Russian naval forces storm hijacked oil tanker, killing 1 pirate, arresting 10

I like that suggestion very much Papa. We should have some semblance of due process.

And much more credible than a Dubya pseudo Military Tribunal!....:cool:
 
Somali Pirates Hijack Chemical Tanker With 22 Crew
By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS

NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) -- Somali pirates armed with rocket-propelled grenades and automatic guns hijacked a chemical tanker off East Africa with 22 crew members on board, the European Union Naval force said Saturday.
Spokesman Cmdr. John Harbour said there is little chance that military forces can storm the ship because officials don't believe the crew all made it to a safe room before the pirates boarded. The crew consists of 19 Indians, 2 Bangladeshis and 1 Ukrainian, he said. The ship -- the Marida Marguerite -- was heading from India to Belgium.
Also Saturday, Taiwan's Foreign Ministry said a Taiwanese fishing boat was hijacked off the Somali coast by pirates who demanded a ransom for the crew.
The ship's Taiwanese owner lost contact with Tai Yuan 227 two days ago as it headed for the Maldives. When the owner resumed contact with the vessel a day later, he was told by hijackers to pay a ransom for the crew, the ministry said.
''The boat has since changed direction to sail toward Somalia, so this may very well have been done by the Somali pirates,'' the ministry said in a statement. ''We hope that the many other boats sailing in the area can stay alert and avoid the pirates from launching an attack at other boats from the Tai Yuan 227.''
It wasn't immediately clear how many crew were aboard the trawler.
Foreign Ministry officials refused to provide contact information for the boat's owner, saying he wanted to remain anonymous until the crew was released.
Pirate attacks have continued to climb despite the presence of about 35 international warships patrolling the waters off the lawless Somalia coast.
Pirates currently hold more than 300 hostages taken from ships attacked off East Africa in the last several months. Eleven suspected Somali pirates were indicted in U.S. federal court late last month, but the international community has had problems formulating an accepted policy to try and jail pirate suspects.
Pirates boarded the Russian tanker Moscow University off the coast of Somalia on Wednesday. They were arrested Thursday after special forces from a Russian warship stormed the tanker. A gunbattle ensued in which one pirate was killed, and 10 others were detained.
The pirates seized were released because of ''imperfections'' in international law, Russia's Defense Ministry said Friday, a claim that sparked skepticism -- and even suspicion the pirates might have been killed.
Anarchy has reigned in Somalia since 1991, when warlords overthrew longtime dictator Mohamed Siad Barre and then turned on each other. The weak Somali government controls only a small bit of the capital, Mogadishu, and is battling Islamic insurgents. The lawlessness has allowed the piracy trade to flourish off Somalia's coastline.
 
I said the reason we don't do it is for moral reasons. At least, that's my reason. Punishment must fit the crime. And for the utilitarians....?? What's theirs? Afterall, killing is both cheap and effective.

jwm

Funny, at the time it seemed you were making a blanket statement. I don't remember all those qualifications, but perhaps you can dig up your post for me so I can see if I got it wrong.
 
Pirate should be tried by a Uniform Naval Court and if found guilty Handed by the neck until dead.

Wouldn't it be easier to hang them? Handed by the neck seems like it would take awhile.
 
Funny, at the time it seemed you were making a blanket statement. I don't remember all those qualifications, but perhaps you can dig up your post for me so I can see if I got it wrong.

I know the one particular post that you're referring to. It was deliberately provocative on my part. However, it was part of making a larger point over several posts so I'm also giving you the context for it. I think most missed that.

Anyway, I thought it was part of your Norway prison thread but I don't see it there. Hell, I've looked at the posts under my profile and I don't see it anywhere now. Maybe I'm just tired now and I'm missing what's right in front of my eyes or maybe someone deleted a post and, as a response, it went with it? Dunno. I'll take another look when I wake from my siesta.

jwm
 
I know the one particular post that you're referring to. It was deliberately provocative on my part. However, it was part of making a larger point over several posts so I'm also giving you the context for it. I think most missed that.

Anyway, I thought it was part of your Norway prison thread but I don't see it there. Hell, I've looked at the posts under my profile and I don't see it anywhere now. Maybe I'm just tired now and I'm missing what's right in front of my eyes or maybe someone deleted a post and, as a response, it went with it? Dunno. I'll take another look when I wake from my siesta.

jwm

No, you're probably not missing it, it's just that the search function for terb is farked. Before they switched over to the new system you could see anyone's posts in chronological order. Not anymore.
 
The pirates seized were released because of ''imperfections'' in international law, Russia's Defense Ministry said Friday, a claim that sparked skepticism -- and even suspicion the pirates might have been killed.
Ah, you already posted it Seth. There does appear to be more than meets the eye about the story. Since quite what "imperfections" the Russian Defense Ministry has in mind are a matter of wonder and puzelment, since Russia was untroubled by such "imperfections" in the case of the Arctic Sea last summer.
 
Ah, you already posted it Seth. There does appear to be more than meets the eye about the story. Since quite what "imperfections" the Russian Defense Ministry has in mind are a matter of wonder and puzelment, since Russia was untroubled by such "imperfections" in the case of the Arctic Sea last summer.

Russia is not the only country to release pirates after capture and certainly not the first that has used problems with international law as a reason.
 
No, you're probably not missing it, it's just that the search function for terb is farked. Before they switched over to the new system you could see anyone's posts in chronological order. Not anymore.

I tried looking again. When I go to my profile and I click to see my posts, that function seems to work fine. But the post in question? I just don't see it. Sorry I can't be more helpful.

jwm
 
I tried looking again. When I go to my profile and I click to see my posts, that function seems to work fine. But the post in question? I just don't see it. Sorry I can't be more helpful.

jwm

Like I said, since they switched over to the new system it doesn't really work like it did. If you go to anyone's profile and click "find all posts", it doesn't. It will show some and omit others, seemingly with no rime or reason. Worked fine before the change, not now. Of course the terb search function has always been woefully inadequate. I place it just slightly higher in value then the terb clock.
 
Russia is not the only country to release pirates after capture and certainly not the first that has used problems with international law as a reason.
True, but the "problems with international law" excuse, has no legs.
 
Like I said, since they switched over to the new system it doesn`t really work like it did. If you go to anyone`s profile and click "find all posts", it doesn`t. It will show some and omit others, seemingly with no rime or reason. Worked fine before the change, not now. Of course the terb search function has always been woefully inadequate. I place it just slightly higher in value then the terb clock.

Okay, found the thread in question and here are some of my posts with respect to your query:
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3102960&viewfull=1#post3102960
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3104512&viewfull=1#post3104512
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3104633&viewfull=1#post3104633
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3104939&viewfull=1#post3104939
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3104944&viewfull=1#post3104944
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...ers-billions&p=3104968&viewfull=1#post3104968

jwm
 
I agree. Russia should have used those "problems" to their advantage and made the idiots disappear forever IMHO.

Apparently, they might have done just that:

"A number of pirates have been simply released, either back ashore or back to their boats, after being disarmed of any weapons that they didn’t already throw overboard themselves prior to capture.

The Russians have come up with a nastier version of this tactic, basically abandoning the pirates far at sea with only the most basic of supplies. Oddly enough, they did want to prosecute the pirates back in Russia, but abandoned that idea because the ship’s crew of the attacked vessel, were not able to directly identify the pirates, given that they were holed up in a secure room, unable to negate the pirate claims that they too were victims of other pirates who got away.

...apparently the Russians stripped the boat of any navigational equipment before setting them free with a tank of fuel."

http://blog.usni.org/2010/05/10/pirates-walk-the-plank/

As far as I know, Russia is the first to "release" pirates in this manner.
 
Apparently, they might have done just that:

"A number of pirates have been simply released, either back ashore or back to their boats, after being disarmed of any weapons that they didn’t already throw overboard themselves prior to capture.

The Russians have come up with a nastier version of this tactic, basically abandoning the pirates far at sea with only the most basic of supplies.
As far as I know, Russia is the first to "release" pirates in this manner.

"One thing is for sure, pirates will not mess around with the Russians once word gets out about what happened to their fellow bandits"
 
Okay, found the thread in question and here are some of my posts with respect to your query:


jwm
Like I said at the time, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt you were just amusing yourself. If it was sarcasm it really wasn't working.
 
one of the things I have noticed over the years is people would give terrorists their children if it meant no problems.

I am perhaps old school but I say blow the bastard into next year.

Come to my house with a gun and I will blow the back of your head off with it


Come to my house with a bomb and I will blow your ass off with it.

You decide where I shove the weapon you bring
 
Like I said at the time, I'll give you the benefit of the doubt you were just amusing yourself. If it was sarcasm it really wasn't working.

DQ you aint and will never be


He had class
 
DQ you aint and will never be


He had class

Yes he did, and as much as you can say about someone you have gotten to know over the internet, I considered him a friend of mine. I certainly never tried to compare myself to him, so I have no idea where the hell you come out of the blue with a comment like that. If I disappoint you, trust me I can live with it.

I lost three friends last year, and DQ was one of them. Do yourself a favor and don't go there.