Is Hawkings right ?????

Is Hawkings right ??

  • They will turn us into sex slaves

    Votes: 13 38.2%
  • They will be peaceful and give us great knowledge

    Votes: 6 17.6%
  • They want to force their religion on us

    Votes: 9 26.5%
  • No such thing as ET

    Votes: 6 17.6%

  • Total voters
    34
I thought about that one time, do aliens believe in God? But what is God? To me God is life, because in the end, logically it comes down to you either live or die, and whether that generation lives or dies. And things that live are attractive and are mathematically closer to the golden ratio. Things evolve over time either to become more attractive for a mate, or more destructive to protect and survive, read hawkins "the greatest show on earth." Aliens really don't have to come destroy our planet because we're doing it to ourselves anyways so it's pointless, waste of their time. Things that are alive stay alive and make others around it alive (sun, superstars that inspire other people), while things that die self-degenerate and self-destruct, eg.human disease, suicide...etc (read david dawkins). Another reason why I believe aliens exist is because it is mathematically impossible that we are the most "intelligent" beings on in the entire universe when we are the most destructive and stupidest as well. It's like us using a nuke to destroy an ant farm. Also, some of us believe there are humans that are worse than animals! Communicating to aliens would be like try to communicate to ants, insects, and other animals. I mean there is life in the waters, on land, in the dirt, in the air, in the trees, and most likely in space. They probably have great knowledge, but they probably want us to work for it, and self develop.
 
even if there are ET (very good chance - somewhere in the infinite or nearly-so universe) they won't be coming here and we won't be going there. All the interstellar travel stuff is just so much science fiction fodder, same thing with time travel - so get real, Steve!!:rolleyes:

It was once thought that flight and space exploration were science fiction.
 
We're applying human ethics, the sum of about 8000 years of physical, intellectual, cultural, philosophical, and spiritual evolution to an alien life form. This life form had its own such evolution. They would view us in a way we can probably can't imagine or understand.

We have a hard time understanding how our great-grandparents did things, imagine something that doesn't share the same biology.
 
So you're saying another lifeform would travel across the universe just to spend some time on the beach at Waikiki. Somehow I doubt that.

Exploration and adventure was what I was getting at :] Not relaxation vacation. Although they could come for that too :]
 
50 years ago people thought that in the year of 2000 humans would be wearing spacesuits and flying to work like the Jetsons did. And yet here we are. If there are other life forms out there on aother planet I don't think we will see it in our lifetime. Exploration on other planets could take hundreds of years. As with every generation in each century, something is always discovered but I don't think the aliens are coming to us. lol.
 
We're applying human ethics, the sum of about 8000 years of physical, intellectual, cultural, philosophical, and spiritual evolution to an alien life form. This life form had its own such evolution. They would view us in a way we can probably can't imagine or understand.

We have a hard time understanding how our great-grandparents did things, imagine something that doesn't share the same biology.

I agree with you that it might be a fallacy to use human experience to model how aliens might behave. However, I think it might be more of a mistake to assume that we can't imaine or understand what they are like

Regardless of their biology, it it almost guaranteed that they would have to be a lot more advanced than our current society if they have achieved interplanetary travel. They probably would have gone through a similar
evolution as ourselves. Maslow's hierarchy of needs probably still applies. Initially their society was more of an individualized primitive society taking care of their individual needs to survive and procreate. Over time
that would have developed to organized tribes, with all the problems that go along with that. Although war does breed innovation, the real development of a society is in times of peace.

Anyways, who knows
 
Forgot to mention, Aliens have already visited this planet leaving behind many indications of their visit. The Bible was probably their handiwork.
 
Forgot to mention, Aliens have already visited this planet leaving behind many indications of their visit. The Bible was probably their handiwork.

Very true. Ever wonder why churches have steeples? Because they look like space ships.
 
Given

All species evolve in a Darwinian fashion IE survival of the fittest.
This is a universal law that has to be accepted until there is evidence to the contrary...

Gotta get Darwin right first.
"Survival does not go to the strongest of the species but the one most adaptive to change." - Charles Darwin.
 
Exploration and adventure was what I was getting at :] Not relaxation vacation. Although they could come for that too :]

I was joking, but exploration has always translated to domination, no matter what you are talking about. Whether it's plants, animals, microbes or whatever. Living forms introduced into a new environment where they can suck the air out of the room, will naturally do exactly that. It has nothing to do with conscious intent, it's simply what living things do. The only thing that keeps anything in check is adequate competition. Take that away and things quickly run amok.
 
They could be hostile, but if they are so advanced to travel light years, why would they need to conquer anything? This isn't about cowboys vs. Indians. Any such ETs would have evolved into a superior state of being, if they survived that far into the future - well beyond ours.

Ever think that they might want to study other intelligent life forms, the progression of life or civilizations, or perhaps just to make contact?

No, I think they'd pretty much be famished and the whole thing took longer than they thought. Probably a bit pissed off to boot that they came all that way for such a weany little planet.
 
Ever think that they might want to study other intelligent life forms,
If that is the case they will be extremely disappointed when they arrive...
happy0188.gif
 
They could be hostile, but if they are so advanced to travel light years, why would they need to conquer anything?
If they are an expanding life form, then they will have to look, process and change environments to sustain and expand their populations. Most of the reactions I've read so far assume they will hold us with some mutual intellectual respect for humanity and for life in general. We could be the intellectual level of gnats to them.

Let's suppose that the intellectual gap is relatively close such as the difference between us and cows. Don't we breed and eat cows ??

Let's also make a parallel example - you are landing on a new sandy beach - do you ever look down to avoid walking on ants ?
 
To the poll...none of the above. But I think Hawkings is right. If aliens do make it here they are:
1. Much more advanced than us
2. Here to stay
3. Willing to do whatever they have to in order to survive.

The reasons...if they come it will be out of desperation, and be the end of a voyage of many many thousands of years (and probably many generations). They will only come in large numbers on a large ship/object because their home planet has been destroyed, or is in danger of it, essentially anyone who comes is on a one way trip both as individuals and probably as a species.

Exploration, etc. is not an option, because of time and distance. For example, for us there would be no possibility of significant exploration of earth like planets with a turn around of less than several hundred years, probably several thousand years.

Travelling faster than the speed of light is still not possible and there is no real idea of how to do that, nor any evidence it has ever been done or can be done. So to predict it will happen is a pure and total conjecture. There is no evidence of any black hole displacement or anything like that which could be used to exceed the speed of light. There is speculation about "information" moving at a greater speed, but my guess is that this is only conceptual and not real. So, stuck at the speed limit of say .7 of the speed of light any space exploration becomes irrelevant as far as any human concept of time is concerned.

Organisams that moved much slower than us though, say with a life span of a million years, might go looking around as the speed of light limitation would become less of an issue for them. But chances are that they would be so different than us that they would not be interested in an earth like planet. And there may be chemical/physics reasons why such life forms are highly improbable.
 
Forgot to mention, Aliens have already visited this planet leaving behind many indications of their visit. The Bible was probably their handiwork.
You must be a mormon.

If the aliens left us the bible they were one screwed up bunch. I don't think anyone who wrote a pile of stuff like that would be capable of piloting a space ship.
 
You think like they're adrift on a boat with limited supplies.

I think any reason they would come here in the first place would be specifically tied to their advancement or survival. I seriously doubt any aliens would show up just to say hi, how you doing, just thought we'd check this place out, going back home now.
 
I think any reason they would come here in the first place would be specifically tied to their advancement or survival. I seriously doubt any aliens would show up just to say hi, how you doing, just thought we'd check this place out, going back home now.

Well I think they'd be coming here for similar reasons why we're going to the moon, to mars, or sending messages out into space. For discovery and exploration. It has nothing to do with our survival. Whether or not they want to dissect us is another matter, but I'm not buying the whole hollywood they're out to get us story.
 
I'm shocked that all the brainiacs here missed the OP's goof. On at least two occasions he refers to a professor "Hawkings", when it is "Hawking". I cannot participate in a debate where something as simple as the name of the theorist is spelled incorrectly.

If I worried about misspelling on this board, my head would have exploded long ago just from reading pappy's posts alone.
 
Well I think they'd be coming here for similar reasons why we're going to the moon, to mars, or sending messages out into space. For discovery and exploration. It has nothing to do with our survival. Whether or not they want to dissect us is another matter, but I'm not buying the whole hollywood they're out to get us story.

Like I said earlier, it wouldn't have to be directly out of bad intent. Their needs would supersede ours, and since they would almost certainly be far more advanced, they would take what they wanted.