Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

As so those fact you spouted weren't yours, but somebody else's. A few references would be nice. We know how good you are in twisting facts to suit your purpose.

There's an article here for example: http://poundedink.com/human-branding-body-modification/

The article starts out saying "the most painful" but read down in the comments and you will see a lot of people talking about their experience, and how it only hurts for a few seconds, after which it usually becomes completely numb--if done properly. For example this quote:

I got my first brand 2 days ago. It was interesting to say the least. I go to a welding school, and there’s a machine shop class next door, I had a kid make a clover out of a piece of 1/4 inch stainless steel, the clover itself is solid, flat, and about 2 inches in diameter. I welded a 1/4 inch x 7 inch rod to the back of it. (just for the record, i’ve always been known as a f@#*ing nutter). As soon as I was done welding it, (for those who don’t know, when you weld metal it gets RED hot) I grabbed it and stuck it right to my arm. And YES, it hurt. I held it for about 3 seconds or so. Pretty quickly afterwards it stopped hurting so much and felt like a hit, like I had a slight bruise. Then when I started poking at it, lol, I realized it was totally numb and stiff like old wet then dried leather, lol. I’ve just been putting anti bacterial spray on it and I must say it looks pretty good.
 
I disagree with all of it except for the part about George W. Bush being branded. The man is the mental equivalent of a cow and I see no problems with branding him. I'm also not surprised that he and you share a common bond.

Are you of the opinion that adults can consent to being branded?
 
Whatever floats your boat. But when you do it to your kids, it's a whole new ball of wax.

I have agreed throughout this thread that there are additional issues around consent in that case, but I don't think it's clear cut. I imagine it differs by jurisdiction.

Let me ask you though: How about tongue piercings? Should someone be charged with assault if they apply a tongue piercing to a consenting 17 year old whose parents also consent?
 
In post #311 you introduced the fact that heating the branding iron to 2000°F, would allow for a painless application but nowhere in any reports on the trial was it stated that the branding iron was heated to that temperature. You're guessing again. So far any forum and BB I can find says that the work is done 200-400°C, and so much lower so you analysis is flawed big time.

Does it hurt? Just watch a cow fight the branding and jump when they get it and their hide is up to 11mm thick. That's why they're tied down or cradled in. Compare that to human skin at 2mm.
 
In post #311 you introduced the fact that heating the branding iron to 2000°F, would allow for a painless application

I didn't say painless. I said far less painful than you would think. The link I provided includes many examples of people saying their brand was relatively painless after a few seconds. Of course it's painful for the few seconds that it's being applied, but the pain is over with pretty quickly.

Do your own research you'll find out nerves die at any significant temperature and that, for example, when hospitals treat 3rd degree burns they generally do not apply an anesthetic because the burn victim can't feel anything anyway in that case. (They will apply anesthetic to other areas not as severely burned obviously.)
 
I have agreed throughout this thread that there are additional issues around consent in that case, but I don't think it's clear cut. I imagine it differs by jurisdiction.

Let me ask you though: How about tongue piercings? Should someone be charged with assault if they apply a tongue piercing to a consenting 17 year old whose parents also consent?

Don't go for it. We're talking about brading a 15 year old, not tongue piercing and as earlier pointed out earlier in one post, the law is grey, and liable to change in Ontario, as to what can safely and legally be done in a tattoo parlour. The doctors in my reference seem to make it clearly not safe and their not interns fresh out of school either.
 
I have agreed throughout this thread that there are additional issues around consent in that case, but I don't think it's clear cut. I imagine it differs by jurisdiction.

Let me ask you though: How about tongue piercings? Should someone be charged with assault if they apply a tongue piercing to a consenting 17 year old whose parents also consent?

I think a tongue piercing is a different story as is a 17 year old that might be able to give legal consent. But no, I am not a fan of people that brand, tattoo, pierce or otherwise allow their children to do something that they might regret had they been old enough to understand the ramifications of what they were doing.
 
I didn't say painless. I said far less painful than you would think. The link I provided includes many examples of people saying their brand was relatively painless after a few seconds. Of course it's painful for the few seconds that it's being applied, but the pain is over with pretty quickly.

Do your own research you'll find out nerves die at any significant temperature and that, for example, when hospitals treat 3rd degree burns they generally do not apply an anesthetic because the burn victim can't feel anything anyway in that case. (They will apply anesthetic to other areas not as severely burned obviously.)

You're are correct, LESS painful. So now, instead of 'Holy f**king mother of God that hurts', it's 'for f**k sakes that hurts', don't touch me.

Just one for now, http://poundedink.com/human-branding-body-modification/

I have no doubt there are more that say the same.

One phrase stuck out. branding is the most painful form of body modification

'Today we’ll look into perhaps the most painful of all body modifications, human branding. Branding is a process that involves burning the skin in a manner that will result in a permanent scar or mark, usually in a pattern or the shape of a specific symbol.'

'Branding works through the process of controlled injury and should never be considered “Safe”. Although if applied by a professional with experience in branding the risk could be considered acceptable.'


...... and don't even think of referring to the old man as almost a professional.
 
He plainly wrote that he thinks branding is like having your arm broken--something that not even adults can consent to.
In the example you chose to use, Hazing, that is I believe the case, and there is case law on point if you wish to take the time to research it. Might it be true in all cases involving adults, there can be disagreement, otherwise would there ever be trials?

Further unlike your tattoo and piecing examples and more like the article Blackrock posted branding is always going to involve permanent disfigurement (baring fairly extensive plastic surgery) and pain. Even in Ontario this is a grey area of the law, and seemingly it is far greyer there than here.

Finally, this is all a sideshow to the real issue is it possible for a father to give unilateral consent* to a permanent disfigurement of minor children (13 and 15). And was this jury’s failure to convict on the charge of Assault in the Second Degree merely a case of jury confusion.


* during the course of a divorce action where child custody is an issue.
 
Whoever said that getting a burn could result in respiratory distress was entirely correct. In addition, electrolyte imbalances, shock and scarring (which can be disabling) occurs. If you factor in the risks of infection and the fact that a "branding" can not be removed, this procedure is not without risk no matter where you live.

And it is painful, no matter how you look at it.
 
By the way, I don't have a cat.

I do, however, have a Jack Russell terrier who, although she is a complete spaz, agrees that branding your children is a heinous and illegal act. :D
 
I think a tongue piercing is a different story as is a 17 year old that might be able to give legal consent.

Can you articulate why it's different? It is presumably about as painful, and presumably carries about the same risk of infection.

This part is true of tattoos as well:

But no, I am not a fan of people that brand, tattoo, pierce or otherwise allow their children to do something that they might regret

Is it your view that it's criminal assault for a 17 year old to get a tattoo with their parents consent?

People react emotionally to the idea of "branding" but the reality is neither as painful, nor as dangerous as you think, and cannot be clearly distinguished from piercing or tattoos in terms of coming up with a reason why it should be treated differently.

I suspect the defense presented all this information to the jury and that is why they acquitted. Perhaps at first they had the same reaction as everyone else, "OMG burning flesh! SICK!", but then as they heard testimony from witnesses about the reality of branding they realized it wasn't so bad. Who knows though.
 
By the way, I don't have a cat.

I do, however, have a Jack Russell terrier who, although she is a complete spaz, agrees that branding your children is a heinous and illegal act. :D

Well a Jack Russell is definitely smarter than fujii. No contest there at all.
 
Can you articulate why it's different? It is presumably about as painful, and presumably carries about the same risk of infection.

This part is true of tattoos as well:

Is it your view that it's criminal assault for a 17 year old to get a tattoo with their parents consent?

People react emotionally to the idea of "branding" but the reality is neither as painful, nor as dangerous as you think, and cannot be clearly distinguished from piercing or tattoos in terms of coming up with a reason why it should be treated differently.

I suspect the defense presented all this information to the jury and that is why they acquitted. Perhaps at first they had the same reaction as everyone else, "OMG burning flesh! SICK!", but then as they heard testimony from witnesses about the reality of branding they realized it wasn't so bad. Who knows though.

So this passage means nothing to you from somebody who really knows;

'Today we’ll look into perhaps the most painful of all body modifications, human branding. Branding is a process that involves burning the skin in a manner that will result in a permanent scar or mark, usually in a pattern or the shape of a specific symbol.'

From my other reference;

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/De...+performed+tattoo+parlours/2760389/story.html

The doctors weren't being emotional they were most knowledgeable and clinical. Do you know more than them?

Dr. Wayne Carman, president of the Canadian Society for Aesthetic (Cosmetic) Plastic Surgery, says anyone who performs a surgical procedure -- which he defines broadly as an act that involves significant breaking of the skin and that requires suturing or stitching and healing -- should have medical training.

"For someone to take on some of these ideas -- even splitting a tongue -- it's not something you do in some-one's basement," he said.


Dr. Richard Warren, a spokesman for the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgery, says some procedures clearly cross the line.

He said life-threatening complications could result if the modifications are not performed properly.

"At some point, invasive body modification becomes practising medicine without a licence," he said.


There's no consensus within the tattoo and piercing industry. Calgary tattoo artist Steve Peace says he thinks most practitioners of extreme body modification are unqualified and unaware of the risks.

"Where do you stop? Now, they're cutting nipples off," he said. "I'm a tattoo artist. I'm not a doctor."

But most doctors won't perform these types of procedures, said Russ Foxx, a body-modification specialist in Vancouver. "That leaves us in a predicament. Who do I go to?" he said.

Foxx said he learns how to perform procedures from talking to veteran practitioners, reading books and travelling to conventions.

He says he always informs clients of the risks involved before beginning any procedure.

Too much regulation could have the effect of driving these activities further underground, said Jason MacDonald, an environmental health officer in Edmonton who inspects tattoo parlours to make sure instruments are sanitized and records are properly kept.

MacDonald added that new forms of body modification are constantly coming out.

If lawmakers start banning certain procedures, he said, the practitioners will just start doing "10 more things that we hadn't thought of."


You, of course, know more than these people.
 
Right thread, Right time.

Be careful and don't pull a Fuji by bringing things in that muddy the points. If any or all those hypotheticals were relevant, the reports might have said something to give the shocking verdict and father some slack, but it wasn't. The part that gets me is it was a mistrial on a hung jury. We can't paint all the jurors as dumb asses.

Weren't there two charges? 2nd and 4th degree assault. Now a second trial? The good news might be that 4th degree assault carries a penalty up to a year in jail and/or $5000. May be he'll get a taste of his own medicine there.
 
Right thread, Right time.

Be careful and don't pull a Fuji by bringing things in that muddy the points. If any or all those hypotheticals were relevant, the reports might have said something to give the shocking verdict and father some slack, but it wasn't. The part that gets me is it was a mistrial on a hung jury. We can't paint all the jurors as dumb asses.

Weren't there two charges? 2nd and 4th degree assault. Now a second trial? The good news might be that 4th degree assault carries a penalty up to a year in jail and/or $5000. May be he'll get a taste of his own medicine there.

One can only hope real justice be served in this case.
 
Can you articulate why it's different? It is presumably about as painful, and presumably carries about the same risk of infection.

This part is true of tattoos as well:


Is it your view that it's criminal assault for a 17 year old to get a tattoo with their parents consent?

People react emotionally to the idea of "branding" but the reality is neither as painful, nor as dangerous as you think, and cannot be clearly distinguished from piercing or tattoos in terms of coming up with a reason why it should be treated differently.

I suspect the defense presented all this information to the jury and that is why they acquitted. Perhaps at first they had the same reaction as everyone else, "OMG burning flesh! SICK!", but then as they heard testimony from witnesses about the reality of branding they realized it wasn't so bad. Who knows though.

This isn't about a tattoo or a 17 year old for that matter. It's about a moron picking up a branding iron and branding his children.