The racist Democrat has died

GotGusto

New member
Jan 18, 2009
3,701
8
0
Robert Byrd, who died on June 28 aged 92, was the longest-serving senator in American history; first elected in 1958, he was the Democratic representative for West Virginia for 51 years, casting an unprecedented 18,680 roll call votes with an attendance record of 97 per cent. - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/politics-obituaries/7859555/Robert-Byrd.html


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Byrd

A former member of the KKK, Byrd once wrote: "I shall never fight in the armed forces with a Negro by my side... Rather I should die a thousand times, and see Old Glory trampled in the dirt never to rise again, than to see this beloved land of ours become degraded by race mongrels, a throwback to the blackest specimen from the wilds."
 
It was a different world. At one time in the 1920's, 10% of white American men belonged to the KKK. Harry Truman was once a member, also Hugo Black who went on to be one of the most liberal Supreme Court Justices and voted in favor of civil rights cases. Not to excuse Byrd's comments from decades before, but he did manage to move forward. Even George Wallace reached out to black communities in his later years.
 
Last edited:
I met him and had a brief conversation with him 15 years ago in DC. He seemed to me to be a very polite gentleman with a great sense of humour.
 
It was a different world. At one time in the 1920's, 10% of white American men belonged to the KKK. Harry Truman was once a member, also Hugo Black who went on to be one of the most liberal Supreme Court Justices and voted in favor of civil rights cases. Not to excuse Byrd's comments from decades before, but he did manage to move forward. Even George Wallace reached out to black communities in his later years.

Although Truman was a product of his time and did express racist beliefs, I don't believe there is evidence that he was a Klansman. This doesn't take away from the point you make, however.
 
Although Truman was a product of his time and did express racist beliefs, I don't believe there is evidence that he was a Klansman.

Yes there is. He was a member of the klan from 1920 to 1922, though I think he did it largely for political reasons. That's what men in society, especially in smaller southern cities, did in those days.
 
Being a Democract he largely got a free ride over such matters and less than sensitive remarks. Now Jesse Helms, and Strom Thurmond on the other hand. . . .

The fact that Jesse Helms was a right wing extremist who practiced the politics of hate and racial divisiveness had something to do with him not getting a free ride.
 
Yes there is. He was a member of the klan from 1920 to 1922, though I think he did it largely for political reasons. That's what men in society, especially in smaller southern cities, did in those days.

I should clarify, I don't believe there is strong evidence he was in the Klan. It's also possible I am forgetting something from the McCullough biography, as it has been 10 years since I read it. But a search just finds several maybes. Maybe he showed up for a while, or maybe he just paid the fee then backed out, or maybe it was his friend who joined and not him, etc. etc.


No, it wouldn't surprise me if he had been in the Klan, I just think it is still a point of contention among historians.
 
Byrd also admitted he'd been wrong in his younger days, apologized, and had a very good voting record on civil rights in the Senate. Presumably those are the main reasons so many people were willing to overlook his youth; he did a lot to try to make up for it.
 
I don't want to get into a debate or defend the KKK but there a historical fact that should be considered in the interest of some balance. The KKK was originally formed by returning Confederate soldiers to defend their women and properties from northern "carpetbaggers". The carpetbaggers were as hated in the Southern U.S. as the Orange Scots were hated in Ireland. Let's not debate this issue. It is far too sensitive.
 
Robert Byrd filibustered for over 14 hours against the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

I guess I should clarify. Byrd, Helms, and Thurmond all practiced racist politics. Byrd at least became a civil rights advocate later in his career. Whether that was political convenience or a true change, I don't know. Thurmond definitely evolved some racial sensitivity later in his career as well. Again, convenience or the real thing, I can't read minds. Helms, on the other hand, practiced a bitter kind of politics to the end. That is why he didn't get a "free ride". The American people tended to forgive former segregationists if they felt they had changed with the times.

Whether they shoud be forgiven or should ever be elected is another topic. But, you should not be surprised that Helms did not get a "free ride".
 
I don't want to get into a debate or defend the KKK but there a historical fact that should be considered in the interest of some balance. The KKK was originally formed by returning Confederate soldiers to defend their women and properties from northern "carpetbaggers". The carpetbaggers were as hated in the Southern U.S. as the Orange Scots were hated in Ireland. Let's not debate this issue. It is far too sensitive.

And quickly became a mechanism to terrorize blacks. Their original Grand Wizard Nathan Bedford Forest quit after the KKK had become to violent even for him, which considering his conduct in the Civil War was saying something. It was a blacklash to the Reconstruction, and the suddenness of blacks being brought into the legislative process. Too much, too quick.
 
Byrd also admitted he'd been wrong in his younger days, apologized, and had a very good voting record on civil rights in the Senate. Presumably those are the main reasons so many people were willing to overlook his youth; he did a lot to try to make up for it.

Younger days? He voted against the Civil Rights Act in 1964. He was 48 years old at the time.

Byrd never "moved forward". The world around him moved forward and he merely rode the wave. Career politicians like him should eat shit and die. I'd piss on his grave.
 
Last edited:
Got anything he didn't later recant? Perhaps "younger days" was the wrong wording, but his later career in the senate was much better. Cynics may say it's because he knew it was required for him to get leadership positions in the Democratic Party, but he could have switched parties as so many old segregationist Democrats did. Even admitting he was wrong earlier on, while not a huge deal, puts him ahead of most of those old segregationists.
 
Cynics may say it's because he knew it was required for him to get leadership positions in the Democratic Party, but he could have switched parties as so many old segregationist Democrats did. Even admitting he was wrong earlier on, while not a huge deal, puts him ahead of most of those old segregationists.


His words, not mine:

In 1997, he told an interviewer he would encourage young people to become involved in politics, but to "Be sure you avoid the Ku Klux Klan. Don't get that albatross around your neck. Once you've made that mistake, you inhibit your operations in the political arena."

Wow, such deep insight and moral grounding from Mr. Byrd.

Byrd was smarter than his segregationist buddies. It's a lot easier to rise in the ranks if you're a racist Democrat than if you're a racist Republican. And Byrd did just that.
 
Winds of change

Politicians have an uncanny sense of knowing which way the wind is blowing.......if society had not changed I doubt very much he would have.........and if there was still segregation he would still have been spouting his racist rhetoric.