Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Is randygirls cat around. It will be more productive speaking with it.

Maybe if you took the time to understand what people are saying before writing how much you object to it you would be less frustrated.

I made my position clear in 30 something separate posts, including that first one.
 
Please find the words broken and arm in the response.

Post #176. I realize you hate reading before responding, and that since in this case you have to read a series of posts, it's damn near impossible to expect you to do it. Of course, despite your ignorance, you surely won't shut up.

Plainly you jumped into this thread with a whole lot of wrong assumptions based on how someone else mis-characterized what I think, but you sure didn't let that stop you. You got into this thread when someone else posted a misrepresentation of my view on another thread, and you never bothered to go check whether their misrepresentation was in any way accurate. You just assumed something false, like you always do.

Edit: Post #168 is a better example in conjunction with post #142. Aardy's example is paying someone to break their arm with a baseball bat is illegal, and then he says it's the same as branding.
 
Maybe if you took the time to understand what people are saying before writing how much you object to it you would be less frustrated.

I made my position clear in 30 something separate posts, including that first one.

Frustrated? Why would you think that? I find you amusing. Not as smart as randygirls cat but amusing nonetheless.
 
So if the kids also expressed enthusiasm in wanting to play with explosives, take dangerous drug combos, skydive without parachutes, it would all be legally OK to enable them to do this because they consent? It's a parents role to stop their kids from doing reckless stuff like branding their skin. Anything less than stopping them is severe neglect causing harm. Helping them do it is abuse.

Arguably branding results in a desirable outcome whereas your other examples result in undesirable outcome. It depends on how you personally value a branding, but you should be open minded to the possibility that other people see it as a positive thing.

As for legally it's unclear to me. The only precedent for the legality of consent to branding in conjunction with a parent is the case in post #1 although you could compare to the legality for getting ear piercings or tongue piercings or tattoos--if you feel minors can do that with the consent of their parents then why not a brand? Can a minor get a tongue or nipple piercing done with the consent of their parent?
 
Post #176. I realize you hate reading before responding, and that since in this case you have to read a series of posts, it's damn near impossible to expect you to do it. Of course, despite your ignorance, you surely won't shut up.

Plainly you jumped into this thread with a whole lot of wrong assumptions based on how someone else mis-characterized what I think, but you sure didn't let that stop you. You got into this thread when someone else posted a misrepresentation of my view on another thread, and you never bothered to go check whether their misrepresentation was in any way accurate. You just assumed something false, like you always do.

Edit: Post #168 is a better example.

In post #289 you were quoting #173, which is what my response was referring to. Now you're telling us it was #176. You can't keep it straight in your head and you expect us to.

Nice add-on-edit there with the reference to #168, but that post #168 showed us that, just as in the past with your difficulty with 'similar' and 'equal', you have difficulty with the difference between someone asking you a question and making a statement.

He was asking you how you could feel breaking an arm with a baseball bat was different than branding. He was not making a statement that they were the same. His comment was a question to you, not a statement of fact or opinion.

and now an add-on edit with reference to post#142.

That's two add-on edits to one post, and we're not talking spelling or grammatical changes, since your initial accusation and challenge to Aartie and others. Nice work. You'd make a quick change artist proud. No wonder members can't keep track of or make sense of you shite.
 
Arguably branding results in a desirable outcome whereas your other examples result in undesirable outcome. It depends on how you personally value a branding, but you should be open minded to the possibility that other people see it as a positive thing.

As for legally it's unclear to me. The only precedent for the legality of consent to branding in conjunction with a parent is the case in post #1 although you could compare to the legality for getting ear piercings or tongue piercings or tattoos--if you feel minors can do that with the consent of their parents then why not a brand? Can a minor get a tongue or nipple piercing done with the consent of their parent?

Really? You brand cows, not people. How can you compare an ear piercing to a cow prod? Unbelievable. If you're so pro branding, why not bend over and let someone brand you?
 
Nice add-on-edit there with the reference to #168, but that post #168 showed us that, just as in the past with your difficulty with 'similar' and 'equal', you have difficulty with the difference between someone asking you a question and making a statement.

Or #142:

Let's go to an overly powerful illustration again. An SP agrees that for $1.5 million I can break her arm with a baseball bat, she agrees not to report it to the police, I know something of orthopedics so I set her arm without the medical establishment becoming involved but her arm is permanently damaged. Can she validly consent to my breaking her arm, what if we successfully cover it up and she only tells someone about this 50 years latter?

Can you not see that the consent is invalid, what actually occurred was that she did not press charges and the cover-up of a crime. *

He is clearly saying that no-one can consent to having their arm broken that it is at best an unreported crime, but still a crime. Later in #168 he says that branding is the same as having your arm broken:

Fuji, this is like banging my head into a wall with you. How on earth do you think that breaking her arm with a baseball bat is any different from branding in terms of consent.

Just because a jury refuses to convict doesn't mean the law has changed. Your argument is basicly the same as saying that killing your ex-wife and her friend is not a crime in Brentwood Los Angeles.

It's pretty clear, you just didn't bother to find out what you were disagreeing with before you disagreed with it.
 
Really? You brand cows, not people. How can you compare an ear piercing to a cow prod? Unbelievable. If you're so pro branding, why not bend over and let someone brand you?

I'm not a fan of branding, tattoos, or piercings. However lots of people are. George W. Bush bent over and got himself a brand, for example. It was a standard part of the initiation into his fraternity at Yale to get a triangle branded on the small of his back.

We feed cows. We feed people. We brand cows. We brand people. Are you now against feeding people too? The only real difference is that we brand cows whether they like it or not, but it's only acceptable to brand a person who consents.

The only thing unclear about the case in post #1 is to what extent a child, even with the consent of their parents, can consent to branding. They can consent to a lot of things, it's not clear branding is well over the line--things like piercings for example are similar in every medical sense. Branding is just a bit more painful, though not as painful as you probably think it is. Enough more to make a difference? It's hard to say.
 
For clarity on this point: "not as painful as you probably think it is"

A branding iron at over 2000 degrees is hot enough that it instantly destroys all the nerves in the area of the brand. Thus there is far less pain than you would expect as the area becomes numb. A lot less painful than the same size burn at 200 degrees. It's counter-intuitive, but the result is you end up with a mark on your skin that is a lot like a tattoo, although, still a lot more painful than a regular tattoo obviously. More painful than a nipple piercing? I don't know.

If you want to torture someone with a brand you're best to do it with a brand that is nowhere near as hot as one you would apply to someone in a consensual branding--specifically, not hot enough to kill the nerves but hot enough to burn off the skin. That would be intensely painful.

So, a branding iron heated up in a wood fire would hurt like hell, but one heated to 2000 degrees using a propane torch--obviously it's going to hurt, but it won't hurt as much as you think it would.
 
Or #142:



He is clearly saying that no-one can consent to having their arm broken that it is at best an unreported crime, but still a crime. Later in #168 he says that branding is the same as having your arm broken:

It's pretty clear, you just didn't bother to find out what you were disagreeing with before you disagreed with it.



No, he doesn't say that in #168. He was asking you a question.

As to the part referring to it as a unreported crime, I'll leave that fine point of law to the lawyers in house. I really can't and won't argue

I read just fine thank you. It's not clear to anyone else either. Only you think so and right now, the good ship Fuji is a beat up old tired hulk, filled shite in it's belly and rust at the waterline, and no one here cares.
 
For clarity on this point: "not as painful as you probably think it is"

A branding iron at over 2000 degrees is hot enough that it instantly destroys all the nerves in the area of the brand. Thus there is far less pain than you would expect as the area becomes numb. A lot less painful than the same size burn at 200 degrees. It's counter-intuitive, but the result is you end up with a mark on your skin that is a lot like a tattoo, although, still a lot more painful than a regular tattoo obviously. More painful than a nipple piercing? I don't know.

If you want to torture someone with a brand you're best to do it with a brand that is nowhere near as hot as one you would apply to someone in a consensual branding--specifically, not hot enough to kill the nerves but hot enough to burn off the skin. That would be intensely painful.

So, a branding iron heated up in a wood fire would hurt like hell, but one heated to 2000 degrees using a propane torch--obviously it's going to hurt, but it won't hurt as much as you think it would.

...... and you know this how?
 
I'm not a fan of branding, tattoos, or piercings. However lots of people are. George W. Bush bent over and got himself a brand, for example. It was a standard part of the initiation into his fraternity at Yale to get a triangle branded on the small of his back.

We feed cows. We feed people. We brand cows. We brand people. Are you now against feeding people too? The only real difference is that we brand cows whether they like it or not, but it's only acceptable to brand a person who consents.

The only thing unclear about the case in post #1 is to what extent a child, even with the consent of their parents, can consent to branding. They can consent to a lot of things, it's not clear branding is well over the line--things like piercings for example are similar in every medical sense. Branding is just a bit more painful, though not as painful as you probably think it is. Enough more to make a difference? It's hard to say.


HaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHa!!!!!!!!! OMFG.
 
I'm not a fan of branding, tattoos, or piercings. However lots of people are. George W. Bush bent over and got himself a brand, for example. It was a standard part of the initiation into his fraternity at Yale to get a triangle branded on the small of his back.

We feed cows. We feed people. We brand cows. We brand people. Are you now against feeding people too? The only real difference is that we brand cows whether they like it or not, but it's only acceptable to brand a person who consents.

The only thing unclear about the case in post #1 is to what extent a child, even with the consent of their parents, can consent to branding. They can consent to a lot of things, it's not clear branding is well over the line--things like piercings for example are similar in every medical sense. Branding is just a bit more painful, though not as painful as you probably think it is. Enough more to make a difference? It's hard to say.

I really, really hope you don't have any kids.
 
Desireable outcome?
Third degree burns can result in more than just scarring. What about risk of long-term infections? Shock? Involuntary respiratory distress?

There's a medical article up thread that asserts the risks of that are low in western countries with access to clean water and soap. In third world countries where branding is practiced in unsanitary conditions there have been reports of people getting very sick from infections. Basically at the time of the branding it's obviously sterile and the key is whether you wash it with soap and water as it heals, or whether you rub mud into it and have no access to clean water.
 
I'm not a fan of branding, tattoos, or piercings. However lots of people are. George W. Bush bent over and got himself a brand, for example. It was a standard part of the initiation into his fraternity at Yale to get a triangle branded on the small of his back.

We feed cows. We feed people. We brand cows. We brand people. Are you now against feeding people too? The only real difference is that we brand cows whether they like it or not, but it's only acceptable to brand a person who consents.

The only thing unclear about the case in post #1 is to what extent a child, even with the consent of their parents, can consent to branding. They can consent to a lot of things, it's not clear branding is well over the line--things like piercings for example are similar in every medical sense. Branding is just a bit more painful, though not as painful as you probably think it is. Enough more to make a difference? It's hard to say.

I'm with blackrock13 on this one or "HaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHaHa!!!!!!!!! OMFG." I can't sop laughing long enough to formulate a decent response.
 
I did a lot of reading on human branding directly as a result of this thread.

As so those fact you spouted weren't yours, but somebody else's. A few references would be nice. We know how good you are in twisting facts to suit your purpose.