Get tough on crime legislation will cost taxpayers billions

Don't tell me you guys are moving towards a US style of justice system. You know, the one that has quadrupled the number of people in jail since 1980. Trust me, you can't afford it.

I hope that we are not, however cost should not be reason that we should back away from punishing criminal behaviour.

Here in Canada, our police officers are too damn busy writing tickets to put anyone in jail.
I don't know the reason that the number of people in jails quadrupled in the US, but what is your alternative?
 
I hope that we are not, however cost should not be reason that we should back away from punishing criminal behaviour.

Here in Canada, our police officers are too damn busy writing tickets to put anyone in jail.
I don't know the reason that the number of people in jails quadrupled in the US, but what is your alternative?

The reason why incarceration has quadrupled in the US since 1980 is due to a couple things. One is three strikes you're out, which Clinton championed. The other is that we have decided to raise the penalty and time served for simple drug possession. Possession of drugs like crack for example, for which the penalty and jail time served is much higher then cocaine possession. This has an additional effect of targeting the poor. In addition the stigma of any felony conviction in the US is impossible to shake. It will follow those so convicted well after they have served their time and make it virtually impossible for them to gain access back into normal society. The US is the biggest jailer nation per capita in the world, and it hasn't made us any safer. You guys want to go down that route, have at it.
 
Putting people in jail is good for just one thing: Putting people in jail. While there's some evidence that some crooks are deterred from some crimes by seeing their buds get hard time, most are too dumb to connect themselves to that picture of their future. If it was a winner in the War on Crime, it woulda won centuries ago. It's been a loser ever since the first prison.

But if you're prepared to lock'em up and pay to keep them there while they attend Crime College, it does keep them, off the streets. Leaving the smart ones, and the young up and comers in control. Until the Wiser Nastier Older Guy gets released.

Stiffer sentences get votes from dummies who think there hasta be an easy answer for everything..
 
Guy Paul Morin, Donald Marshall, Thomas Sophonow, Stephen Truscott.

Oh, and a buncha people a bungling, incompetent Ontario pathologist gave untrue testimony about.

But none of that ever happens these days, right all_wet_one?

I see that you missed my tongue in my cheek. Ah well, the written word isn't the best for relaying sarcasm...

All the same, kill them all and let God sort'em out. Worked for the Duke! ;)
 
Putting people in jail is good for just one thing: Putting people in jail. While there's some evidence that some crooks are deterred from some crimes by seeing their buds get hard time, most are too dumb to connect themselves to that picture of their future. If it was a winner in the War on Crime, it woulda won centuries ago. It's been a loser ever since the first prison.

But if you're prepared to lock'em up and pay to keep them there while they attend Crime College, it does keep them, off the streets. Leaving the smart ones, and the young up and comers in control. Until the Wiser Nastier Older Guy gets released.

Stiffer sentences get votes from dummies who think there hasta be an easy answer for everything..

Methinks we have the winning analysis here.

That said, something has to be done with the bad guys...
 
A recent Oped in the Star:


"We are absolutely convinced in our consultation with Canadians that this is welcomed." That was Justice Minister Rob Nicholson's only response to questions about what evidence supports the government's Bill C-15, which would impose mandatory minimum sentences for certain drug crimes.
Not exactly the sort of evidence one would expect to justify a new law that will have tremendous social and fiscal costs for us all. There are no credible studies to show that this approach is likely to be effective in decreasing drug crimes, no examples from other countries, no reviews of the best-practices literature, not even case studies of individuals who have stopped dealing or using as a result of this approach.
The reason is that this research doesn't exist; in fact, the research shows the opposite. Mandatory minimum sentences have been a clear disaster in the U.S., spiralling the cost of the criminal justice system out of control and doing nothing to decrease crime rates. So why would the Canadians who were polled by the government "welcome" a law that will cost them millions but not make them any safer?
For many in the criminal justice policy field, Nicholson's answer underscored the need for more meaningful and informed public discussion about prisons: how they work, what purposes they serve and how the criminal justice system can be more effective.
Unlike other public policy areas such as health care, criminal justice policy is often debated only by noisy pundits and ideologues, and with little attention to the evidence.
In fact, it is important for us all to think and talk about prisons because we are all affected by them. We pay for them, we depend on them to make our communities safer and we are concerned if abuses occur inside. Some worry about their parents and children living inside.
While many think that prisons serve to prevent crime, this is a function that they perform very poorly, if at all. Prisons are isolating, violent, overcrowded and stagnating places where people's anti-social behaviours worsen. Though it may be counterintuitive, prison stays fail to have a deterrent effect, meaning that sending someone to prison in no way decreases the chance that they will reoffend after their release. In fact, research shows that many prison settings actually increase the likelihood that those who leave will reoffend. Compared to evidence-based correctional programs in the community, prison is very poor at reducing further criminal behaviour.
Nor do sentences of incarceration have any meaningful general deterrent effect. Sentencing convicted people to certain or longer prison terms has no impact on the criminal behaviour of others. If it did, then the murder rate in Canada would have skyrocketed after the death penalty was abolished (in fact, it went down steadily in the years following, along with the general crime rate). So the argument that sending people to prison "teaches them a lesson" or "sends a message" to other bad guys is a fallacy.
So what about the programming offered inside prisons? While laudable in many regards, these programs cannot be as effective as those offered in community settings. The lessons learned are impossible to meaningfully practise and incorporate, and are often contradicted by the social skills required in the "gladiator school" culture of many prisons. Prison mainly teaches people how to survive in prison – a set of skills that doesn't make our communities safer once prisoners are released.
Sending people to prison may meet a need for vengeance when we're understandably angry at those who cause hurt and fear in our communities. But the redemption that we hope to see will not be created in prison environments. We mustn't let our anger get in the way of recognizing the research about what works, particularly since the vast majority of prisoners eventually return to our communities.
Part of the reason is that our prisons house a great number of those with treatment needs that contribute to the behaviours that landed them in the system and that are poorly met in prison environments.
Rates of addiction, mental health concerns, fetal alcohol syndrome and a host of other health and social issues are all disproportionately high inside our prisons.
Prisons are not a treatment centre for addictions, mental health concerns and other health issues; in many cases they make them worse.
So what function does prison serve well? It can incapacitate, for a time, those few among us whom we have decided are too dangerous to live in our communities. That's important, but that's all.
If we want to be smart about crime, meaning that we want to make community safety the main goal of our criminal justice system, then imprisoning more people is not the answer.
Mandatory minimum sentences legislation will have only one effect: sending many, many more people to prison. At an average cost of $164 per inmate per day in Ontario, this is an extraordinarily expensive mistake.
The research clearly shows us what to do: community-based correctional programs that keep most convicted people out of jail and busy in programs that meaningfully target their anti-social behaviour while keeping them connected to positive social networks.
More broadly, the most effective (and also, incidentally, the cheapest) approach is to prevent crime in the first place through social development. Effective crime prevention starts with ensuring quality education and health care, employment opportunities and a range of social supports. Our reliance on prisons to solve the problem of crime is deeply misguided.
Getting "tough" about crime might sound good, but it will not make us safer – only getting smart will do that.
 
If community safety and saving money is to be our goal, there are indeed many ways of achieving that. Wet-suit-one's tongue-in-cheek proposal seems viable. Sure, some innocents would be killed but why, under this proposal, should we mourn them anymore than those who are killed by murderers? Tell their noisy protesting families (Danmand: I think in another thread you so described some victims' families.) to suck it up in the name of community safety. Kind of, shoe on the other foot, wouldn't you say?

Or, staying in the real world, perhaps we should hang drug traffickers as they do in Singapore? And cut off the hands of petty thieves as they do in some Middle East countries? With respect to the latter, I understand that in many such places, you can go to prayers and not worry about your worldly goods being taken.

Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?

jwm
 
If community safety and saving money is to be our goal, there are indeed many ways of achieving that. Wet-suit-one's tongue-in-cheek proposal seems viable. Sure, some innocents would be killed but why, under this proposal, should we mourn them anymore than those who are killed by murderers? Tell their noisy protesting families (Danmand: I think in another thread you so described some victims' families.) to suck it up in the name of community safety. Kind of, shoe on the other foot, wouldn't you say?

Or, staying in the real world, perhaps we should hang drug traffickers as they do in Singapore? And cut off the hands of petty thieves as they do in some Middle East countries? With respect to the latter, I understand that in many such places, you can go to prayers and not worry about your worldly goods being taken.

Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?



jwm

This is not about murders. We are not building more prisons because of incarcertation of murderers. The number of murders in Canada is
declining.

try drug users instead.
 
This is not about murders. We are not building more prisons because of incarcertation of murderers. The number of murders in Canada is
declining.

try drug users instead.

I didn't restrict myself to murderers in what I wrote. That indeed is my point. Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?, i.e. why not shoot them all.

jwm
 
If community safety and saving money is to be our goal, there are indeed many ways of achieving that. Wet-suit-one's tongue-in-cheek proposal seems viable. Sure, some innocents would be killed but why, under this proposal, should we mourn them anymore than those who are killed by murderers? Tell their noisy protesting families (Danmand: I think in another thread you so described some victims' families.) to suck it up in the name of community safety. Kind of, shoe on the other foot, wouldn't you say?

Or, staying in the real world, perhaps we should hang drug traffickers as they do in Singapore? And cut off the hands of petty thieves as they do in some Middle East countries? With respect to the latter, I understand that in many such places, you can go to prayers and not worry about your worldly goods being taken.

Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?

jwm
This proposal has nothing to do with community safety, nor the wise use of money or the saving of it; it's entitrely about pandering to your political base.
 
This proposal has nothing to do with community safety, nor the wise use of money or the saving of it; it's entitrely about pandering to your political base.

This thread has kinda moved along from the political, wouldn't you say? We're now also looking at the reasonings behind imprisoning people or not.

jwm
 
That was the original post, to which I replied: Is that what you're after? Or do you want a time-wasting primer on recent Canadian political history? If an exegisis of the stuff I referred to is 'needed', someone will ask. Or you can supply it I am sure.

No actually the context would be the economic collapse which triggered the spending, which by the way was demanded by all three of the other parties... that would be the context
 
I didn't restrict myself to murderers in what I wrote. That indeed is my point. Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?, i.e. why not shoot them all.

When you say justice, you really mean revenge. And clearly the candian justice system is mainly based upon revenge.

If I was in charge of the countrty, I would want as few people as possible in jail. People in jail are not paying taxes, on the contrary, they cost lots of money to house and guard. I would want the penal system to be focused upon rehabilitation. Apart from dangerous offenders, who has to be kept in secure institutions, I would treat drug users and mental patients, and in general make an effort to get offenders back into society, back to paying taxes.

Now, I realize that Harper got into power fair and square, and I would imagine that most canadians like you are happy with his approach to justice. I just do not like my tax dollars to go to incarcerating people, that possibly could be productive members of society. Then again I do not like to pay for the adventure in Afghanistan.
 
I didn't restrict myself to murderers in what I wrote. That indeed is my point. Once we no longer concern ourselves with that old-fashioned notion of justice, of criminals receiving their just deserts, but no more, you have to ask yourself, well why not?, i.e. why not shoot them all.

jwm

I'm beginning to think you're just pulling our collective leg. You can't possibly be serious.
 
When you say justice, you really mean revenge. And clearly the candian justice system is mainly based upon revenge.

If I was in charge of the countrty, I would want as few people as possible in jail. People in jail are not paying taxes, on the contrary, they cost lots of money to house and guard. I would want the penal system to be focused upon rehabilitation. Apart from dangerous offenders, who has to be kept in secure institutions, I would treat drug users and mental patients, and in general make an effort to get offenders back into society, back to paying taxes.

Now, I realize that Harper got into power fair and square, and I would imagine that most canadians like you are happy with his approach to justice. I just do not like my tax dollars to go to incarcerating people, that possibly could be productive members of society. Then again I do not like to pay for the adventure in Afghanistan.

What is the restraint upon your seemingly benign rehabilitative efforts? Suppose you are dealing with a petty thief who is resistant to change. Could he be subject to an indefinite attempt to change his behaviour, i.e. a sort of indefinite sentence? Maybe twenty years of probation and parole for stealing a loaf of bread? And if not, what guards against that type of lengthy coercion if not a sense of proportionality to the original offence?

jwm
 
I'm beginning to think you're just pulling our collective leg. You can't possibly be serious.

What would be our reason for not shooting them all? It would be cheap and effective. What restrains us from doing so? That's what I'm driving at.

jwm
 
What would be our reason for not shooting them all? It would be cheap and effective. What restrains us from doing so? That's what I'm driving at.

jwm

Because it would be mass murder. Or do you condone that kind of thing.
 
No actually the context would be the economic collapse which triggered the spending, which by the way was demanded by all three of the other parties... that would be the context

Oh here we go again. Harpo was warned cutting the GST was trouble. He was warned he might well run a deficit as a result. Thus his famous dictum—like Drapeaus's—stupid, and soon to be proven wrong. After which the world's economies went south, sparing him from holding the bag alone.

"Our government will never run deficits", means they'll NEVER run deficits. No matter what. Even children know better than to make stupid undertakings like that. That's the context.

Stupid then, stupid now. When you say dumb stuff like the deficit boast, or 'stiffer sentences will take care of crime', you either think your audience is doltish enough to believe your lies, or you're so cynical you realize they'll vote for you even if they know it's crap.

Got anything to say on topic?
 
Because it would be mass murder. Or do you condone that kind of thing.

What would impel you to call it "mass murder" if they were found guilty by due process? I'm pushing the idea of proportionality to the original crime but you may have something else in mind.

jwm