Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

BRANDING someone does not constitute bodily harm?! Explain to me how, please.

I think it's borderline. It doesn't cause any lasting harm, and it doesn't present any particular health risk, it's just a somewhat more painful way to get a tattoo in some sense.
 
The only difference is that there's temporarily more pain involved in a branding than in a tattoo. Is it enough pain to constitute serious bodily harm? The court did not think so, apparently.

Fuji, this particular JURY didn't think so. Maybe the jury was composed of Fuji's. A friggin great scar on your body and the 3rd degree burns that this necessarily involved would certainly be serious bodily harm under Canadian law. I am at a loss as to how the jury did not convict the accused on 2nd degree assault.
 
I've learned that when people start insulting you rather than debating it means they've lost the debate. Thanks Victor and Oagre for conceding.

And I have learned that when people simply keep repeating idiotic arguments it means they are incapable of debating and accordingly further engagement is futile.
 
The court did not think so, apparently.
Just a minor point of clarification, the Jury not the Court.

Again we are attempting to put ourselves into the minds of the Jury, but do not know what their actual reasoning was.

---------
Ah I see Oagre already beat me to this.
 
Fuji, this particular JURY didn't think so. Maybe the jury was composed of Fuji's. A friggin great scar on your body and the 3rd degree burns that this necessarily involved would certainly be serious bodily harm under Canadian law. I am at a loss as to how the jury did not convict the accused on 2nd degree assault.

There is really one way: They didn't think that it amounted to serious bodily harm, and therefore they accepted that the children in conjunction with their parents could consent to it. Not much else in the case was disputed from what I can see in the newspaper report. Maybe something has been left out of the reporting though, I don't know. Seems like the accused agreed to the rest of the facts.
 
I think it's borderline. It doesn't cause any lasting harm, and it doesn't present any particular health risk, it's just a somewhat more painful way to get a tattoo in some sense.

Doesn't cause any lasting harm. He seared their flesh indelibly. No lasting psychological harm? Keep digging a hole for yourself fugi, you deserve it.
 
Doesn't cause any lasting harm. He seared their flesh indelibly. No lasting psychological harm? Keep digging a hole for yourself fugi, you deserve it.

Do you have any evidence that they suffered any lasting psychological harm? I don't think you do. You are full of assumptions, in my opinion--ones that the jury, who were well acquainted with the evidence, apparently felt were wrong.
 
Do you have any evidence that they suffered any lasting psychological harm? I don't think you do. You are full of assumptions, in my opinion--ones that the jury, who were well acquainted with the evidence, apparently felt were wrong.

No I don't. They are still kids, but I'm imagining how any child would deal later in life being branded by their parent as if they were an animal. One thing I've learned about you is that you will argue any point no matter how absurd, just to see if you can win. In your own mind anyway.
 
Do you have any evidence that they suffered any lasting psychological harm? I don't think you do. You are full of assumptions, in my opinion--ones that the jury, who were well acquainted with the evidence, apparently felt were wrong.

You can not prove psychological harm right now. Years from now, when they are more mature, I would be willing to bet money that the children will regret this.

Whether or not it causes lasting harm is not the issue, either. Like Victor Lazlo pointed out, many injuries don't cause "lasting" harm, but that doesn't make them any less egregious when inflicted.
 
Do you have any evidence that they suffered any lasting psychological harm? I don't think you do. You are full of assumptions, in my opinion--ones that the jury, who were well acquainted with the evidence, apparently felt were wrong.

Are you insane? Do you think that the fact that this branding might not have caused lasting psychological harm (and none of us here have any idea whether or not it will) makes it any less heinous.
 
Are you insane? Do you think that the fact that this branding might not have caused lasting psychological harm (and none of us here have any idea whether or not it will) makes it any less heinous.

Yes. I think if it did not cause any serious bodily harm and it did not cause any lasting psychological harm then it is less heinous than an act that caused serious bodily harm or lasting psychological damage. Plainly.
 
You can not prove psychological harm right now. Years from now, when they are more mature, I would be willing to bet money that the children will regret this.

Regret is not the same thing as lasting psychological harm.

Whether or not it causes lasting harm is not the issue, either. Like Victor Lazlo pointed out, many injuries don't cause "lasting" harm, but that doesn't make them any less egregious when inflicted.

If there is no serious bodily harm or lasting psychological harm then there is no basis for a serious assault charge. The jury, who knew the facts quite well, apparently felt it didn't add up to that much harm.
 
One thing I've learned about you is that you will argue any point no matter how absurd, just to see if you can win. In your own mind anyway.

I am willing to challenge assumptions that others accept as fact. I find I have greatly improved my knowledge and understanding of all things through it. I also find there is nothing more rewarding than being proved wrong in a debate, but I do demand proof.
 
Regret is not the same thing as lasting psychological harm.



If there is no serious bodily harm or lasting psychological harm then there is no basis for a serious assault charge. The jury, who knew the facts quite well, apparently felt it didn't add up to that much harm.

Fuji, having regrets is definitely psychologically harmful, sometimes even crippling.

As per Aardvark's post #20, the definition of second degree assault has nothing to do with causing "lasting" bodily harm.

f) Knowingly inflicts bodily harm which by design causes such pain or agony as to be the equivalent of that produced by torture;



Are you trying to say that what the father did does not fit this criteria? Causing pain or agony, even momentarily, fits the definition of second degree assault. The issues surrounding this "branding", however, go way beyond momentary pain if you actually consider that these children are marked for life.
 
Yes. I think if it did not cause any serious bodily harm and it did not cause any lasting psychological harm then it is less heinous than an act that caused serious bodily harm or lasting psychological damage. Plainly.

With apologies to Mr. Lazlo see post 56.