Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

What happened on this thread is that you expressed sympathy for an act of unmitigated cruelty

I do not believe it was an act of unmitigated cruelty. I believe it is, at best, technically illegal because the children may not actually have a legal capability of consenting. I do not think you can call something an "act of unmitigated cruelty" for only 2 of the 3 children on the grounds that the third child is but a few years older and can legally consent.

Comparing modern decorative brandings with medieval torture is like saying that piercing someone's tongue is equivalent to nailing them to the cross. It's not really the same.
 
I do not believe it was an act of unmitigated cruelty. I believe it is, at best, technically illegal because the children may not actually have a legal capability of consenting. I do not think you can call something an "act of unmitigated cruelty" for only 2 of the 3 children on the grounds that the third child is but a few years older and can legally consent.

Comparing modern decorative brandings with medieval torture is like saying that piercing someone's tongue is equivalent to nailing them to the cross. It's not really the same.

What? What did you say? I cant hear you?
 
There is no way in hell you're going to convince me that putting a hot iron to my upper arm isn't going to hurt. I suspect I've handling more wood burning stoves and campfires than anyone on this BB, and I got news, it would hurt like hell. Now you ask a son who has wanted this and has his father do it, if it hurt, he's going say yes, ya sure. Not likely and risk being called a wimp or worse. I'm amazing how well Fuji can tell from photo that it didn't hurt or blistered or got infected. I don't know a real doctor or EMR tech who could hazard a conclusion like that, but Dr Fuji is like no one else we know.

Apparently Fuji, I'm not the only one who thinks you're a class A circle jerk.
 
There is no way in hell you're going to convince me that putting a hot iron to my upper arm isn't going to hurt.

That doesn't make it illegal. There's no way you're going to convince me that a girl nailing a stud through her nipple doesn't hurt, but guess what--it's not illegal to do that either.
 
That doesn't make it illegal. There's no way you're going to convince me that a girl nailing a stud through her nipple doesn't hurt, but guess what--it's not illegal to do that either.

Your totally fucked. It's her nipple and that makes a big difference. I hope one of the members who've had this done will give him first person feedback. He'll deny you know what you're talking about of course. It's when you do it to a child, even your child, there's the difference. Many people have told you this including some lawyers. I think they've got more incite in the law than you.
 
I don't know, he seems to be inciting you with your ad hominems - over and over and over again. lol

Nice play on words. We already covered that term in class you must have missed that one. Define it however you want. It doesn't change the fact that he's a narcissistic jerk.
 
Nice play on words. We already covered that term in class you must have missed it. Define it how ever you want. It doesn't change the fact that he's a narcissistic jerk.

So what? lol
You really need to repeat that over and over and over again?
 
So what? lol
You really need to repeat that over and over and over again?

Maybe I like to hear Fuji's rebuttals. It's hilarious to watch him dig himself in deeper. If he'd stop maybe it would get quieter, but he can't help having the last word and he screws it up something fierce each time and ticks people off.
 
Your totally fucked. It's her nipple and that makes a big difference. I hope one of the members who've had this done will give him first person feedback. He'll deny you know what you're talking about of course. It's when you do it to a child, even your child, there's the difference. Many people have told you this including some lawyers. I think they've got more incite in the law than you.

What?! What's the difference between a teen girl getting her nipple pierced and a teen boy getting a part of his body branded when both involve consent and both involve pain? I'm sure some girls who get tattoos or piercings are socially pressured into getting them akin to how this boy might have felt pressured to get the branding by the fact that other members of his family were doing it. Her body, his body - what's the diff?
 
What?! What's the difference between a teen girl getting her nipple pierced and a teen boy getting a part of his body branded when both involve consent and both involve pain? I'm sure some girls who get tattoos are socially pressured into getting them akin to how this boy might have felt pressured to get the branding by the fact that other members of his family were doing it. Her body, his body - what's the diff?

I have no way of gauging the pain you get from a piercing as nobody in my close circle has one, and certainly no 13 and 15 years olds, but I know many people who have a tat in sensitive places, belly button or base of the spine and they'd walk on broken glass before they'd get another one like it. As to how much a nipple modification hurts or not, I'll leave that to somebody who's had it done, but getting a 2nd degree+ burn in skin hurts like a bitch. You can't really tell for certain from the photo, but there appears to be crusting/scabbing on the wound.

The assumption that something is legal doesn't make it right or smart. Drinking yourself into an alcohol stupor isn't illegal, but it's a smart thing. Using you tongue to check if a 9 volt battery has a charge, isn't illegal, but it's really stupid.
 
What?! What's the difference between a teen girl getting her nipple pierced and a teen boy getting a part of his body branded when both involve consent and both involve pain? I'm sure some girls who get tattoos or piercings are socially pressured into getting them akin to how this boy might have felt pressured to get the branding by the fact that other members of his family were doing it. Her body, his body - what's the diff?

Give the man a lollipop. Women can and do consent to having all sorts of things pierced that yes I imagine are quite painful to have done. Why? To acquire a desirable adornment on their body.

Exactly like branding.

None of the blustering around here has ever produced a counter-example to that point: Human body modification is just not illegal. It is a WIDESPREAD cultural practice. Branding a little less so, but it's still not uncommon.
 
I have no way of gauging the pain you get from a piercing as nobody in my close circle has one, and certainly no 13 and 15 years olds, but I know many people who have a tat in sensitive places, belly button or base of the spine and they'd walk on broken glass before they'd get another one like it. As to how much a nipple modification hurts or not, I'll leave that to somebody who's had it done, but getting a 2nd degree+ burn in skin hurts like a bitch. You can't really tell for certain from the photo, but there appears to be crusting/scabbing on the wound.

The assumption that something is legal doesn't make it right or smart. Drinking yourself into an alcohol stupor isn't illegal, but it's a smart thing. Using you tongue to check if a 9 volt battery has a charge, isn't illegal, but it's really stupid.

So there is no difference? Other than you know how much one hurts and are unsure of how much the other hurts. I'm in wholehearted agreement with you that many would find branding stupid, just as many would find piercing and tattooing stupid. But you know what? If that's what they want, who am I to say "no, you can't do that because *I* feel it will be too painful for you and I think it's a stupid thing to do"?
 
Give the man a lollipop. Women can and do consent to having all sorts of things pierced that yes I imagine are quite painful to have done. Why? To acquire a desirable adornment on their body.

Exactly like branding.

None of the blustering around here has ever produced a counter-example to that point: Human body modification is just not illegal. It is a WIDESPREAD cultural practice. Branding a little less so, but it's still not uncommon.

The key word in your statement was 'women' not hormone addled 13 year old teenagers. There is the difference, but for some reason you don't catch on. Most people I know who have teenagers will confirm they suffer age induced insanity very common to young people of the same age as a result of raging hormones and seem to come out of it around 21 years of age. I'm guessing you don't have teenagers. Even if you did, you wouldn't admit it so no use thinking about it.
 
The key word in your statement was 'women' not hormone addled 13 year old teenagers.

Thanks, you just agreed with the point I've been trying to make for several pages now. You now agree with me, and disagree with Aardvark, Oagre, and toguy. Thanks.
 
Thanks, you just agreed with the point I've been trying to make for several pages now. You now agree with me, and disagree with Aardvark, Oagre, and toguy. Thanks.

Wha? How's that? Again you're showing that you're just not clued in.

I don't believe that those addled brained teens can give advised consent with much credibility, especially for something like this, Their brains don't work that way. Are you reading the same post as the rest of us? This man took a hot branding iron to his teenagers' arm, even with his son and daughter saying sure dad go ahead. There was no way those teens had any real idea what could happen to their armed. I'm not even sure the father was all there and knew the consequences.

There are good reasons why the age of consent for medical procedures, I believe, is 16 in Canada. I've been unable find a single age for the US but it appears to hover around 16 but it's also appears to never be cut and dry.
 
But you specifically agreed that an adult woman can, which was the point under debate.

The point is a 15 year old teen can't give reasonable consent for a medical procedure and that can be extending to this branding easily. WTF is the matter with you? You can't read simply english or what?