The Millionaire Next Door

slaconte1978

New member
Aug 26, 2007
141
0
0
All Government "workers" are millionaires and here is why, with a median yearly income of 78.3K their guaranteed INDEXED pension for life, given today's life expectancy, is worth around 1.7 Million.

While your mislay RRSP, if you are lucky to have one, will go down with the markets, their pension can only go up. Buy, hey, they deserve that after all the hard work they put in for the rest of us.

The best part, when you are old and going through garbage cans looking for your next meal, remember that you are the one that paid for their cushy retirement with your taxes.
 
Whoah, Slaconte.

But in our almost free market, capatilist system, the blame is only on you for not being smart enough or working hard enough to make yourself rich.
Don't blame anyone else when you're digging in the garbage.
 
The vast majority of government workers have a glass ceiling that they crash their heads into at one point. There will be a few that do better than most. Unless these government workers invest, they will never be extremely wealthy.
 
Not all government workers—a category that includes town and city, provincial and federal government—have indexed pensions. As with most pension plans, government workers paid a contribution to that plan on ever every paycheque, (no choice in the matter) and the amount they were allowed pay to an RRSP shrank by that much. And that specific $1.7 million you invented requires some assumptions—which you haven't put in your post—about how much that pension will be. Since, as in most pension plans, it's a reduced percentage of their salary when working, those concealed assumptions of yours are assuming some very high rates of pay when you say, "All Government "workers" are millionaires". Some surely do fall into that slot, as do some in almost every pension-paying industry or business of size. But the government also employs lots of cleaners and janitors, drivers, basic data entry keyboarders and other low-paid workers who will never see that sort of money.

Did you have a point? Because it just reads like jealousy and envy. Maybe you should be asking why you and your peers have failed to negociate such a reasonable sounding thing as a pension indexed to inflation.
 
While your mislay RRSP, if you are lucky to have one, will go down with the markets, their pension can only go up.

Last time I checked investments like RRSP's only go up in the long run. Sure there are "corrections" and dips in the market, but in the long run investments in the markets always go up. If that were to change, there'd be a lot more to worry about than if you've got enough to retire on or not.
 
The $1.7 million is for somebody on the cusp of retiring after working for 30 years or more and also a function of very low interest rates i.e. to generate the amount required when rates are so low is much higher.

I think there is a legitimate issue of equity however when comparable public service workers earn 30% more than their private sector counterparts and can retire at 55 with a fully indexed pension that is funded in part or whole by the taxpayers not worker contributions.
 
As far as I'm aware, government (fed/provincial/municipal) pension plans work the same as many private ones - the employer matches employee payments into the plan.

If the market drops, contribution rates go up to make up the difference.

Yes, the employer contributions come from taxes, just like the base salary or wages and benefit packages.
 
I think there is a legitimate issue of equity however when comparable public service workers earn 30% more than their private sector counterparts and can retire at 55 with a fully indexed pension that is funded in part or whole by the taxpayers not worker contributions.

You got it, some of the other replies are obviously by well-fed government parasites that wanna keep tax payers sleeping.

The Government is Canada's largest employer, no other successful country is in a similar situation (Greece for example, is). If it were not for our natural resources we'd be screwed. Having such a large body of public "workers" is not capitalism, it's socialism at its worst.

Private sector workers actually have to produce something, have 0 job security, no pension, and make 30% less than their often less talented public sector employees while working 100% harder.
 
I think there is a legitimate issue of equity however when comparable public service workers earn 30% more than their private sector counterparts and can retire at 55 with a fully indexed pension that is funded in part or whole by the taxpayers not worker contributions.

You sound like a socialist, which I'm sure you're not.

You too have the ability to certify your workplace, establish a union, and negotiate for better working conditions and terms of employment. If you choose not to, then that was your choice. You're left to your own bargaining power in determining what your terms of employment will be. If you're a superstar, you can do better than what unionized workers get. But if you're just joe average, you'll probably do significantly worse. But hey, if you despise unions then that comes at a price.

In Ontario, OPSEU has done well for its members over many years of negotiations with the Employer. Had the government treated its white collar workers better, OPSEU likely would never have formed. But the government took its workers for granted back in the 1960's and as a result they got fed up, formed an association, and then eventually formed a union. And the rest is history.
 
You got it, some of the other replies are obviously by well-fed government parasites that wanna keep tax payers sleeping.

The Government is Canada's largest employer, no other successful country is in a similar situation (Greece for example, is). If it were not for our natural resources we'd be screwed. Having such a large body of public "workers" is not capitalism, it's socialism at its worst.

Private sector workers actually have to produce something, have 0 job security, no pension, and make 30% less than their often less talented public sector employees while working 100% harder.

Yawn, the so-called government workers as millionaire next door and what private sector could do to replicate has already been covered by the following, except we have here like flubadub mentioned somebody has "sour grapes" or more appropriately a diatribe...:rolleyes:

http://www.moneysense.ca/2010/04/09/make-your-own-pension/

Simply put, if you want to get the same pension, do yourself a favor and try to apply for a job in any three levels of governments. Or try to replicate identical pension yourself but I guess people find it convenient to blame everything squarely on others, instead of being responsible/self-reliant on their own, especially when we have TFSA available to more or less level the "playing field".

WRT government jobs paid significantly higher than their counterparts in the private sectors, keep in mind though many government workers do not have much, if any RRSP contributions room remaining since the majority of the increased amount will be automatically diverted to the pension and obviously the government as employer does the matching. It's truly a forced automatic savings for retirement.

Just in case why you question government used tax payers money to match the pension, doubtful people realize or want to know the truth but the relatively generous government matching acts as deterrent to prevent the government workers get underpaid to the point that they would be very receptive to get kickbacks/rebates/bribery/corruptions/powers for rent from the private sectors in order to supplement their take home pay.

Obviously that would not stop all corruption but the measure does make those government workers who do commit corruption and caught red-handed get severe sanctions to the extent of the law.

Having said that, that doesn't mean the unions in the governments and the public corporations like TTC wouldn't go way over the top and totally distort the rationale behind higher compensation.

And nope I am not a government worker.
 
Last edited:
A government pension ends when you die (or your SO if there is a survivor benefit).

The money in an RRSP and investments can be passed on to your children through estate planning.

That is a major difference between the number crunching in comparing these two types of plans and why a one to one dollar comparison is flawed.
 
A government pension ends when you die (or your SO if there is a survivor benefit).

Yep, you and your spouse lose when your employer/government bet you two have short life expectancy.

Simply put, the government pension is essentially an indexed annuity funded partially and supported by the taxpayer and the sovereign debt ratings respectively.

No matter since many people consider government workers should be called public servants and they should live up to and being compensated as "servants". ;)
 
A government pension ends when you die (or your SO if there is a survivor benefit).

The money in an RRSP and investments can be passed on to your children through estate planning.

That is a major difference between the number crunching in comparing these two types of plans and why a one to one dollar comparison is flawed.

Any defined benefit pension is collapsed on death even if the beneficiary dies the day after he or she retires.

I think the most telling comparison is the monthly pension that can be generated by a lifetime annuity from an RRSP at a comparable age based on the same amount of dollars contributed as a defined benefit pension.
 
I think the most telling comparison is the monthly pension that can be generated by a lifetime annuity from an RRSP at a comparable age based on the same amount of dollars contributed as a defined benefit pension.

I agree with that, so if there is an actuary in the audience let the calculating begin.
But that is my point, it is not a simple comparison of I have $1,000,000 in my RRSP and the guy next door has $1,000,000 of pension benefits.
In that example I would be far better off than my neighbour.

Annuities are a separate legal creature that also trigger other benefits and risks that need to be considered.
For example, funds in an annuity cannot be seized if you declare bankruptcy or be taken by court order in a lawsuit (some rare exotic exceptions).
On the other hand the annuity company can go bankrupt.
 
Ha ha ha...pay the postie $100K so he doesn't steal your mail.....ha ha ha.

LOL, I would find it "funny" when you try to convince us paying the firefighter $30K or less and don't worry about him or her demanding tiered "water fees" before they start to extinguish fire. :rolleyes:
 
it is not a simple comparison of I have $1,000,000 in my RRSP and the guy next door has $1,000,000 of pension benefits.
In that example I would be far better off than my neighbour.

You would be screwed dearly by the government once you convert $1 million RRSP to RRIF at age 71 since there is a min (roughly 7% of the balance if I could recall) required to be taken out annually and that will be taxed based on your marginal tax rate.

That means you will get tax hit big time once you take the minimum out of $1 million tax deferred account like RRIF and I am not starting to address clawback on OAS. If you have a financial adviser/CFP on his or her watch when this happen, he or she will be truly at best unethical, at worst a "rumbag".

It is very likely he or she is strongly advise you to buy annuities, variable or indexed or fixed instead of converting to RRIF. That way he or she is going to receive a handsome commission one last time after collecting trailer fees on the high MER products he or she sold to you for the past decades.

Having $1 million balance in TFSA OTOH is a BIG booyah!! That beats banging hot SPs/MPAs if possible outside MP/civilian counterparts since the amount in TFSA is tax free every time you withdraw. :)

Too bad the politicians would sooner or later try to get their cut from TFSA, maybe right after the big banks take "theirs" by "withdrawal fees".

And yes, fees is a 4 letter word, just like Bush....

On the other hand the annuity company can go bankrupt.

Can I say AIG?
 
All Government "workers" are millionaires and here is why, with a median yearly income of 78.3K their guaranteed INDEXED pension for life, given today's life expectancy, is worth around 1.7 Million.

While your mislay RRSP, if you are lucky to have one, will go down with the markets, their pension can only go up. Buy, hey, they deserve that after all the hard work they put in for the rest of us.

The best part, when you are old and going through garbage cans looking for your next meal, remember that you are the one that paid for their cushy retirement with your taxes.

You are completely off track!

If one worked 2080 hours for 13.00 over 40 years $1081600 earned. $13.00per hour will make you a millionaire in terms of gross income.
Jobs in that 13.00 range can be labour to sales.

I have a neighbour that works in concrete as a labourer, high school education. 2080 hours for 27.00 over 40 years $2246400 million that's with 3 months off in the Winter where he goes in E.I. and collects. I kept the 2080 hours as he works overtime due to overtime and seasonal. But, he still gets from E.I.

Now, what about the Autoworkers and Steelworkers 2080 hours for 35.00 over 40 years $2912000 million

FFS, I know a bartender who clears 1500 per week that's right per week! (78000.00) annually.

I'm going to say that Police Officers, Firefighters, Corrections Offficers, Paramedics, Nurses, 911 dispatchers earn their keep. In fact, C.Os and Paramedics are the worst paid. Transit operators have to put up with alot of garbage, maybe not from you, but there are many who create problems. Now, you can and will probably rebut with "Well they chose it." "Well, you chose to be stock shelves too."

I'm tired of hearing all the poor me, my plight is all because of the government employees wages. There are bad seeds in all professions and jobs.
 
I'm going to say that Police Officers, Firefighters, Corrections Offficers, Paramedics, Nurses, 911 dispatchers earn their keep. In fact, C.Os and Paramedics are the worst paid.

+1, government workers belong to disciplinary services mentioned above are well deserve their keeps and Defined Benefit Plans.

Others though, not so much, probably Defined Contribution Plans for recently hired, while grandfather the old ones or "buy out" to get the old ones retired, just like the automobile workers.

But hey it's not going to happen since all unions within the governments will fight to death and use everything possible, including taking the public hostages before they give up. To them, the way they want to keep the perks is similar to the Palestinians demand for their homeland-all or nothing.

Transit operators have to put up with alot of garbage, maybe not from you, but there are many who create problems.

Not going to have sympathy to those operators since they are mainly responsible for the public anger towards the system. I do give the credit though they share the same blame with the politicians.

WRT "garbage", literally and physically, the transit system could set up by-laws and levy heavy fines, say starting $500 fines for each littering, spitting and eating in the transit system, locking funds of the accused bank account if necessary before paying the fines, $3000 or whatever the number and criminally charge to assault the operators, while giving the TTC constables for example firearms training and police power along the line.

Better yet, the transit system should consider a "reward" system. In addition to CCTV, the transit should encourage passengers to use IPhone/smartphone to catch people violating the by-laws and "hand in" the recorded clip to the nearest station as evidence. Once those perpetrators got identified and caught by the transit, the passenger would receive a reward tied to the % of the fine.

If it's sound too complicated, one could always try to shame those perpetrators by uploading to the youtube of the world. :rolleyes:

BTW, such "draconian" policies are probably not going to happen here since the unions have the politicians in the pocket. The unions don't want additional works, while the politicians will strike down these suggestions as "human rights" violations.
 
Last edited: