Government to be held in contempt it fails to comply with Parliamentary order

Yawn
 
double yawn. The calls by the opposition for contempt findings of parliament probably come a few times a week.

Rather than calling for a contempt finding, the LIberals should just put forth a no confidence vote if they were so outraged, which they wont do of course...
 
Parliament has several methods by which to bring a dictatorial Prime Minister to heel. A non confidence vote is one. Holding the government in contempt of Parliament is another. It's up to Parliament to decide which method is most appropriate in a given circumstance, all options are available.
 
Parliament has several methods by which to bring a dictatorial Prime Minister to heel. A non confidence vote is one. Holding the government in contempt of Parliament is another. It's up to Parliament to decide which method is most appropriate in a given circumstance, all options are available.

Dictatorial? Harper? Get real fuji. Dictatorial = Chavez. Harper has a minority gov't, how can you possibly call him dictatorial? Go live in a socialist country for a while then you'll know what dictatorial really means.
 
Dictatorial? Harper? Get real fuji. Dictatorial = Chavez. Harper has a minority gov't, how can you possibly call him dictatorial? Go live in a socialist country for a while then you'll know what dictatorial really means.

A Prime Minister who holds himself to be a higher authority than Parliament is indeed a dictatorial Prime Minister, and must be brought to heel.
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?

Harper (nor anyone he appoints) doesn't have the legal authority to block the release, that's why. By appointing an ex judge to the task via his executive authority Harper is maintaining that his executive authority, or any decision flowing from it, has greater authority than an order of Parliament.

It does not. Orders of Parliament must be followed. There is no ambiguity here.
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?

Iacobucci is a very well respected former jurist, who has as much authority as you or I to determine which documents should or should not be released: none. This is a diversionary tactic and nothing more.
 
The judge is not deciding on Parliament's authority; that is essentially absolute, because only they represent the country. Nor is he deciding what may be released. What he's deciding on is whether the government is going too far—or not far enough—in redacting (blacking-out) the ordered documents, to comply with the security laws. This may, or may not satisfy the Committee, only they can say. Parliament, and only Parliament may revise the order to accommodate this process or not, as it sees fit. Only a dictator could forbid, prevent or defy Parliament. In olden times it got you beheaded.

Since Harper steadfastly refused any such reasonable compromise before proroguing, this counts as the only re-calibration he actually managed to achieve between hockey games. Perhaps it was worth the wait. We'll see whether it's 'plays well with others' now, or the same old conniving and bullying that's kept him the choice of only one in three for so long. We can always hope.
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.

And our democracy is diminished because no one else "really gives a damn". It is a sad comment on our country, regardless of what you think of the underlying issue.
 
If anyone tried to hold Harper accountable he would run away to mommy governor general and close parliament again. he'd close it for a whole year rather then be held accountable for his actions he's a whiny little punk. But 30% of this country wants a whiny little punk leader so he wont be held accountable.
 
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?

I would agree but: who will set the terms of reference for his review; how much time will he be given and; will he be given the resources required to carry out his review? If the answer is "the government" then I think the outcome is predetermined, if the answer is "parliament" then we'll see.
 
This was what I pointed out months ago, also in Canada there are a number of Judges that have recieved the nessisary security clearance to review the documents. The other part of the equation is the need to know. Both the clearance and the need to know ( as defined) are required to see classified documents. The retired Justice apparantly has the clearance and has now been given the need to know in that he has been tasked to review the documents and report back as to which documents if any can be released to public access, in parliment. The screaming and frothing at the mouth from the opposition are entirly for the benefit of the media , to remain in the spotlight.
 
Again you and the Ottawa press corps are the only ones who really give a damn.
The issue has been passed to a retired SCC justice to determine what disposition is to be made of the documents. The man is well respected by everybody in the country. Why not let him determine what documents are to be released?

Why are you so eager to believe the average Canadian doesn't care about the proper functioning of our parliament? About 2/3 of Canadian voters didn't vote for Harper so it's not like his 'popularity' gives him any extra leeway. When he prorogued parliament, Harper took quite a tumble in the polls and that's a clear indication that people DO care. Lots of people don't understand the finer points of our parliamentary system but they know it's the place where our democracy plays out and it's the only form of government we've got. So when people see news stories and articles talking about Harper's prorogation of parliament, his wasteful abandonment of those bills awaiting passage and now his contempt for parliament's authority, they see that as an assault on our democratic system. Technicalities aside, people want their PM to be anwerable to their elected parliament. People see a minority PM thumbing his nose at a majority of elected representatives in the house and they know intuitively that something is wrong. You'd like for them to not care but they do.
 
Given a choice between a bunch of rabid mp's and a retired judge to look at matters which may or may not impact national security I think I'd pick the judge. Guys like Layton don't give a damn about some Afgan detainees they just want to score some political points. And as far as the Liberals are concerned I agree with Kingfisher they would do exactly as Harper is doing, stall, use national security as an excuse etc etc. No one in power wants complete disclosure about what happens in a theatre of war. No one.

One has to question the naivete of terbites here. Actually I don't think that you really are I think that you just get so worked up about certain issues that you lose perspective and balance. Obama Healthcare, Bush and Harper seem to be the biggies that cause you guys to flip. This is another one of those topics although mainly because its Harper the pack is chasing.
 
While I agree with you on what the PM is doing on the whole and I firmly believe in the end it will hurt Mr. Harper --- this particular issue is one that he actually has the law on his side. The opposition is right to make a fuss here simply because it does illustrate the overall point you are making. Even if the Liberals won the next election the same information would be redacted in the same manner.

Like I said this is simply good Parlimentry politics by the opposition and in fact it is exactly what they should be doing --- however it doesn't mean as Fuji seems to think that the Government is compelled to release this information.


kf

I'm not very familiar with the legal side of this issue but we did have one instance during the last round of detainee hearings where they ended up with two versions of the same document. One was heavily redacted but later they obtained an unredacted copy. Sure enough, the redacted passages had nothing to do with national security and everything to do with political damage control. I never understood why this didn't make headlines because the gov't was caught red- handed using national security as a cover for political censorship. I have no doubt that the Liberals would redact the national security content if they were releasing similar documents but it is harder to predict whether or not they'd lie to the whole country by redacting content that had no bearing on security.

http://www.globalnational.com/world...cuments+prove+need+inquiry/2295346/story.html
...."What we've seen from this government is a whole lot of redaction, in other words blacked out documents," charged Paul Dewar, NDP foreign affairs critic. "It's like reading tea leaves."

Dewar produced his own document, obtained through an access to information request, showing that the government had blacked out a reference to torture in a 2006 report from its own Foreign Affairs bureaucrats on the state of human rights in Afghanistan.

The original, unedited, document, which was leaked to the media in 2007, concluded that "extrajudicial executions, disappearances, torture and detention without trial are all too common."

"This is precisely why Canadians can't trust any documents with redactions from this government," said Dewar.".....


But all the above is irrelevant to public opinion. Harper has been stalling and boycotting the detainee hearings to the point where only his core supporters believe anything he says on the subject. If he ends up in a standoff with the opposition majority over access to the documents, most voters will believe that Harper is just stonewalling again and that will continue to hurt him politically.
 
A summary of the Security of Information Act is as follows:

It does not apply to Parliament itself. Parliament itself is supreme. If you were paying attention you would know that's the point. Specifically Parliament can order one of two things to over-ride that act:

One, Parliament can order that the Minister reclassify the information. The Minister has the power to do that, and must obey the order of Parliament to do so. At that point the information is no longer classified and can be released.

Two, Parliament can simply order that the Minister release the classified information notwithstanding any prior act of Parliament (e.g., that Act), asserting that Parliament itself is supreme and is not bound by the act.

The point, dear boy, is that Parliament is supreme, the government has no choice but to comply with an order of Parliament. It is not possible, by definition, for an order of Parliament to violate the law, unless it violates the *constitution*. The securities act is a mere act of Parliament and has not got constitutional force.

As someone said up thread, when it comes down to a question of which prevails, the constitution (e.g., Parliament's supremacy) or the law, the constitution wins.
 
Both the clearance and the need to know ( as defined) are required to see classified documents.

By civilians or other people in the government that is true. But not Parliament. Parliamentary privilege overrides the securities act. You are missing the point about the supremacy of Parliament.
 
Given a choice between a bunch of rabid mp's and a retired judge to look at matters which may or may not impact national security I think I'd pick the judge.

Sure, it sounds like a sensible thing to do. However it is not your choice to make nor is it the Prime Minister's choice to make. It is up to Parliament to decide whether that is how it will be done. The only way that process has legitimacy is if *Parliament* endorses it. Parliament could decide to dispense with that process and order the information outright released. That is a decision that your elected representatives in Parliament are entitled to make. Alternately Parliament could decide to set up a commission to review the documents, and, under the authority of Parliament, decide what to release. It is up to your elected representatives to decide which way is better.

You do have a say, though: If Parliament goes around making orders (or laws, or speeches, or anything else) that you think are inappropriate you have the option of voting for different representatives in the next Federal eleciton, people you think would make better decisions. Parliament is ultimately held accountable to the people--at the ballot box.