Man who branded his children acquitted of assault.

Did you read the article? It is not disputed by anyone, not by the court, not by the prosecution, not by his family, not by his kids, that he did it out of love for his kids. The problem is that despite that they may be unable to consent to it, that's the only legal question really, whether they're able to consent.

They were under age and were branded permanently by their father. Exactly how do you equate that with love? A rational person would see that as a display of ownership.
 
Randygirl, do you feel the same way about tattoos? Should parents be brought up on charges if they allow their child to get a tattoo? After all that permanently mutilates kids bodies too in essentially exactly the same way. How about piercings?

As a matter of fact, I do. If it were MY CHILDREN, over MY DEAD BODY would they get a tattoo or a piercing until they were AGE OF MAJORITY and consented to it THEMSELVES.
 
I suggest you read the article.

I did. What are you suggesting I missed? This is not a tattoo, which would be bad enough. He branded them. Permanently. They are under age. What about that don't you get. I hope you don't have, or plan to bring, any children into this world.
 
Are you a parent?

I am not. I don't believe I need to be to have a viewpoint on this, either. At those ages, children, from a psychological maturity standpoint do not see the long term picture. A lot of maturing happens between the ages of 13 to 18. By the time they are 18, it would be their decision and they could then live with the permanent consequences of making that decision. Hopefully by the time they reach 18 they have enough maturity to see longer term, make their decisions informed and accept responsibility for what they do (of course this doesn't always happen).

Either way, at that point, it is out of the parents hands. If I were a parent, I would do my utmost to protect my children from making bad decisions, such as mutilating their bodies, until they were old enough and it was no longer my decision.

I certainly would never, in a million years, condone or participate in a situation like what happened here. If my child wanted to be branded, they could do it themselves, with no help from me. They would have to work to get the branding iron, the propane torch and do it on their own, and in secret. The father in this case was an active participant, behavior that I just can't fathom.

You might think I'd be a bit of a Nazi- parent, but whatever.
 
Last edited:
That's the only legal question really, whether they're able to consent.
I'm reminded of "Other than that Mrs. Lincoln, how did you like the play?"!

Whether they are able to give informed consent is rather a large question wouldn't you say Fuji?
 
The difficulty of comparing this situation with having been tattooed, is that anymore tattoos can be pretty much erased by laser treatment, removing a "brand" will require extensive plastic surgery.
 
The difficulty of comparing this situation with having been tattooed, is that anymore tattoos can be pretty much erased by laser treatment, removing a "brand" will require extensive plastic surgery.

The difficulty in comparing branding to tattooing is that they are not comparable. Branding is the searing and burning of flesh. It is a barbaric assault by any definition and children cannot consent. And fujii before you attempt to make some semantic comparison don't even try. It would be sheer sophistry. The two are not comparable at all.
 
The difficulty of comparing this situation with having been tattooed, is that anymore tattoos can be pretty much erased by laser treatment, removing a "brand" will require extensive plastic surgery.

One would think that shouldn't have to be explained, but fugi seems to think this was an act of love. I thought branding was reserved for cattle, and even then it seems more than a little grotesque. Sheik was right. Fugi is an idiot.
 
I did. What are you suggesting I missed?

That nobody doubts he did it because he loved his kids. What they doubt is his judgement and whether or not it's possible for a kid that age to consent. He plainly did not do it out of anger or any intent to harm them, in fact he did it to himself first and originally only planned to do it to himself. That's not been disputed by anyone. What's been disputed is whether it's something that it's possible for the kids to consent to, whether it constitutes serious bodily harm or not.

This is not a tattoo, which would be bad enough. He branded them. Permanently.

A tattoo is also permanent.

I think what he did was stupid, but I'm not convinced it's criminal. It's borderline in my view.
 
That nobody doubts he did it because he loved his kids. What they doubt is his judgement and whether or not it's possible for a kid that age to consent.



A tattoo is also permanent.

Not really, as discussed above.

images
 
Fuji, you are an idiot.
 
The difficulty in comparing branding to tattooing is that they are not comparable. Branding is the searing and burning of flesh. It is a barbaric assault by any definition and children cannot consent. And fujii before you attempt to make some semantic comparison don't even try. It would be sheer sophistry. The two are not comparable at all.

The only difference is that there's temporarily more pain involved in a branding than in a tattoo. Is it enough pain to constitute serious bodily harm? The court did not think so, apparently.
 
That nobody doubts he did it because he loved his kids. What they doubt is his judgement and whether or not it's possible for a kid that age to consent. He plainly did not do it out of anger or any intent to harm them, in fact he did it to himself first and originally only planned to do it to himself. That's not been disputed by anyone. What's been disputed is whether it's something that it's possible for the kids to consent to, whether it constitutes serious bodily harm or not..

Why do you think it makes a difference whether or not it was done out of love. If he broke his kids arm out of tough love would that be OK.
 
What's been disputed is whether it's something that it's possible for the kids to consent to, whether it constitutes serious bodily harm or not.

BRANDING someone does not constitute bodily harm?! Explain to me how, please.

I think what he did was stupid, but I'm not convinced it's criminal. It's borderline in my view.

How is it borderline? Because he did it "out of love" and children who aren't old enough to know better think that it was okay? Please elaborate.
 
Why do you think it makes a difference whether or not it was done out of love. If he broke his kids arm out of tough love would that be OK.

I don't think it makes any legal difference whether or not it was done out of love. If you review up to where I originally made that comment you will see that.