Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

The point is a 15 year old teen can't give reasonable consent for a medical procedure and that can be extending to this branding easily. WTF is the matter with you? You can't read simply english or what?

But that's not what we've been debating. We've been debating whether an adult can, and you just agreed.
 
But you specifically agreed that an adult woman can, which was the point under debate.

ROTHFLMAO. You are now taking credit for proving a point that was never in dispute. You are too much. Didn't you also prove that the world was round.
 
My bad. The above scenario might change if the advise is given by a medical person, but we can call his dad a doctor now can we.

Son this won't hurt a bit and it'll look cool, just like your sisters.
 
But that's not what we've been debating. We've been debating whether an adult can, and you just agreed.

ROTHFLMAO. You are now taking credit for proving a point that was never in dispute. You are too much. Didn't you also prove that the world was round.

this whole thread has been about a teen getting branded by his father. What planet is Fuji on or have his meds not kicked in today? I hear goal posts moving again or is it the brakes on the looney wagon.

He has to try and take credit for something, even if it's an imagined victory. The rest of his argument is down the crapper.
 
this whole thread has been about a teen getting branded by his father. What planet is Fuji on or have his meds not kicked in today? I hear goal posts moving again or is it the brakes on the looney wagon.

He has to try and take credit for something, even if it's an imagined victory. The rest of his argument is down the crapper.

Well at least perhaps he will now give it a rest secure in the knowledge that he has convinced everyone here that an adult can consent to having himself/herself tattooed, pierced and even branded. Quite the revelation. His rhetorical skills and powers ofr persuasion are truly amazing.
 
This is hilarious I am going to save this thread! Here you are disagreeing with me for the sake of disagreeing nothing more, but you don't even know what you're disagreeing with, and you're making colossal fools out of yourselves. I love it! You're both so bloody pathetic it's hilarious.

My point on this thread since my first post is that it is legal for consenting adults but possibly not for children due to their inability to consent.

I mean, it's not like I haven't made that clear in pretty much every post.

You guys are pathetic, truly pathetic.

fuji said:
The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent.

fuji said:
The problem is that despite that they may be unable to consent to it, that's the only legal question really, whether they're able to consent.

fuji said:
What's been disputed is whether it's something that it's possible for the kids to consent to, whether it constitutes serious bodily harm or not.

fuji said:
If branding were really "serious bodily harm" or some such, it would never be legal, not even for consenting adults. As you yourself pointed out oagre, no-one can ever consent to serious bodily harm. But branding is a legal form of body modification for consenting adults, so it cannot amount to serious bodily harm.

fuji said:
What it shows is that it is not serious bodily harm. Georgie could consent to it, after all, and no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. It then becomes a question of what sort of consent is required by a child--a much murkier question, once you've ruled out serious bodily harm.

fuji said:
How was George W. Bush able to consent to it (whether or not he actually did) if branding is serious bodily harm? In the story it's the part where about the only thing the jury had to decide was whether it was the sort of thing the children could consent to in conjunction with their parents.

fuji said:
The fact that branding can be consented to by adults implies that it is NOT serious bodily harm, but rather something less than that. Something more like boxing punches.

fuji said:
Were it as clear cut as you say then anyone who applied a branding to an adult would be guilty of assault as well: Your argument that no consent can be given based merely on quoting this section of law would equally outlaw all branding of anyone ever, child or adult.

fuji said:
When done on an adult who consents it is NOT the case that a branding is an unreported assault. It is not an assault period. The only question is whether children can consent to it the way adults can. Consenting to a properly performed branding is plainly unlike trying to consent to have your arm broken--no court is going to convict someone for performing a piercing or branding or tattooing on a consenting adult.

fuji said:
could not consent to having you intentionally break my arm. Not unless there were some medical reason. I can, however, consent to being branded. There is a big difference between you breaking my arm by accident while we are playing football--a risk I knew I was taking--and your setting out to do it on purpose. No matter what I sign I cannot consent to the latter, yet I can consent to branding.

fuji said:
Because branding is legally consented to all the time in tattoo parlours around Canada and the United States, by the former President of the United States potentially, and so on. There is no question that branding can be consented to by adults. None. The only question is whether children in conjunction with their parents can consent to it.

fuji said:
The British Courts have ruled that it is legal provided there is no intent to commit cruelty, for example. In a case without elements of cruelty the courts ruled it was not assault, but in a case of sadomasochism where there were elements of cruelty they registered a conviction. So intent is key here, at least under British common law. You cannot consent to bodily harm ONLY when there are elements of cruelty or maliciousness present

fuji said:
Despite all your protestations to the contrary the reality is this: Adults can consent to bodily harm when there is no element of maliciousness or cruelty. This is why you can consent to risks of injury in sport, or to medical procedures, and yes, to human branding, piercings, tattoos, or other forms of body modification. It's a LONG established principle going back hundreds of years.

fuji said:
Well I've been saying for some time here the only real legal question is whether it can be consented to with children. I've been getting back guff about how it can never be consented to by anyone, which is plainly wrong--Gotta move past that first!

Note that the court found it is not disfiguring but described it as "the acquisition of a desirable piece of personal adornment".

That does not prove that children can consent to it--I think there's a valid debate around whether children can. I happen to think they should be able to in this case, but that is not something I can prove the way I can prove it's legal for adults.

fuji said:
Causing bodily harm without aggressive intent, when the act has been consented to, is NOT assault. Specifically in this case of human branding, and generally too. At least not in the UK, and since it's based on principles we share with the UK system, presumably the exact same reasoning holds in Canada, and pretty likely in the USA as well.

fuji said:
When there is no "aggressive intent", such as when an act is "done for love", adults can consent to being branded, or to other similar acts that cause some bodily harm, and it is not an assault or any other sort of offense either.

fuji said:
The reality is that in all three countries there is recognition that you can consent to adorn your body with decorations, even if the procedure for creating them involves burning, piercing, scarring, tattooing, or other forms of wounding.

fuji said:
Oagre and Aardvark are arguing that it's illegal even when applied to adults, but they can't support their BS claim with any sort of credible reference.

fuji said:
They are making the BS and unsupportable claim that it is illegal when it is done to adults WITH their consent. That is what I am ridiculing.

fuji said:
Specifically I have said since page #1 that the only question is whether or not children can consent to the activity and that I think they could. Aardvark and Oagre have responded with the ludicrous claim that not even an adult could consent. Since then we have been debating whether adults can consent. It remains my view that adults can, and that furthermore so can the children in conjunction with their parents. I have made that clear repeatedly.

fuji said:
Then meet my challenge. Find a case where, with no colour of cruelty, with no aggressive intent, with no maliciousness, someone was convicted of assault for branding or piercing or tattooing or scarrification or similar body modification of another adult despite the act being fully consensual. I've given you R vs Wilson. I've explained that the branding will be seen as a desirable adornment rather than a disfigurement.

fuji said:
It has been my position on this whole thread that if there is any crime here at all it is only because of an issue around the ability of the children to consent.

fuji said:
Can you cite any cases of anyone being convicted for consensual body modification, such as branding, where there is no malice, cruelty, or aggressive intent?

fuji said:
Then they ought to be able to quote a case, anywhere, of anyone being convicted for body modification. It isn't happening: Body modification is not illegal. Not via branding. Not via scarification. Not via tattoos. Not via piercings. It's ludicrous to assert these things are illegal--you don't see people getting arrested for getting a piercing in their tongue do you?? And yet it's a wound under the same section that these guys have tried to cite. They didn't think it through.

Now whether children can consent--that I don't know. It's untested, other than by this case on this thread.

fuji said:
What happened on this thread was this: A bunch of people jumped in with a knee jerk "oh my god protect the kids this is horrible" emotional reaction. They let their emotions blind them to the actual legal reality of the situation, which is that the act in question is perfectly legal for adults to engage in, and that it's merely a question of what children can consent to.

fuji said:
I do not believe it was an act of unmitigated cruelty. I believe it is, at best, technically illegal because the children may not actually have a legal capability of consenting. I do not think you can call something an "act of unmitigated cruelty" for only 2 of the 3 children on the grounds that the third child is but a few years older and can legally consent.

blackrock said:
The key word in your statement was 'women' not hormone addled 13 year old teenagers.
 
Well at least perhaps he will now give it a rest secure in the knowledge that he has convinced everyone here that an adult can consent to having himself/herself tattooed, pierced and even branded.

Great. So since that is the ONLY thing have been debating: I win!

LOL you are pathetic.
 
That's pretty, but we have no post numbers to refer to find out how much you edited the quotes from those 25+ posts to suit your purpose. That plus the fact that the collection of quotes really don't have much commonality except that most are accredited to you.
 
That's pretty, but we have no post number to refer to find out how much you edited the quotes from those 25+ posts to suit your purpose. That plus the fact that the collection of quote really don't have continuity except that most are accredited to you.

LOL, you don't mind if I bump this thread a few times today to keep it at the top? I want everyone to see how pathetic you are.
 
blackrock, just for you, here is my post #12 on this thread, in its entirety, the one that kicked off this debate. I've bolded the parts that we've been debating:

fuji said:
What makes me somewhat sympathetic is that he branded himself first, and it was only because his children desired to copy his behavior that they wound up being branded. The children do not see themselves as victims, they appear to be proud to have the branding, just like their dad does.

I think the whole family are a pack of idiots, but if the behavior is illegal, it is illegal on a technicality--I have a hard time accusing someone of assault when all the participants are happy, willing, and proud.

The technicality is that the children are not old enough to consent. The same act, if they are old enough to consent, is plainly not criminal. They implicitly have their fathers consent, they have the mother's consent, they themselves consent (for whatever it's worth), and the act was not done out of any desire to inflict harm, but rather, as stupid as it may be, it was done out of love.
 
Great. So since that is the ONLY thing have been debating: I win!

LOL you are pathetic.

LOL. You are fantastic. Why don't you point to the thread were anyone said that an adult could not consent. As someone pointed out very early on It would be more productive debating with a cat.
 
Fuji, you totally changed your argument. At the beginning of this thread, you said that what the father did was not criminal because there was no malicious intent, it was not serious bodily harm, and that the kids consented to it.

Everyone here debated that logic.

Starting on page ten or something, you started to argue about adults giving consent to modifications on their bodies, even citing cases regarding adults. and then would add a little sentence saying "but the question is whether children can give consent", which is the opposite of your original argument of it not being criminal because the children were happy with it.

I still fail to see where the guys said it was illegal for a consenting adult modify their body. No one was arguing whether what the father did to himself was illegal, because everyone already knows it's not. What they were arguing was what the father did to the children was illegal; because they are children, and can not consent. You argued to opposite of that, because it was done 'out of love', and everyone was happy with it, it wasn't criminal.

I would go back and quote you, but I have better things to do. The shift in your argument was a slow one, but it is there nonetheless. Anyone who has followed this thread closely should be able to see it.
 
Fuji, you totally changed your argument. At the beginning of this thread, you said that what the father did was not criminal because there was no malicious intent, it was not serious bodily harm, and that the kids consented to it.

See my post #12. I said that the only legal question was whether the parents could consent. Just a few posts ago I quoted every place where I've said that, which adds up to some 20 or 30 posts where I've said that.

I called the consent of the parents a technicality because the kids are teenagers.
 
By the way, Aardvark was talking about not being able to consent to assault, as it is defined under the law. His post is still correct.

Tattoos, piercings and (gasp!) even brandings are not, for an adult, assault under the law. Same goes with boxing matches, or football games, where consent is given when you decide to participate in the activity.

Breaking an SPs arm, would be considered assault. Often abuse occurs, such as between spouses, and the victim does not want to press charges. The law does so for them, whether or not the victim want to give the perpetrator a free pass. The victim in that case, has consented to being assaulted, but the law says otherwise. Hence, an adult can not consent to being assaulted as it is defined by law. If they could consent to that assault, then the police would not be able to charge the perpetrator of the assault if the victim says not to. This is untrue, because often, no matter what a victim says, charges are still laid.

The only way they would not press charges is if the victims testimony was the only evidence available to get a conviction...but they are not not pressing charges because the victim consented, but in that case, it would be because they needed the testimony to prove the case. If there were witnesses around other than the victim, then they would press charges, no matter what the victim had to say about it. See?

You are twisting that post into something it is not...

Either way, this whole time, we haven't been debating whether or not an adult can consent to being assaulted (well, maybe YOU were). We were debating whether or not what the father did to those children was illegal. You stated your position and rationale on the first page, and have nicely gotten away from your original viewpoint without admitting that you were incorrect.
 
Last edited:
You can't even do that right, 141 or 142. Either way, nothing I'm reading in them holds up your argument. It must be in more of that invisible words you read so often. I'll let the lawyer touch on this one.

Oh, that's two.

Aardvark: "Fuji is confusing activity which is not normally harmful and can be consented to e.g. athletic activity with activity which always causes serious bodily harm: i.e. branding or hitting someone with a baseball bat. "

At this point, blackrock, I'd be really interested to hear whether there is anything I've posted that you can say you disagree with. Be specific. It's certainly NOT my point that an adult can consent to be branded that you disagree with.
 
The shift in your argument was a slow one, but it is there nonetheless. Anyone who has followed this thread closely should be able to see it.

My argument hasn't changed since the start of the thread, if you want to go back and read something and save yourself the time of searching, just go to page 1 of the thread and read post #12 which was my first lengthy post.

In that post I said I do not see anything particularly wrong with what they did, although I think it's stupid. I thought that if it's illegal it's on a technicality: they aren't old enough to consent legally by a couple of years.

Much of what followed was to demonstrate to all the "oh my god burning flesh" crew on the thread that branding is somewhat commonplace and not all that terrible--George Bush probably has one, adults can do it, etc., and so doing it to a child is not as bad as, say, breaking their arm, or beating them--things which would be criminal if done to an adult or child.