Can you articulate why it's different? It is presumably about as painful, and presumably carries about the same risk of infection.
This part is true of tattoos as well:
Is it your view that it's criminal assault for a 17 year old to get a tattoo with their parents consent?
People react emotionally to the idea of "branding" but the reality is neither as painful, nor as dangerous as you think, and cannot be clearly distinguished from piercing or tattoos in terms of coming up with a reason why it should be treated differently.
I suspect the defense presented all this information to the jury and that is why they acquitted. Perhaps at first they had the same reaction as everyone else, "OMG burning flesh! SICK!", but then as they heard testimony from witnesses about the reality of branding they realized it wasn't so bad. Who knows though.
So this passage means nothing to you from somebody who really knows;
'Today we’ll look into perhaps the most painful of all body modifications, human branding. Branding is a process that involves burning the skin in a manner that will result in a permanent scar or mark, usually in a pattern or the shape of a specific symbol.'
From my other reference;
http://www.vancouversun.com/news/De...+performed+tattoo+parlours/2760389/story.html
The doctors weren't being emotional they were most knowledgeable and clinical. Do you know more than them?
Dr. Wayne Carman, president of the Canadian Society for Aesthetic (Cosmetic) Plastic Surgery, says anyone who performs a surgical procedure -- which he defines broadly as an act that involves significant breaking of the skin and that requires suturing or stitching and healing -- should have medical training.
"For someone to take on some of these ideas -- even splitting a tongue -- it's not something you do in some-one's basement," he said.
Dr. Richard Warren, a spokesman for the Canadian Society of Plastic Surgery, says some procedures clearly cross the line.
He said life-threatening complications could result if the modifications are not performed properly.
"At some point, invasive body modification becomes practising medicine without a licence," he said.
There's no consensus within the tattoo and piercing industry. Calgary tattoo artist Steve Peace says he thinks most practitioners of extreme body modification are unqualified and unaware of the risks.
"Where do you stop? Now, they're cutting nipples off," he said. "I'm a tattoo artist. I'm not a doctor."
But most doctors won't perform these types of procedures, said Russ Foxx, a body-modification specialist in Vancouver. "That leaves us in a predicament. Who do I go to?" he said.
Foxx said he learns how to perform procedures from talking to veteran practitioners, reading books and travelling to conventions.
He says he always informs clients of the risks involved before beginning any procedure.
Too much regulation could have the effect of driving these activities further underground, said Jason MacDonald, an environmental health officer in Edmonton who inspects tattoo parlours to make sure instruments are sanitized and records are properly kept.
MacDonald added that new forms of body modification are constantly coming out.
If lawmakers start banning certain procedures, he said, the practitioners will just start doing "10 more things that we hadn't thought of."
You, of course, know more than these people.