Sorry to disagree with you fine gentlemen.
Before signing that ridiculous, 7-year, $126 million contract in 2006 Vernon Wells had exactly TWO seasons where he was even 30% better than the average hitter. 2003 (OPS+ of 132) and 2006 (OPS+ of 129.) Other than that, V-Dub was an average hitter - look it up. Yes, he was a Gold Glove centre fielder, but his defensive metrics were already on the decline in 2006 as he bulked up.
For a team like the Jays, they could simply not afford to sign one player to 20%+ of their payroll (based on his average annual salary - by the end of the albatross of a deal, it may very well work out to almost one-third of the Jays' payroll) with a career OBP of .329 and OPS under .800. He IS a star, a nice guy and an above-average all-around player at a premium position. He is NOT a superstar, a true team leader and someone worthy of one of the 10-15 largest contracts ever given. Not even on potential of his two best seasons, which were inflated and somewhat overrated. The two first round draft picks would have been a better tradeoff if the team couldn't get a decent return via trade.
Unlike some of the vitriolic posters and "fans" I don't blame Vernon Wells or his agent - he is what he is as a player. And who among us would turn down that kind of scratch? I blame JP Ricciardi, Paul Godfrey and the Jays management at the time for making a poor business decision that will cripple this organization until 2015.
$126 million for a player like Vernon Wells on a team like the Yankees, Mets, or Red Sox? Maybe. For a team like the Toronto Blue Jays? Not in a million years.
Excellent article/statistical piece that breaks down Vernon Wells' projected value over the course of his contract: http://www.hardballtimes.com/main/article/will-vernon-wells-be-worth-the-price/
With regards to VW's contract, I think it's worth mentioning that he was entering the prime years [i.e. 28-32] when many players really hit their stride so the expectation that he would continue to produce is not as crazy as 20/20 hindsight makes it appear.
As well, it's possible that his signing was needed to keep Toronto's credibility as a competitive franchise. There was concern that if he got away it would be tough for the Jays to be taken seriously and be able to attract free agents. I think this kind of thinking was also seen in the huge contracts given to Carlos Delgado and Vince Carter when they were on the verge of leaving.
D.
Last edited:

