While I agree with you on what the PM is doing on the whole and I firmly believe in the end it will hurt Mr. Harper --- this particular issue is one that he actually has the law on his side. The opposition is right to make a fuss here simply because it does illustrate the overall point you are making. Even if the Liberals won the next election the same information would be redacted in the same manner.
Like I said this is simply good Parlimentry politics by the opposition and in fact it is exactly what they should be doing --- however it doesn't mean as Fuji seems to think that the Government is compelled to release this information.
kf
I'm not very familiar with the legal side of this issue but we did have one instance during the last round of detainee hearings where they ended up with two versions of the same document. One was heavily redacted but later they obtained an unredacted copy. Sure enough, the redacted passages had nothing to do with national security and everything to do with political damage control. I never understood why this didn't make headlines because the gov't was caught red- handed using national security as a cover for political censorship. I have no doubt that the Liberals would redact the national security content if they were releasing similar documents but it is harder to predict whether or not they'd lie to the whole country by redacting content that had no bearing on security.
http://www.globalnational.com/world...cuments+prove+need+inquiry/2295346/story.html
...."What we've seen from this government is a whole lot of redaction, in other words blacked out documents," charged Paul Dewar, NDP foreign affairs critic. "It's like reading tea leaves."
Dewar produced his own document, obtained through an access to information request, showing that the government had blacked out a reference to torture in a 2006 report from its own Foreign Affairs bureaucrats on the state of human rights in Afghanistan.
The original, unedited, document, which was leaked to the media in 2007, concluded that "extrajudicial executions, disappearances, torture and detention without trial are all too common."
"This is precisely why Canadians can't trust any documents with redactions from this government," said Dewar.".....
But all the above is irrelevant to public opinion. Harper has been stalling and boycotting the detainee hearings to the point where only his core supporters believe anything he says on the subject. If he ends up in a standoff with the opposition majority over access to the documents, most voters will believe that Harper is just stonewalling again and that will continue to hurt him politically.