Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

No, those aren't the issue. It's dad did something that put his son's health at risk by most standards and may still. He's an amateur doing something that a lot of professional artist won't do. By the way, it looks like shit.

If the dad tattooed his son he'd deserves a smack for the same reason.


Did I say it looked like shit?

Atleast we both agree with that part. But you can't say the issue is solely the dad put his son's health at risk (which is debatable, more like he inflicted pain on his son), without also saying consent is an issue. Otherwise, any tattoo artist or anyone else who does body modifications would be charged. The reason this story was so controversial WAS because of the kid's age, and hence his inability to give proper consent.

The fact that many people think he's an asshole for branding his son isn't legal grounds to get charged. Inflicting a certain amount of pain without proper consent is. Inflicting a certain amount of pain WITH proper consent isn't. Therefore, the issue IS consent. Follow?
 
Atleast we both agree with that part. But you can't say the issue is solely the dad put his son's health at risk (which is debatable, more like he inflicted pain on his son), without also saying consent is an issue. Otherwise, any tattoo artist or anyone else who does body modifications would be charged. The reason this story was so controversial WAS because of the kid's age, and hence his inability to give proper consent.

The fact that many people think he's an asshole for branding his son isn't legal grounds to get charged. Inflicting a certain amount of pain without proper consent is. Inflicting a certain amount of pain WITH proper consent isn't. Therefore, the issue IS consent. Follow?

Good post, rhuarc. I believe exactly that, the father may be an asshole but simply being an asshole isn't criminal. And thank goodness because the jails would be bursting. The issue in the case that makes this criminal, is the consent of the children, and whether or not the father, as the parent, can consent to this type of mutilation and whether the children can.

Aside from the pain he inflicted on his kids, the permanent disfigurement, and the potential risks involved, the main issue here is consent.

It is too bad there hasn't been much talk of the mother, who voiced her dissent. I am willing to bet that she files a civil lawsuit against the father when the criminal charges are finished being heard. I am also willing to bet that she will win.
 
The jury in the OP article did not convict. Was it because they agreed with you I do not know.

And now we do know, some of the jury have spoken with the media about their decision:

http://www.komonews.com/news/local/93721479.html

juror said:
The jury had difficulty in determining if the father branding the boys was an assault," Lidstrom said, adding that the jury believed the act of branding was not necessarily an assault.

"[The verdict] was based on the understanding and the evidence brought forth that there was no struggle, it was not done against their will, there was no maliciousness intended and they were careful in putting it all together to do this," Lidstrom added.

I'd like to call out to toguy's attention that the jury specifically considered maliciousness, that this was a factor in deciding it was not an assault. That makes toguy flat out wrong in his claim that maliciousness only factors into sentencing and not into determining whether a crime occurred. A crime did not occur in part because there was no maliciousness.

We also have an answer to blackrock's question:

Did the father use antiseptic?

Which is yes:

Seamonds said:
He compared the practice to ear-piercing and said that getting hit with a water balloon "hurts worse."

Seamands said in testimony that he had researched the practice on the Internet, had purchased ointment with advice from a drug store employee to have a friend perform the procedure on himself and had not intended to brand his boys until they insisted he do so.

Oops, note that the procedure doesn't hurt much, there is not a lot of pain--getting hit with a water balloon hurts worse.

And from the judge we get this:

judge said:
"Whether this is or is not a crime turns to a large extent on whether the result was disfigurement."

Apparently the jury accepted that it was not disfigurement, that it was, to use the R v Wilson terminology, a "desirable adornment".

Finally we can also answer Aardvark, that this is in fact legal for consenting adults, because that was specifically why there was no charge in the case of the 18 year old daughter:

Seamands also branded his then-18-year-old daughter, Paige Davis of Boise, Idaho, on the calf. Since she was old enough to give consent, no charges were filed in her branding.
 
Great minds and all that.

heh. I've said from the start that for a parent to facilitate this, is unconscionable. A parents job is to protect their children from making stupid decisions, not to help them out with that. I said it back on page two, that children want to do lots of stupid things, but it's the parents job to kibosh stupidity.

At the ages of 13 and 15, the children do not have the mental maturity and critical thinking skills required to think about situations in the longer term, to see the consequences. That is why they have parents, to help guide and protect the children until they themselves are capable of this kind of thinking. The father here completely and utterly failed in his responsibility to his children.

When the child is of age and emancipated, they can make their own decisions, stupid or otherwise.
 
I loved this comment from the father, 'Seamands minimized the impact of branding his children in a December 2008 interview with county Sheriff's Office investigators, comparing it to ear-piercing and getting hit by a water balloon.

It kind of tells you where his head is at. The civil suit might be an idea, but it would probably tear the family apart.

OJ and Lizzie would be proud of those jurors.
 
I loved this comment from the father, 'Seamands minimized the impact of branding his children in a December 2008 interview with county Sheriff's Office investigators, comparing it to ear-piercing and getting hit by a water balloon.

It kind of tells you where his head is at. The civil suit might be an idea, but it would probably tear the family apart.

Who would file a civil suit? The children supported him and were reportedly happy that he was acquitted. As for the pain level, that is in line with the links I found--do you have any evidence that branding hurts more than getting hit with a water balloon? I'd like to see it.
 
Who would file a civil suit? The children supported him and were reportedly happy that he was acquitted. As for the pain level, that is in line with the links I found--do you have any evidence that branding hurts more than getting hit with a water balloon? I'd like to see it.

Another one for the file people.
 
Please keep your irrelevant comments to your thread, you have a place for your pointless garbage please use it and keep other threads, like this one, free of your nonsense.

Ooow!

I wonder how much time you spend actually shaving in the morning when you`re standing in front of the mirror. What you do the rest of the time? How difficult is it to shave with a big grin on your face?
 
So I take it from your silence that you do not have any reason whatsoever to believe that a properly done branding hurts worse than getting hit by a water balloon.
 
So I take it from your silence that you do not have any reason whatsoever to believe that a properly done branding hurts worse than getting hit by a water balloon.

Wrong again, but that's not new. No, my silence is from my habit of not answering idiotic questions form idiotic people. Even Sheik thinks your 'bloody idiot.'
 
OK, so in summary, I've documented multiple sources that assert branding is relatively painless, and you've spouted off your mouth and called me a bloody idiot. It's pretty clear here that you haven't got a clue what you're talking about, you just like the sound of your own voice, and you have nothing whatsoever to say.
 
Who would file a civil suit? The children supported him and were reportedly happy that he was acquitted. As for the pain level, that is in line with the links I found--do you have any evidence that branding hurts more than getting hit with a water balloon? I'd like to see it.

The mother would file the civil suit. As the children's other parent in a shared custody agreement, she also has a right to either give, or rescind consent where her children are concerned. The mother was quoted in articles as being 'horrified' when she found out the children were branded, and 'saddened' by the verdict.

Whether or not the children were happy with it, makes no difference at all, seeing as they are underage and did not have their mothers consent. She could sue the father for making this decision, and for allowing the children to be branded without her knowledge and without giving her a chance to state her dissent.

As for tearing the family apart, the family is split anyways, and the parents breakup happened before this branding incident...the family was already torn apart.
 
Well sort of, but not to the question and the question was idiotic.

Presumably you think it is "idiotic" to assert that branding is relatively painless, but that is just your ignorant assumption. You actually have no idea. I've provided you with a variety of sources asserting that because the area goes numb it is only painful for a few brief seconds and afterwards there is really not any pain at all.

You simply refuse to admit that you're wrong, and you respond to being shown that you are wrong by calling others idiots. It basically shows that you are not man enough to own up to your mistakes.
 
Presumably you think it is "idiotic" to assert that branding is relatively painless, but that is just your ignorant assumption. You actually have no idea. I've provided you with a variety of sources asserting that because the area goes numb it is only painful for a few brief seconds and afterwards there is really not any pain at all.

You simply refuse to admit that you're wrong, and you respond to being shown that you are wrong by calling others idiots. It basically shows that you are not man enough to own up to your mistakes.

Don't presume, you really bad at that also.
 
Nope. You fail at comprehension. Try again. Go back to square one--start with grade 1 reading lessons. The articles you quotes clearly assert that in the face of modern wound treatment--like the antiseptic sprays or just plain soap and water--that complications from branding are rare. You read that yourself. You chose to ignore it.

Why?

I can only imagine it's because you think you can win a debate through lies and deception.

I'm surprised that blackrock13 didn't jump all over the obvious here. Or Fuji's lack of 1st grade writing skills.:p