Could Incalls be in trouble?

I have read the news regarding the upgrading of "keeping a bawdy house", along with gambling, as part of a list of serious offences. IMHO, I strongly suspect that this has more to do with the federal government appearing to be tough on crime than anything of substance. My reasoning is as follows (specifically related to prostitution):

(1) "Keeping a common bawdy house" (i.e. keeping an incall SP location) is already illegal and has been for quite some time. In essence, the only reason that more incall locations have not been subjected to raids and shutdowns has to do more with the discretion of law enforcement and their priorities than anything related to legal matters. In Toronto (and I suspect in other larger cities such as Montreal and Vancouver), the police have from what I understand long made the determination that most incall agencies and independent incall SPs are not a top priority due to resource issues, and hence their focus has been on the sleazier, high traffic agencies which are, more often than not, operated by organized crime (most often Asian triad gangs or the Russian mafia).

(2) Based on my (admittedly somewhat limited) understanding of criminal law, vice investigations are the responsibility of the municipal police force, not the RCMP or the OPP (unless if the criminal activity crosses municipal boundaries). Federal changes in the listing of serious offences only make a difference if they are vigorously enforced -- if not, what is to change?

(3) Politicians across the political spectrum, whether they be the Conservatives or the Liberals, have for a long time now talked of being "tough on crime" for as long as I recall (even though the overall crime rate across many municipalities throughout Canada have been falling for some time now), particularly if they are increasingly unpopular or wish to draw attention from other matters (e.g. controversy related to the scrapping of the mandatory long-form census). This is just the latest chapter of the same old story from Ottawa.

The practical impact of these changes will thus in my opinion be minimal. After all, incalls still exist in the US, even with tougher laws on prostitution, and reputable agencies such as Mirage and Select have been smart enough not to attract any undue attention to themselves, leading to scrutiny from law enforcement.
 
The typical whitebread rural voter that Harper and his cronies pander to are the type who thinks a guy who goes for a simple rub and tug has the potential to be a Robert Pickton or a Paul Bernardo. The Cons are going to need to fill all those shiny new prisons somehow. Mandatory minimums for simple possession and being a found-in would probably score them some political points amongst the law-and-order types.
I can hardly wait for some Conservative MP to be nabbed as a found-in or charged with possession of a controlled substance.

Like Jaffer and his impaired and cocaine charges?
 
Legalized RLD's like those of Amsterdam and Hamburg would bring the government even more revenues as the ladies in European 'incalls' and 'outcall' agencies must declare their income for tax purposes and be checked regularly for std's to hold licenses.

It's unbelievable that in the 21st century that Canada is still in the Victorian era with prostitution laws. Regretably, as long as Canadians elect neo-cons like Harper and friends, this will never change.
 
Hello. I have been a long time viewer of the board and just signed up today to post on this thread. After reading extensively and having some first hand knowledge of the issue, these new powers granted to Police now open the door for them to go after every Agency providing Incalls. Here's the tricky thing, those Agencies won't have a clue until it's too late. I have to wonder if this is being done as a result of the outstanding constitutional challenge by Terri Jean Bedford. The gov running scared in advance of that decision supposed to come in September. With easy access to disposable cell phones however the police will not find this an easy task to complete.
It seems for the most part these Agencies are on their own and can expect no real public support.
The end of Incalls and upcoming potential incarceration for long standing Agency owners are at hand.
Maybe this is for the better as I don't believe there should be people making money hand over fist off the ladies.
 
Though having only 1 lady working incalls for you is not safe from LE with these new powers, the unit enforcing the laws for each Municipality is only so big and the idea is to go after the MONEY makers.

The focus is likely to be on the Agencies with multiple women working for them and there are plenty of those even right here on this board.
Any bets on who shall be the first to fall?
 
Incalls are illegal so big ones or independents should be careful because you never know when LE will get a burr under their butt and start sweeping everything because of the proposed new laws.
 
Though having only 1 lady working incalls for you is not safe from LE with these new powers, the unit enforcing the laws for each Municipality is only so big and the idea is to go after the MONEY makers.

The focus is likely to be on the Agencies with multiple women working for them and there are plenty of those even right here on this board.
Any bets on who shall be the first to fall?

Maybe I'm just being naive but I think it's unlikely that the escort agencies that advertise on TERB are going to get raided. I mean if that's the case then what's left for us pooners?
 
WTF they want to turn our country into America. America sucks, we should go the way of Europe.

Maybe I'll join the Rockslinger clan in Australia.

Query: Whatever happened to the police's priority of capturing G-20 thugs? Don't they cause more damage to society than little old you?
 
Really, its all about money, tax money. The government can go on about safety, community standards,bla bla bla... really it comes down to money. Think about the total toronto wide escort business. How much money is made and how much is reported in just a day? Multiply that by 364 (Xmas off..lol) and the I steal your money fat cats say whoa! Thats a big chunk of change we need to get our greedy little fingers on. Same as speeding, what a fucking joke! The whole system is designed to steal your money in the name of safety. If you believe that your an idiot. Its all about how much money the Government can take from you! The only organized crime I worry about is our multi levels of Government. Sorry if I got off topic...lol

Don't worry. We empathize.
 
In the National Post today, Terence Corcoran comes out swinging against the new prohibition laws, including the bawdy house foolishness:

http://www.financialpost.com/opinion/columnists/Prohibition/3371491/story.html

And in a related column, called "Playing to the Reactionaries," Conrad Black also questions some of the Tories' law and order stuff. "It is a howling mystery to me why the Harper government is seeing to placate the reactionary end of the law and order vote," Black says.

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...k-playing-to-the-reactionaries/#ixzz0vvfgcN4y

I suspect other voices will also emerge -- you can bet law professor Alan Young, who has a strong libertarian bent, will have something to say at some point. Publicly, the focus for many critics may be more on pot than prostitution, but I think there will be a backlash.

Thank you for posting these (I read Corcoran's article in another Terb thread).
 
I think people are missing the real power this Government Order gives. The OPP quote earlier in the thread gives you a big hint. In the past to obtain a wire tap you had to show a judge that you could not obtain evidence by other means ... a very high standard which meant that this means of investigating was not available to LE.

What this order does is to remove this standard and make it so much easier for LE to wire tap suspect people and obtain evidence. In the past LE might have known about the major Agencies, their owners etc., but having direct evidence that they are breaking the law would be difficult to obtain without a complaint. Now it would appear the suspicion of wrong doing maybe all that is needed to obtain a wire.


kf

Yes it facilitates LE's evidence-gathering tools and the penalties, but it doesn't change the existing laws against bawdy houses. Someone told me to be careful with MPs but I can't see how this increases the risk for 'non-SP services' which aren't even discussed on the phone (a wiretap would yield nothing). However, it does increase the risk to 'keepers'.
 
The practical impact of these changes will thus in my opinion be minimal. After all, incalls still exist in the US, even with tougher laws on prostitution, and reputable agencies such as Mirage and Select have been smart enough not to attract any undue attention to themselves, leading to scrutiny from law enforcement.

Really? And what justifies that opinion? They very publicly advertise Incalls on this Board? There is clearly an advertised breach of the laws. Not attracting undo attention? Oh, I beg to differ and realistically the long standing respect of these Agencies by Hobbyists won't mean squat after a planted bug has been removed and charges are laid. They fall under the class of Agencies that produce large revenues based on sheer number of ladies compared to otther smaller operations.
 
The law is like the referee in hockey, if LE enforces every single rule in the book every time, everybody would be in jail (unless the courts take a more rational approach). Same with the referee in hockey, if he calls every infraction every time, all the players would be in the penalty box.
 
The law is like the referee in hockey, if LE enforces every single rule in the book every time, everybody would be in jail (unless the courts take a more rational approach). Same with the referee in hockey, if he calls every infraction every time, all the players would be in the penalty box.

UHUH and did you miss the announcement on the recent approval of Super Prisons?.....Seems the Gov is preparing for an influx of Visitors to State Housing.
 
mruptonogood,

In the rest of my original post, I had stated before that the only reason more incalls in Toronto (and other larger cities such as Montreal and Vancouver, can't speak about other municipalities in Canada) have not been subjected to raids and shutdowns was because of questions of priorities by the police. Namely, the police do not have the resources to shut down all of these places and frankly don't care about them.

If the police cared about shutting these places down, even with existing laws they could go ahead and raid them and arrest the SPs and the owners, bug or no bug. The proposed changes in the law only stiffen the penalties, not the actual illegality.

Furthermore, the reputable agencies do not attract undue attention to themselves because they are reputable (e.g. no drugs, no violence, no suspected cases of human smuggling or sex slavery that I'm aware of) and practice caution in using multiple locations and being discreet in public (i.e. outside these boards).

Really? And what justifies that opinion? They very publicly advertise Incalls on this Board? There is clearly an advertised breach of the laws. Not attracting undo attention? Oh, I beg to differ and realistically the long standing respect of these Agencies by Hobbyists won't mean squat after a planted bug has been removed and charges are laid. They fall under the class of Agencies that produce large revenues based on sheer number of ladies compared to otther smaller operations.