Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

This isn't about a tattoo or a 17 year old for that matter. It's about a moron picking up a branding iron and branding his children.

This stopped being about the moron picking up a branding iron and branding his children a long time ago. It is now about the morin defending the other moron.
 
This isn't about a tattoo or a 17 year old for that matter. It's about a moron picking up a branding iron and branding his children.

Exactly. How easy it is to skew the debate with a bunch of irrelevant information and points! I am not sure how many times we can say that a branding is NOT the same as a tattoo... but there it is once more for fuji.

lol@ toguy...
 
This isn't about a tattoo or a 17 year old for that matter. It's about a moron picking up a branding iron and branding his children.

Now you're just repeating yourself. I suggest you sit back and digest some of the information you've been given about human branding not being quite what you thought it is. Formulate some conclusion on why you think it's the same, or different, than branding, and then share it with us. That would be useful.
 
So this passage means nothing to you from somebody who really knows;

Meanwhile you just ignore the 10 or so comments from people saying they experienced little pain after the first few seconds... nice. Talk about cherry picking! You're a piece of work.

If you want to understand just how much I exceed you in intellectual and debating honesty you can look back and notice that I already mentioned the part you quoted and drew attention to it.

This however:


That's a useful addition to the thread, rare for you. I think it gives a good summary of the debate and the issues. It points out that there is controversy, which there is. Where do you draw the line?

In terms of medical risk of branding itself (as opposed to, say, cutting off nipples) I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which a couple of MD's assert that it is reasonably safe in Western practice.

Certainly I agree with the article when it points out that some of these procedures become medical procedures--amputations certainly.
 
Meanwhile you just ignore the 10 or so comments from people saying they experienced little pain after the first few seconds... nice. Talk about cherry picking! You're a piece of work.

If you want to understand just how much I exceed you in intellectual and debating honesty you can look back and notice that I already mentioned the part you quoted and drew attention to it.

This however:

That's a useful addition to the thread, rare for you. I think it gives a good summary of the debate and the issues. It points out that there is controversy, which there is. Where do you draw the line?

In terms of medical risk of branding itself (as opposed to, say, cutting off nipples) I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which a couple of MD's assert that it is reasonably safe in Western practice.

Certainly I agree with the article when it points out that some of these procedures become medical procedures--amputations certainly.


What I will do is ignore comments from people who don't want to admit they screwed up and did something stupid and put more credence in medical professionals, especially a cosmetic surgeon who may have treat a few, and a responsible practitioner in the business of body modification.

You wouldn't useful if you stepped it.

I'm glad I haven't eaten yet, excessive intellect and honesty.

Since you weren't considerate enough to provide a number for Sillygirls thread, I'll have to hunt for it, but nothing she posted grabbed my attention as out of line.
 
Meanwhile you just ignore the 10 or so comments from people saying they experienced little pain after the first few seconds... nice. Talk about cherry picking! You're a piece of work.

If you want to understand just how much I exceed you in intellectual and debating honesty you can look back and notice that I already mentioned the part you quoted and drew attention to it.

This however:

That's a useful addition to the thread, rare for you. I think it gives a good summary of the debate and the issues. It points out that there is controversy, which there is. Where do you draw the line?

In terms of medical risk of branding itself (as opposed to, say, cutting off nipples) I refer you to SillyGirl's article in which a couple of MD's assert that it is reasonably safe in Western practice.

Certainly I agree with the article when it points out that some of these procedures become medical procedures--amputations certainly.

I finally found the reference in post #148, one of Sillygirls 7 post in this thread, all of which had very negative comments about you. I especially like the one where she wondered if you were high.

I really had to search for you quote(?) and I believed finally found it tucked a way amoung a whole bunch of really serious negative comments about the proceedure and found the quote to be incomplete;

'Branding has recently become more fashionable in Western countries [1,3], where it is increasingly practised as body art. In these settings branding is usually performed in safe conditions, or with more precautions against serious infection, and is not used for counter irritation as it is in people whose health is already seriously compromised. Branding in Western society is described as a behavior associated with a high level of substance use, sexual intercourse and multiple partners, high risk sexual activity, smoking, marijuana use, suicidal ideation and suicidal and homicidal attempts [9-11].'


Comment s such as the following were far more compelling;

From the same authors.


'This article describes the complications of skin branding which still has therapeutic uses in some cultural societies. Severe medical complications of skin branding are worrisome and these risks far outweigh the benefits of these procedures. In the present study we have seen complications without therapeutic benefit, therefore universal recognition of the complications of skin branding is necessary among both patients and physicians, as it will have crucial implications in the management of patients who seek branding for a variety of medical reasons due to the lack of availability of modern medical resources.'

'There are two populations with different cultural backgrounds who seek branding for entirely different reasons. There is no direct association between the behavior associated risk problem in Western populations and the complications seen in our patients. Thus people who seek branding for body-art do not have the same sequelae of acute infections because of better sterile techniques. However, it is unclear whether the use of a sterile procedure in the chronically ill who seek branding would not still result in severe local complications. Thus a careful assessment and discussion of host factors should be an integral aspect in people who seek branding for various reasons.'


In the long-term, branding procedures can cause disfigurement from contractures (especially over joint surfaces), scars, hair loss, keloids, orthokeratotic hyperkeratosis, acanthosis and squamous cell carcinoma (Marjolin's ulcer). Other medical complications include foreign body reaction, oral and tooth complications, aspiration and hypoxia, edema and swelling, infections and viral transmission including hepatitis and HIV

This covers less than half the full body of the work, but even you should get the drift.
 
Now you're just repeating yourself. I suggest you sit back and digest some of the information you've been given about human branding not being quite what you thought it is. Formulate some conclusion on why you think it's the same, or different, than branding, and then share it with us. That would be useful.

I don't need to digest anymore information on branding humans and children. It's picking up a really hot piece of metal and placing it on the skin of a child. It burns and hurts like a MF. I don't see the positive aspects of doing this to a child or anyone for that matter. It's still exactly what I thought it was from the first second I read the article. I think others have done a fine job of pointing out the various and numerous medical reasons branding people is bad and you ignore them. I don't need to repeat them. Also, I don't need the medical evidence provided by doctors to conclude that it's a bad idea, not good for you and should under no circumstances be done to a child. That's just plain common sense.
 
Well put. The fact that we have to argue that branding a kid is bad is obvious evidence of this.

Hear! Hear! To me, there has never been any other argument. However, I guess to some, this practice is A-okay. Different strokes, I guess. But that doesn't mean I can't say the person who says it's okay is a douche bag.

Btw, if you think branding your children is a legal practice (no matter what your rationalization)...you are a douche bag.
 
I am not sure how many times we can say that a branding is NOT the same as a tattoo... but there it is once more for fuji.

Both tattooing and branding involve a certain degree of pain and risk. Tattooing involves repeatedly puncturing the skin and inserting pigment. The other obviously involves the use of extreme heat or cold. Where do you draw the line between what is serious bodily harm and what isn't? If one is more socially acceptable than the other, does that make one right and the other punishable?

The issue here isn't daddy hurt me, it's daddy acquiesced to my request when I'm not old enough to give binding consent. Would it be any different if he decided to tattoo his initials on his kid's arms with their consent? Why should it?
 
Both tattooing and branding involve a certain degree of pain and risk. Tattooing involves repeatedly puncturing the skin and inserting pigment. The other obviously involves the use of extreme heat or cold. Where do you draw the line between what is serious bodily harm and what isn't? If one is more socially acceptable than the other, does that make one right and the other punishable?

The issue here isn't daddy hurt me, it's daddy acquiesced to my request when I'm not old enough to give binding consent. Would it be any different if he decided to tattoo his initials on his kid's arms with their consent? Why should it?

No, those aren't the issue. It's dad did something that put his son's health at risk by most standards and may still. He's an amateur doing something that a lot of professional artist won't do. By the way, it looks like shit.

If the dad tattooed his son he'd deserves a smack for the same reason.

Did I say it looked like shit?
 
'This article describes the complications of skin branding which still has therapeutic uses in some cultural societies. Severe medical complications of skin branding are worrisome and these risks far outweigh the benefits of these procedures.

As usual you are dishonest. You knew when you posted that that it specifically referred to third world countries that lack proper sanitation. Yet you intentionally chose to misrepresent it.

I know you're a fuck up. You know you're a fuck up. Go ahead and post something to try and convince other people that you're not--but we both know what sort of dishonest stunt you just pulled.


There is no direct association between the behavior associated risk problem in Western populations and the complications seen in our patients. Thus people who seek branding for body-art do not have the same sequelae of acute infections because of better sterile techniques. However, it is unclear whether the use of a sterile procedure in the chronically ill who seek branding would not still result in severe local complications. Thus a careful assessment and discussion of host factors should be an integral aspect in people who seek branding for various reasons.'

Yup. So if you're chronically ill with a disease, don't get a branding until you're well. That's what it says. Everyone else is OK.

You really are a piece of work.
 
No, those aren't the issue. It's dad did something that put his son's health at risk

Nope. You fail at comprehension. Try again. Go back to square one--start with grade 1 reading lessons. The articles you quotes clearly assert that in the face of modern wound treatment--like the antiseptic sprays or just plain soap and water--that complications from branding are rare. You read that yourself. You chose to ignore it.

Why?

I can only imagine it's because you think you can win a debate through lies and deception.
 
What I will do is ignore comments from people who don't want to admit they screwed up

What you do is ignore facts you don't like. You aren't worthy of any further response, and while I'm expecting some snide response you KNOW what I'm talking about. You have lost this debate. I know it. You know it.

Now let's hear your sad pathetic insult and be done with it, go ahead and show us all what you're about.
 
Nope. You fail at comprehension. Try again. Go back to square one--start with grade 1 reading lessons. The articles you quotes clearly assert that in the face of modern wound treatment--like the antiseptic sprays or just plain soap and water--that complications from branding are rare. You read that yourself. You chose to ignore it.

Why?

I can only imagine it's because you think you can win a debate through lies and deception.

Did the father use antiseptic?
 
Did the father use antiseptic?

Do you have proof he did not? He used a propane torch. Someone who had not read up on branding would not have done that--that suggests he is well read on the topic, not just acting randomly. I would assume that he was following a proper procedure, given he started it out with the right equipment--but who knows. I am sure you have no reason to think he did not.

My guess is that the jury heard all the evidence and realized he'd done this right, learned it's not painful, understood it was desired, saw that he did it safely--and acquitted him.
 

Those severe consequences of branding only happen when the brand is not properly taken care of afterwards. It is extremely rare in Western countries for there to be any significant problem after a brand is applied. That is because anyone with at least a highschool education knows to keep the brand clean and wash it with soap and water. Some go further and apply antisceptic creams, which is what the branding websites suggest.

The only people who get into medical situations following a branding are people who do not keep it sterile afterwards via soap and water and other simple things. In 3rd world countries, such as blackrock's article discussed, people have difficulty accessing clean water and so their wounds get infected. In America clean water comes out of a tap. Soap can be purchased from any store. Problems are rare.
 
Do you have proof he did not? He used a propane torch. Someone who had not read up on branding would not have done that--that suggests he is well read on the topic, not just acting randomly. I would assume that he was following a proper procedure, given he started it out with the right equipment--but who knows. I am sure you have no reason to think he did not.

My guess is that the jury heard all the evidence and realized he'd done this right, learned it's not painful, understood it was desired, saw that he did it safely--and acquitted him.

I simply asked you the question. We'll let other readers chuckle where they may.

Funny thing about juries. They found OJ Simpson and Lizzie Borden not guilty. Tell me if I'm wrong, but the verdict in this case was a hung jury, yes/no.
 
I simply asked you the question.

If it turns out that he used antisceptic, do you agree that he should be acquitted? If not, then why would this question matter to you? If it's a relevant question then you are saying that those who take proper care of the wound are innocent. If it's not a relevant question in your view why ask it?