Welfare Fraud

xix

Time Zone Traveller
Jul 27, 2002
5,990
2,668
113
La la land
Has anyone ever seen or heard of someone getting kicked off Welfare before?

Someone told me that calling the fraud line is a joke.

They don't seem to chase anyone who is committing Fraud, like two checks or a check all year round while they go to the island for 6 months and come back every year.

Is the Fraud Line really a joke?
 
when you consider that Bill and hillery Clinton have been collecting since the early 80's
 
Probably depends on how much information you can provide in order to help them catch the perps. Calling up and telling them that your neighbour "Bob" gets too much welfare probably won't see much happen. Providing them with Bob's full name, address, phone number, details of what exactly he is misleading Welfare on and your contact info will get more results.
 
Has anyone ever seen or heard of someone getting kicked off Welfare before?

Someone told me that calling the fraud line is a joke.

They don't seem to chase anyone who is committing Fraud, like two checks or a check all year round while they go to the island for 6 months and come back every year.

Is the Fraud Line really a joke?

Probably a bit of a joke. Consider this example related to me by a person in the know:

Someone is living in a shelter in Toronto. He receives a "personal needs allowance" and is thus not eligible for "Ontario Works". However, the City of Toronto makes its computerized shelter intake system inaccessible to its own welfare workers so that an applicant's living situation cannot be checked on. Considerations of privacy don'tcha know. So, an emergency cheque is cut for a couple hundred dollars. Makes both the applicant and probably a low-level drug dealer very happy.

jwm
 
I know a guy who takes welfare checks, and it isn't because he can't hold a job. It's because he doesn't want to. He can't take direction from anyone without being insulted, as if taking orders is too demeaning for him even from his boss (I had the misfortune of actually having to work with him once). Once he has got it in his mind that the boss is out to demean him, he takes 2 or 3 sick days a week until they fire him. After going through 4 jobs in 6 months he gave up, basically citing how hard it is to get a job, and now he sits at his parent's home living off drugs and his welfare check.
 
Canada may not be as bad as Greece but there is a significant proportion of our population that keeps their heads buried deep in the trough, welfare is just the tip of the iceberg. I promise that you could send half of the provincial non- essential service workers home and no one would know. If Queen's park shut down for a year who would care? Seriously?
 
I have known of cases where people have been put on suspension for three months due to the fact of not following the guides lines of Ont works, for example if someone is collecting Ont works and working a cash job or getting large cash gifts monthly weekly etc etc, having Ont works under the ideal that you are living at address A when in fact you are living at address B. Collecting Ont works while you live with a partner who is gainfully employed and is able to maintain a sustainable way of life for him herself and partner. If there is a report made about someone collecting Ont works and is suspected of a fraud of one way or another then that file remains open for a year then closed and destroyed if there no provable facts. If it is brought to court and that person is found guilty then it can mean a max of a life time suspension from Ont works
 
Canada may not be as bad as Greece but there is a significant proportion of our population that keeps their heads buried deep in the trough, welfare is just the tip of the iceberg. I promise that you could send half of the provincial non- essential service workers home and no one would know. If Queen's park shut down for a year who would care? Seriously?

I would strenuously take the position that alot of useless bureaucrats in the ABC and MUSH sector are the real Welfare queens that are bleeding the private economy bone dry, not the occasional lost soul who's so broken in spirit that he's resorted to begging for scraps of a few hundred dollars. The Teachers Pension fund, OMERS et al, funded by every sap in the private sector, many of whom don't have pensions, owns tens of billions in real estate (including Cadillac Fairview) and other assets that will ensure members of the privileged bureaucatic classes comfy retirements. Or how about the pals of McGuinty and company who are able to get sweetheart deals to do 'consulting' of one kind or another....people like these are the real crooks imho.

Just face it: a given percentage (2-3%?) of the population is disturbed/too weak to make it in this world; it borders on ignorant to kick a guy when he's down.
 
Last edited:
Wow, what a winner!

Doesn't that just make YOU want to go out and commit welfare fraud?

The kicker is he's listing his residence as somewhere else, presumably so he gets his full welfare "entitlement". Lol ENTITLEMENT. Crazy way of looking at it. His parents are on welfare to, although his mom atleast TRIES to make a living when she isn't having health problems (drug use again). As far as I can see the only times you see them outdoors is when they're burning something in their burn barrel out back. No idea what they're always burning, but it stinks like hell.
 
Now that at least 85% of employers check for a crimminal record & Steven Harpor has tabled legislation to deny pardons to all except those with misdemeanors .......... JUST get a crimminal record & you are set for life to stay on welfare , legitamatly look for work & constantly be turned down. :confused:
 
There was a story in the media about 2 years ago about how many muslim immigrants were collecting multiple cheques because they were married to 5 women. Each wife got a welfare cheque and the old man would cash them all in.

I'll bet you dollars to doughnuts that NOTHING was ever done to put an end to this since cuiture seems to trump the law every time in our socialist town.

http://cnews.canoe.ca/CNEWS/Canada/2008/02/08/4834833-sun.html
 
I'm currently on OW and hate it. Feel like a hypocrite. Let me tell you, it seems quite easy to commit fraud. The peoples don't even seem to care. Their was a kid waiting with me for a job counsellor appointment. Iphone, designer jeans, $300 jacket, $50 hat, $200 sneakers, $200 Ipod, smoking Du Maurier cigarettes outside while waiting. How much is this bastard getting on welfare? I had to quit smoking because I couldn't afford it after being laid off. Hell, I even quit coffee because it was too damn expensive. I'm in debt, slowly trying to work my way out, working with the counsellor to find work AND get an education, yet most of the people around me are bitching about not having enough money for rent while they also rant and rave about how they got soooo drunk last night at the bars. Being on welfare makes me hate the welfare parasites even more. Ah well. Hopefully I won't be on it for much longer. Have an interview tomorrow, so here's hoping.
 
I'm currently on OW and hate it. Feel like a hypocrite. Let me tell you, it seems quite easy to commit fraud. The peoples don't even seem to care. Their was a kid waiting with me for a job counsellor appointment. Iphone, designer jeans, $300 jacket, $50 hat, $200 sneakers, $200 Ipod, smoking Du Maurier cigarettes outside while waiting. How much is this bastard getting on welfare? I had to quit smoking because I couldn't afford it after being laid off. Hell, I even quit coffee because it was too damn expensive. I'm in debt, slowly trying to work my way out, working with the counsellor to find work AND get an education, yet most of the people around me are bitching about not having enough money for rent while they also rant and rave about how they got soooo drunk last night at the bars. Being on welfare makes me hate the welfare parasites even more. Ah well. Hopefully I won't be on it for much longer. Have an interview tomorrow, so here's hoping.

If you hit the OW point and you have debt you (honestly) should consider bankruptcy not credit counciling. Depending of the likely pay of your next job, and how big the debt is. It's probably fair to say that this is 'something of a clean slate moment in your life'. Creditors and credit councillors (who are often funded by big credit issuers even when not for profit) will scare the bejesus out of a person about their credit score. The simple truth is that re-establishing credit isn't that hard, and despite the fact that a bankruptcy lingers on your credit report for a good long time 'credit' is about 'you lately' as much as anything else. Bancruptcy can be a good tool when used appropriately. Businesses incorporate for that reason-- consumers shouldn't enter into bankruptcy lightly, but it is a tool like any other and should be used soberly as such.

As for the OP-- If you report anything to a government agency for any reason details, and articulately expressing details is your friend. Then expect a wait before any enforcement, and then to hear nothing (unless you're going to court). As far as there being fraud-- Yes. But that should be weighed against the costs of increased enforcement, the costs of throwing a person off the welfare roles for too long of a period of time, and a basic respect for human rights. (Yes, there should be reasonable investigation and penalties where appropriate, but 'one strike and off forever' tends to produce criminals of a more untoward sort.) The real solution(s) are in properly incentivising work, and better care for those with mental health issues. 'All stick' approaches actually become counterproductive at a certain point. That point is where people either see better (or their only) opportunities in black market, grey market, or criminal activities. We all pay for that in police costs, court costs, jail costs, property values, and insurance rates. Too much stick and Regan type thinking gives you Detroit.
 
The " welfare parasites " will soon have the preasure taken off them to actually obtain a real full time job provided they have a crimminal record ...... thanks to Steven Harpor.
 
I know a guy who takes welfare checks, and it isn't because he can't hold a job...He can't take direction from anyone without being insulted, as if taking orders is too demeaning for him even from his boss (I had the misfortune of actually having to work with him once)....

Someone is living in a shelter in Toronto. He receives a "personal needs allowance" and is thus not eligible for "Ontario Works". However, the City of Toronto makes its computerized shelter intake system inaccessible to its own welfare workers so that an applicant's living situation cannot be checked on. Considerations of privacy don'tcha know. So, an emergency cheque is cut for a couple hundred dollars.
jwm


As a band aid solution, it's not that bad. A few hundred dollars a month per reson is a relatively small price to pay compared to what it would cost to provide a successfull detoxing and year round psychotherapy which would be needed to make these people functional. And it's MUCH cheaper than prosecuting & jailing them if they eventually turned to more hardcore methods of survivng.

Bottom line, it's abetter value for the money paying these people off as long as they are content to stay in and get high in some decrepid shelter or subsudized flee pit - doing nothing worse than occasional petty shopifting and drug possession for household use.

Enforcement resources are better directed to those who scam benefits & subsidies while working for cash with which they can finance larger scale illegal activities or channel the moneyback to their terrorist home branch.
 
Welfare should be a stepping stone from hard times to getting back on your feet... it should NOT be a way of life.

Unfortunately... all too often it is the latter and not the former.

It is hardly a "way of life". You HAVE to be looking for a job while on welfare unless you have a disability and are waiting to get onto ODSP.

All these stories of people "parasiting" welfare are nothing but hyperbole.

Speaking of which, OW only pays like $550 for a single person. Who the hell can live on that? They should raise the rates imo.