on our country and a massive humiliation that we are the only lapdogs that could not protect our citizen from this kangaroo court. Canada's status as a subservient 2nd rate US ally has been sealed by Harpo who is our elected trained seal.....

Please.

There are a large number of liberal lawyers, just as there are a number of conservative lawyers. A good lawyer knows all the points which both sides will argue. Most good lawyers don't even get to pick what side they will present in court. But to confuse commentators with law displays a bit too much naivete for this forum.

The simple fact remains that Khadr is receiving due process, as attested to by the numerous Supreme Court decisions which have shaped this process.

But apparently some here believe that a child should be able to commit murder abroad and not be prosecuted because they were born in Canada. I don't know if Khadr is guilty or not (though the evidence presented in public so far suggests that even Khadr believes he's guilty). But he does deserve the opportunity he is currently presented with to tell why he should not be found guilty of the serious charges he is facing.
 
Please.

There are a large number of liberal lawyers, just as there are a number of conservative lawyers. A good lawyer knows all the points which both sides will argue. Most good lawyers don't even get to pick what side they will present in court. But to confuse commentators with law displays a bit too much naivete for this forum.

The simple fact remains that Khadr is receiving due process, as attested to by the numerous Supreme Court decisions which have shaped this process.

But apparently some here believe that a child should be able to commit murder abroad and not be prosecuted because they were born in Canada. I don't know if Khadr is guilty or not (though the evidence presented in public so far suggests that even Khadr believes he's guilty). But he does deserve the opportunity he is currently presented with to tell why he should not be found guilty of the serious charges he is facing.

Nonsense, Gitmo is out of the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court. Which is why it was CREATED in the first place. To say you can deliver justice at a location that was selected to avoid due process set us on this slippery slope. The jury is a group of people from the military... what a sick joke. Even our govenment is using delay tatics to avoid OUR courts in this sorry mess.
 
The simple fact remains that Khadr is receiving due process, as attested to by the numerous Supreme Court decisions which have shaped this process.

The process would be unconstitutional if the trial were being held inside US territory, and for good reason. Canada should not accept that its citizens are subjected to this sort of mockery of justice, and if the US wants to present itself this way then as I said the US should tear down the Statue of Liberty as that's an equivalent message.

But apparently some here believe that a child should be able to commit murder abroad and not be prosecuted because they were born in Canada.

Nobody thinks that, and you know it. What people want is for him to be given a fair trial under the same sorts of laws that America would accept for its own citizens. Nothing less. Nothing more. The same level of justice, the same day in court that the US extends to rapists, serial killers, child molesters, and other scum of the earth: A fair trial, and a fair trial reveals that he's guilty then lock him up--let justice be served.

Of course the US Govt. so systematically abused his rights, including acts of torture, that in any constitutionally valid court most of the evidence against him would be tossed out and the prosecution severely reprimanded for their gross violation of his rights.

Obviously that's a problem, but let's be clear on exactly what the problem is: An out of control government that systematically violated human rights of people it unlawfully detained. If you think the problem lies somewhere else then your democratic credentials are questionable: You do not believe in the rule of law, you discount the constitution, and you don't care how things are done so long as your agenda is implemented, whatever the cost, whatever the means, no matter how foul.
 
Except this is a BRAND NEW BOOK. Get real, so many legal minds have expressed the opinion that this process is an utter scam. It is a HUGE shame on our country and a massive humiliation that we are the only lapdogs that could not protect our citizen from this kangaroo court. Canada's status as a subservient 2nd rate US ally has been sealed by Harpo who is our elected trained seal.....

LMAO....... yeah right...thanks for that Mr. Layton
 
well his father did

Yep, and you get 4 traffic violation points because your father qnce was caught speeding.
 
Yep, and you get 4 traffic violation points because your father [o]nce was caught speeding.
Lets say that your father was Vidkun Quisling, any reason why people (particularly in Norway) might regard you with shall we say a certain disdain higher than that of the son of a habitual speeder?
 
Lets say that your father was Vidkun Quisling, any reason why people (particularly in Norway) might regard you with shall we say a certain disdain higher than that of the son of a habitual speeder?

Be careful not to overcook the woolly mammoth.

People in Scandinavia do not believe in punishing people for the sins of their ancestors. Actually, I do not believe that is the case in Canada either. I can believe that neanderthals like yourself think differently.
 
People in Scandinavia do not believe in punishing people for the sins of their ancestors.
Yes doubtless that is why calling someone a Quisling in Norway is a guaranteed way to make sure that they want you to marry their favorite and much loved sister.
 
Yes doubtless that is why calling someone a Quisling in Norway is a guaranteed way to make sure that they want you to marry their favorite and much loved sister.

Go back to your cave and tend to the fire.
 
And here I've enjoyed my visits to the three Scandinavian Countries. :)

You picked up very little common sense. I am afraid you were distracted by the blondes.
 
The Board (jury) has been impaneled. Four men and three women all Commissioned Officers.


The Associated Press

U.S. Naval Station Guantanamo Bay (Cuba) — A smiling Omar Khadr appeared in a suit and tie Tuesday and greeted prospective jurors at the start of his trial, billed by defense lawyers as the first war-crimes prosecution of a child soldier since World War II.

Khadr, the Toronto-born son of an alleged al-Qaida financier, is the youngest prisoner at Guantanamo and the only remaining Westerner.

He was 15 when he allegedly hurled a grenade that killed a Delta Force soldier from New Mexico during a firefight in Afghanistan in 2002.

The trial will be closely watched as the first under President Obama, whose administration is weighing whether to use the embattled Guantanamo courts as a possible venue for dozens of other detainees — including “high-value” figures such as the self-professed mastermind of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and four alleged henchmen.

The Khadr case has been held up by legal wrangling at several versions of the tribunal system since he made his first appearance in the courthouse overlooking the Caribbean Sea in 2006.

The Canadian, now a bearded and broad-shouldered man of 23, traded his typical prison jumpsuit for a gray suit before the start of jury selection. As his Pentagon-appointed attorney introduced him to the pool of 15 U.S. military officers, Khadr stood and said to them in English: “How are you?” Defense lawyers and prosecutors spent much of the day asking prospective jurors their opinions on matters including the significance of a juvenile offender’s age and the treatment of detainees at Guantanamo Bay.

Advocates have argued that prosecuting somebody who was so young at the time of the alleged offense would violate international treaties protecting child soldiers. But the court sided with prosecutors, who argued that such protections do not apply to Khadr.

At one point Tuesday, however, the judge interrupted a prosecutor’s questioning to say that jurors could consider Khadr’s age in deciding whether he intended to commit a crime.

“It’s certainly something you may consider in deciding whether the government has proved its case beyond a reasonable doubt,” said the judge, Army Col. Pat Parrish.

Once a panel of at least five officers is seated, opening arguments are planned as early as Wednesday in a trial expected to last roughly three weeks.

Defense lawyers say Khadr was himself a victim, forced into war by a family with close ties to Osama bin Laden. His father, Ahmed Said Khadr, was an Egyptian-born Canadian citizen and alleged militant killed in 2003 when a Pakistani military helicopter shelled the house where he was staying with senior al-Qaida operatives.

“He’s not a real Taliban warrior. He’s a kid who was put in an unfortunate situation,” said Dennis Edney, a Canadian lawyer for Khadr.

Khadr faces a total of five charges including murder for allegedly killing U.S. Army Sgt. 1st Class Christopher Speer, 28, of Albuquerque, N.M., after a battle at an al-Qaida compound on July 27, 2002. Military prosecutors say he also planted explosive devices to kill coalition forces and spied on U.S. troops.

He has pleaded not guilty and faces a maximum life sentence if convicted.

Meanwhile a formal conviction is imminent for another detainee, al-Qaida cook Ibrahim Ahmed Mahmoud al-Qosi, who reached a plea agreement with military prosecutors. Details of the plea bargain with the 50-year-old from Sudan were sealed as part of the deal but will be revealed eventually following an official review, said Navy Capt. David Iglesias, a prosecution spokesman.

The system established by the Bush administration to prosecute terror suspects following Sept. 11 has yielded only three other convictions, including two detainees who have already served their sentences and returned home.

The Supreme Court in 2006 struck down one version of the military trials, known as commissions, before Congress and the Bush administration came up with new trial rules.

Obama revised them further to extend more legal protections to detainees.
 
Presumably you refer to the character created by Stieg Larsson? I thought you Dane's hadn't the greatest love for Swedes.

The girl with the dragon tatoo. I liked what she did to the parole officer. (yes, yes, I know it is fiction)
 
The Board (jury) has been impaneled. Four men and three women all Commissioned Officers.

Plainly a jury of his peers. I hear at least one of them lost soldiers in the same war he's on trial for fighting. Of course, when asked, the obviously biased juror said he wasn't biased by it--so it's all good, right?

I mean in a civilian trial it would be commonplace to select a jury from a pool of people who had in some way been victimized by similar events.