Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Nobody believes it's a good idea, Randy. Here's fuji's first post on the subject.

People have a right to be stupid, and in my opinion this is just stupid. No criminal conviction required--they have all literally branded themselves as morons already!
 
I do think he's a little stupid too, though.

Understatement of the century. Doesn't exactly help your argument, either. For the sake of argument, he was branded as an adult, and was able to make an informed decision. A parent branding a child? Completely different scenario, in fact, there's no comparison.
 
However if the President of the United States can have a branding, and everybody thinks that's normal, then I fail to see what the big deal is. I do think he's a little stupid too, though.

There you go again. Turning supposition into fact. But no matter. Keep clinging.
 
There you go again. Turning supposition into fact. But no matter. Keep clinging.

Sure, it's within the realm of possibility that he was the only pledge not to get branded. I'm willing to bet, though, that George W. Bush has a triangle branded on the small of his back. At any rate, if he doesn't, then at the very least he was part of an organization that routinely engages in that practice.
 
Sure, it's within the realm of possibility that he was the only pledge not to get branded. I'm willing to bet, though, that George W. Bush has a triangle branded on the small of his back. At any rate, he was part of an organization that routinely engages in that practice.

You can dance all you like but you do not know that he was branded. It is unfortunately your modus operandi to turn supposition or guesses into fact.

In any event as someone else has pointed out even if it is true he was an adult. Parents are supposed to protect their children not mutilate them.
 
Remind me. I notice you didn't contest anything else I posted.

Recently? I thought there would be no significant cases of burqa's being used in crime, and subsequently changed my view to say that I agreed they could be restricted in banks and such when it turned out there were a few. There are other examples. I am pretty honest about admitting when I'm wrong--I will let you know when I'm wrong.

I have plainly disputed your claim that he scarred the children for life in other posts, and I disputed that branding was all that bad by pointing out that former President G.W. Bush more than likely has a branding on his back.
 
Recently? I thought there would be no significant cases of burqa's being used in crime, and subsequently changed my view to say that I agreed they could be restricted in banks and such when it turned out there were a few. There are other examples. I am pretty honest about admitting when I'm wrong--I will let you know when I'm wrong.

I have plainly disputed your claim that he scarred the children for life in other posts, and I disputed that branding was all that bad by pointing out that former President G.W. Bush more than likely has a branding on his back.
You will let me know when you are wrong. Swell. By general announcements or will you be sending me emails? George is an idiot, and I assume if that is correct he did it as an adult. These were kids. They were branded for life. Dispute that all you like.
 
You will let me know when you are wrong. Swell. By general announcements or will you be sending me emails?

I'll note it on the thread in questions if it happens again.

George is an idiot, and I assume if that is correct he did it as an adult. These were kids. They were branded for life. Dispute that all you like.

What it shows is that it is not serious bodily harm. Georgie could consent to it, after all, and no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. It then becomes a question of what sort of consent is required by a child--a much murkier question, once you've ruled out serious bodily harm.
 
What it shows is that it is not serious bodily harm.

No what it shows is that you do not understand the concept of serious bodily harm to a child and that you are unable to let go of a postilion which most sane people would be ashamed to have taken in the first place. Your narcissism will simply not permit you to let go. Keep clinging.
 
I'll note it on the thread in questions if it happens again.



What it shows is that it is not serious bodily harm. Georgie could consent to it, after all, and no-one can consent to serious bodily harm. It then becomes a question of what sort of consent is required by a child--a much murkier question, once you've ruled out serious bodily harm.

You continue to dig a hole for yourself. This is disfigurement, likely premanent. These were kids, 13 and 15 years old. Consent goes out of the window. Parents have one major role, and that is to protect their children. The father in this case failed miserably. Dispute that all you like. In my opinion it is serious bodily harm.
 
I have plainly disputed your claim that he scarred the children for life in other posts, and I disputed that branding was all that bad by pointing out that former President G.W. Bush more than likely has a branding on his back.

Fuji, you can't seriously believe that he didn't scar his children for life? They are scarred. For life. As in, unless they undergo painful removal of the burn by surgical means and then more painful skin grafting operations, (which may still cause scarring) they are stuck with their "mark", for life. Any scar I've ever received did not magically disappear on its own. How exactly did he NOT scar them for life?

As for branding not being that bad because former President Bush did it. Again, you can not compare the two, it's like apples to oranges. This parent mutilated three of his children, two which were underage. The children are not adults, and as such, are not in a position to give consent. It is the parents responsibility to care for their children. If the President was branded, he was an adult at the and made his own stupid decision. That, in my opinion is what makes what this father did criminal.

I have a hard time seeing your argument, every example you cite is either not heinous (tattoos and piercings) or refers to an adult giving consent. Your rationalizations fail to enforce your position.
 
Fuji, you can't seriously believe that he didn't scar his children for life?

I agree they have been branded for life. I just don't see it as serious bodily harm or psychologically scarring. I think it's a stupid thing to do, but since everybody consented, I don't see why it should be criminal.

The children are not adults, and as such, are not in a position to give consent.

However, since it is not serious bodily harm, they can consent if their parents concur, and their parents concur.
 
Nope, and neither was the jury. Serious bodily harm is serious bodily harm. Period. The concept is no different for adults or children.

Fuji, the jury was deadlocked, which means half of them were of different mind. They did not acquit him, at all.

btw, you make me sick. Sorry, but it's true.
 
Nope, and neither was the jury. Serious bodily harm is serious bodily harm. Period. The concept is no different for adults or children.

You continue to make that statement as if you know what you are talking about. The fact that he was acquitted on the more serious charge does not mean that the harm inflicted on his children was not serious bodily harm. There are a number of components to the charge and none of us here know the basis on which he was acquitted. Please do not state something as a fact which is not a fact as is your habit. The fact that the jury was hung on the lesser charge leads me to suspect, NOT KNOW, that there was something else at work in the trial.