Abolition of Pardons .......

cute-bald

Banned
Nov 14, 2005
1,280
0
0
Toronto
Please read all before commenting: I do believe we should make sure serious violent criminals & those who abuse children & sex offenders are not pardoned. Most phsychiatrists believe from their reaserch that sex offenders always have the urges & need constant help.
SOOOO onto all the rest of those who have criminal records & are not repeat " career criminals".
Harper wants those with inditable offences & those with 3 criminal charges ( not sure if at 3 different times or even 3 charges steming from 1 incident) NOT to be eligable to apply for Pardon ( Or new name they plan to call it= criminal record suspention)
PROBLEMS: fact 1) based on Ministry of Justice aprox. 10% of Canadians have criminal record
fact 2) due to internet & cheap access to records almost all employers do criminal
record background check , esp. #1 employer in Canada, the appearal & retail sector. .
fact 3) according to Pardons & Parol Canada aprox. 97 % of those Pardoned do not re-offend or get in trouble with the law in any way to re-voke a pardon.
SOOO to have those & all new individuals with a criminal record for employers to see creates in the future a growing # of Canadians virtually unable to get legal employment for which to make a decent wage above the poverty line.
DO we want a growing class of people who will find very few alternatives than to persue criminal means to earn a living???????? THINK of how many people will be in this group 20-30 years from now & if this will serve the safety & interests of the Canadian public. Remember I am not speaking about child & sex offenders & career criminals. Harper's legislation goes further than that & severly excludes most, .... other than those who had a mis-demeanor.
 
I'm no expert but my understanding is that now the parole board pretty much 'has to' grant parole in most cases. The new law will allow them to consider factors before granting parole. I don't believe that they 'can't' still grant parole in some cases.

I don't think parole should be an automatic thing.
 
Quest4Less, if you meant to type 'pardon', but accidentally typed 'parole', perhaps you could let us know. 'Parole' is an entirely different kettle of fish, and not the subject of the Cons' new bill. Since they're proposing to intoduce yet another name into the mix, it's best to keep our terms precise. But perhaps you wanted to talk about parole, if you do a new thread on that topic would keep things clearer.

'Pardon' in the context of this bill, is a procedure administered by the Parole Board which seals the pardoned offender's record from all but the police (under certain circumstances). So a guy like me who blew over .08 wouldn't show up in a criminal record check, if I got a pardon. If the employment application said: 'Have you ever been convicted of a criminal offence?' I would have to answer 'Yes' whether I had a pardon or not. And if my record was already in some foreign government's files a Canadian pardon would mean squat.

It may well be that pardons have been too easy to get, for too many criminals, but this piece of hasty pandering to brain-dead law and order types really goes overboard in the other direction. It's all about perv-pounding because of one diddling hockey coach. Where's the evidence that there's a general problem that needs to be fixed? If it really was a thought-thru concept then why wasn't it proposed back in 2007 when the Cons supposedly 'fixed' the pardons process the last time?
 
no pardons for sexual crimes or for murder. not sure about the repeat offender idea. though i like the thought about extending the period.
 
Please read all before commenting: I do believe we should make sure serious violent criminals & those who abuse children & sex offenders are not pardoned. Most phsychiatrists believe from their reaserch that sex offenders always have the urges & need constant help.
SOOOO onto all the rest of those who have criminal records & are not repeat " career criminals".
Harper wants those with inditable offences & those with 3 criminal charges ( not sure if at 3 different times or even 3 charges steming from 1 incident) NOT to be eligable to apply for Pardon ( Or new name they plan to call it= criminal record suspention)
PROBLEMS: fact 1) based on Ministry of Justice aprox. 10% of Canadians have criminal record
fact 2) due to internet & cheap access to records almost all employers do criminal
record background check , esp. #1 employer in Canada, the appearal & retail sector. .
fact 3) according to Pardons & Parol Canada aprox. 97 % of those Pardoned do not re-offend or get in trouble with the law in any way to re-voke a pardon.
SOOO to have those & all new individuals with a criminal record for employers to see creates in the future a growing # of Canadians virtually unable to get legal employment for which to make a decent wage above the poverty line.
DO we want a growing class of people who will find very few alternatives than to persue criminal means to earn a living???????? THINK of how many people will be in this group 20-30 years from now & if this will serve the safety & interests of the Canadian public. Remember I am not speaking about child & sex offenders & career criminals. Harper's legislation goes further than that & severly excludes most, .... other than those who had a mis-demeanor.

How tall are the offenders?

Just askin'. :p
 
Yes I agree this panders to brain-dead law & order extreem types but the reality of our political system ( unlike in the U.S. were the President must get the vote of Congress & has time to get proper consideration & reflection on the long term consequences) is the Prime Minister will be able to push it through. In the past 8 years in has become extreemly cheap AND easy for potential employers to check for criminal records ...... AND there has been a explosion of growth in the % of them doing so. THIS situation has not been considered & thus we will have a growing class of individuals permanently prevented from getting LEGAL employment . I think this poses a dangerous situation for us all. Will break ins, theaft, shop lifting, drug dealing get worse???? I thought Pardons were the final part of rehabilitation & full intergration of an individual into legal employment.
 
Sorry - I did in fact mean pardon not parole. Very tired when I wrote that.

I have nothing against giving someone a second chance - IF they deserve it. It should however not be an automatic thing - it deserves very carefull thought and consideration. Some people do not DESERVE a second chance - much less a third or fourth chance (in some cases).
 
Quest4Less, if you meant to type 'pardon', but accidentally typed 'parole', perhaps you could let us know. 'Parole' is an entirely different kettle of fish, and not the subject of the Cons' new bill. Since they're proposing to intoduce yet another name into the mix, it's best to keep our terms precise. But perhaps you wanted to talk about parole, if you do a new thread on that topic would keep things clearer.

'Pardon' in the context of this bill, is a procedure administered by the Parole Board which seals the pardoned offender's record from all but the police (under certain circumstances). So a guy like me who blew over .08 wouldn't show up in a criminal record check, if I got a pardon. If the employment application said: 'Have you ever been convicted of a criminal offence?' I would have to answer 'Yes' whether I had a pardon or not. And if my record was already in some foreign government's files a Canadian pardon would mean squat.

It may well be that pardons have been too easy to get, for too many criminals, but this piece of hasty pandering to brain-dead law and order types really goes overboard in the other direction. It's all about perv-pounding because of one diddling hockey coach. Where's the evidence that there's a general problem that needs to be fixed? If it really was a thought-thru concept then why wasn't it proposed back in 2007 when the Cons supposedly 'fixed' the pardons process the last time?

+1 from me. Harper is an asshole. I guess he wants to get the yokels to start cheering for him again come election time.
 
As stated, I too am all for giving someone a second chance but as for repeat offenders? No fricken way. They've had their second, third and fourth chances.

If someone made a mistake when they were in their 20's, and lived a law abiding life for 10 yrs or more, then yeah, they should be reviewed and possibly pardoned. But the whole thing about breaking the law and getting caught is that there are plenty and I mean PLENTY of other law abiding people who would be elligible to get the job, cross the border etc. Why should a criminal have a leg up on them?

The thing is, many commit crimes without care for the results now. Remove the added threat of a life long record and where's the deterrent? They already get a slap on the wrist in jail time.....

I know someone who spent YEARS in school getting a degree and then went out and committed a crime that prevents them from working in the field they trained for. I thought, well just how stupid do you have to be?
 
It should depend on the nature of crime. Currently, even if you get caught shoplifting with $2.00 worth of stuff in walmart, BAN! life long record! can't get job anywhere. or at least 5 years before you can apply for pardon. Even after pardon, it only erases CRIMINAL RECORD, but POLICE RECORD stays FOREVER. So BAN! still can't get a descent job... What do some of these poeple do? They keep committing crimes. nothing to lose right? Employers will turn you down if there is 1 record or 10 records doesn't make much difference anyway. That's why I think for lesser crimes, such as shoplifting or street fight or misdemeaners, police should not be able to keep record forever.
 
One can definitely make a good case for fixing this part (and many others) of our justice system. The Cons should send flowers to Gordon James in Mexico, for reminding them Stockwell said he was gonna fix this back in '06, (and they claimed they had in 2007). It's an issue that could actually get them past their self-imposed 30% ceiling, because a busted legal system serves no one. But neither does the stupid, bludgeoning, "if you're not for this bill, and the rights of victims, then you must prefer criminals' rights should take precedence" line that Vic Toews is using. Shades of Afghan detainees; "Anyone questioning what we're doing is attacking our brave troops."

Do these guys really have such a low opinion of anyone not a charter member of their Reform Club? No wonder after five years they still have two outta three voters against them.
 
Here is the information on how to obtain a pardon

http://pardons.org/index.html Please read this, specifically the employment section.

On a job application, the would be "have you ever been convicted of a criminal offence for which a pardon has not been granted?" Yes/No

For certain career and volunteer positions, there is a separate search done by the RCMP called vulnerable sector search.

How to decipher what crimes should never be pardoned?
Drug trafficing, Human trafficing
The distinctions between Murder1, Murder2 and Manslaughter-read the fine print too. http://info.lawyershop.ca/criminal/...st-and-second-degree-murder-and-manslaughter/ Read the sections of killing a police officer and killing someone while driving impaired.
Any crimes, against children, seniors or hate related, should never be pardoned.
Repeated violence should never be pardoned.
Gang association and Arson should never be pardoned
Fraud (the Conrad Black kind) should never be pardoned

The real problem is classifying what crimes to be listed:
A=never pardoned
B=pardoned with conditions
C=pardoned and sealed

Example: I'm defending myself and I punch the other person, who falls and dies from hitting the ground, not from my punch. Manslaughter, but should I get a pardon after my time is served?

Example: I'm pulled over at a ride check and blow 1.00. but I'm not a drinker, had a couple at dinner sort of thing. Lose the license, criminal record, but should I not receive a pardon when warranted?

Here's another: True story: P.C. Kim Walker of Hamilton Police Service was just convicted of impaired driving, causing 20K damage to a private citizen's fence, and she left the scene. She blew 1.74 2x the limit. Her sentence: loss of license 1 year, 1500 fine, 20K restitution for the property damage. Under the police act, she was demoted for 15 months (loss of 14K approximately), must walk a beat or desk duty because she can't drive, has a criminal record now. That 14K income loss, she'll work overtime and paid duties-earn her regular income and then some. The charge of leaving the scene was dropped.
Question:
Should she have lost her job? She is a police officer sworn by oath to abide by the rules.
Should she ever be pardoned because she is a police officer and let's see if there is a pattern of behaviours?

Now, I make it no secret that I support the Police, but when they commit crimes and are convicted of crimes get rid of them.

This is just an example.

Sometimes, good people screw up.
 
I know for a fact that if you are CHARGED with any minor crime such as shop lifting or assult, it does not even have to have conviction, it will stay on police record FOREVER. If you want to get a job in security or law enforcement or any jobs that are security sensitive, you will have tough luck! Also you will be searched every time when crossing the border or getting on the airplane. Now is this fair?
On one hand, it serves as a constant reminder that he has made a mistake in the past and not to repeat it. On the other hand, it makes him feel he is now being labeled as a criminal for life NO MATTER WHAT HE DOES, he wil always be scrutinized and descriminated in job market.
 
I know for a fact that if you are CHARGED with any minor crime such as shop lifting or assult, it does not even have to have conviction, it will stay on police record FOREVER. If you want to get a job in security or law enforcement or any jobs that are security sensitive, you will have tough luck! Also you will be searched every time when crossing the border or getting on the airplane. Now is this fair?
On one hand, it serves as a constant reminder that he has made a mistake in the past and not to repeat it. On the other hand, it makes him feel he is now being labeled as a criminal for life NO MATTER WHAT HE DOES, he wil always be scrutinized and descriminated in job market.

Which one did you do? How sure are you?
 
I know for a fact that if you are CHARGED with any minor crime such as shop lifting or assult, it does not even have to have conviction, it will stay on police record FOREVER. If you want to get a job in security or law enforcement or any jobs that are security sensitive, you will have tough luck! Also you will be searched every time when crossing the border or getting on the airplane.

Then you'd better get your facts straight cuz you're dead nuts WRONG!

If you get charged and the charge gets dismissed (it can't just remain as a charge forever), it's supposed to be wiped from the criminal database. If you have a lawyer then part of the lawyer's job is to write a letter requesting that your photo and fingerprints be removed from the database as well. There was a case where the cops got sued for millions and lost over not removing the information so they're pretty on the ball now with removing the data (although it may take a number of months).

If a CPIC search is done after the charge has been dismissed, it won't turn up anything. This includes for charges that you were later granted a pardon for (possibly with the exception of sexual offenses when you're doing a CPIC check for an inquiry related to a vulnerable persons check; i.e., working with young children, which is a different form of check). Note, a pardon does not delete your criminal conviction file, it just seals it. If you later get in trouble with the law again, your file can be reopened and will once again will show up on CPIC.

Once on CPIC, if you cross the US border and customs does a search in the Canadian database (which they have access to), they will download your info onto their system where it will stay FOREVER. Doesn't matter if you subsequently get a pardon, the Americans don't recognize it and they won't take you off their database once they have your info. So if you have a charge you're fighting, you should avoid going to the US until after you have either beaten the charge and it's been removed off CPIC, or until you've received a pardon and the conviction has been removed from CPIC. That way if US customs does a search, they won't find anything to download to their database.

The police service (e.g., Toronto, Peel, York, etc.) that originally charged you has the right to retain your information related to your arrest on its files (i.e., they're not going to destroy the officer's notes, the in-processing paperwork when you were arrested, etc.) but they use the same CPIC database as all the other police so that will show up empty if searched.
 
Then you'd better get your facts straight cuz you're dead nuts WRONG!

If you get charged and the charge gets dismissed (it can't just remain as a charge forever), it's supposed to be wiped from the criminal database. If you have a lawyer then part of the lawyer's job is to write a letter requesting that your photo and fingerprints be removed from the database as well. There was a case where the cops got sued for millions and lost over not removing the information so they're pretty on the ball now with removing the data (although it may take a number of months).

If a CPIC search is done after the charge has been dismissed, it won't turn up anything. This includes for charges that you were later granted a pardon for (possibly with the exception of sexual offenses when you're doing a CPIC check for an inquiry related to a vulnerable persons check; i.e., working with young children, which is a different form of check). Note, a pardon does not delete your criminal conviction file, it just seals it. If you later get in trouble with the law again, your file can be reopened and will once again will show up on CPIC.

Once on CPIC, if you cross the US border and customs does a search in the Canadian database (which they have access to), they will download your info onto their system where it will stay FOREVER. Doesn't matter if you subsequently get a pardon, the Americans don't recognize it and they won't take you off their database once they have your info. So if you have a charge you're fighting, you should avoid going to the US until after you have either beaten the charge and it's been removed off CPIC, or until you've received a pardon and the conviction has been removed from CPIC. That way if US customs does a search, they won't find anything to download to their database.

The police service (e.g., Toronto, Peel, York, etc.) that originally charged you has the right to retain your information related to your arrest on its files (i.e., they're not going to destroy the officer's notes, the in-processing paperwork when you were arrested, etc.) but they use the same CPIC database as all the other police so that will show up empty if searched.

Unbelievable, we agree. Post 13.
 
I would say some sexual offenders should be allowed to be pardoned. But hear me out before you tar and feather me.

Let's say I get piss drunk. I mean really piss drunk. And I grab the bottom or breasts of a woman. She is pissed (naturally) and calls the police. She charges me with sexual harrassment, etc. and the charges stick in court because people saw me do it. But I don't remember doing it. I'm convicted and labelled a sex offender. yada yada yada Several years later, I am eligible for a pardon. I have not reoffended, nor have I had any urges to reoffend. I am granted the pardon because of the aforementioned facts. And I continue to live my life without offending in that way again.

From what I have heard, even this one-time occurence would condemn me to a life as a sex offender ineligible for a pardon under the new 'regulations' being debated. And that's wrong. I think the system should stay as it is, i.e. anyone can apply. BUT, we need to strengthen the analysis of each application, so that those who are rehabilitated can receive a pardon and those who are not can not.

Just my thoughts.
 
....... based on Ministry of Justice aprox. 10% of Canadians have criminal record
.......

Yikes.... I'll keep a better hold on my wallet next time I'm in YYZ

OTB