Why shouldn't Curling be Unisex?

  • Thread starter Thread starter burt-oh-my!
  • Start date Start date
B

burt-oh-my!

After all, I see no advantage men have over women in this event, so why not make it unisex? I don't see strength etc coming into play.

For that matter - is the equestrian events seperated into men/women? Same thing should apply there.
 
So do you want a 3rd (co-ed) team in the Olympics or to do away with the men's and women's teams and just have one?

What I would like to see is the Para-lympics absorbed into the Olympics.
 
After all, I see no advantage men have over women in this event, so why not make it unisex? I don't see strength etc coming into play.

I asked this question already.
1) Those rocks are heavy so strength is important, or not.
2) The greater strength of men gives them an advantage in sweeping the ice.
 
I think it's easier for the Olympics to justify separate events for men and women if all events are split that way. Once you start having some events mix, it'll be a slippery slope and you'll start getting lawsuits from women who want to compete in mens' events.
 
Men may have greater strenght at sweeping but women have more practice...just saying.
 
As long as it doesn't replace women's curling that's fine. What other sports allow you to ogle the women for such a long time?
 
Same reason they don't let old fat guys compete on the national team. They don't want to shatter the myth that curling is a sport.
 
After all, I see no advantage men have over women in this event, so why not make it unisex? I don't see strength etc coming into play.

For that matter - is the equestrian events seperated into men/women? Same thing should apply there.

There are mixed team events just not at the olympics. The only advantage that men have over women is in the sweeping they can apply more broom and affect the shot to a greater degree and therefore give a larger margin for error on any given shot. Other than than that, no difference.
 
Same reason they don't let old fat guys compete on the national team. They don't want to shatter the myth that curling is a sport.

You're obviously too young to remember Hector Gervais in the past. His technique sucked big time but he was a world class curler.
 
Does sweeping even make a cunt hair of a difference?
Make it a single person sport just like darts, shuffleboard or crokinole. And yes, make it unisex - strength isn't a factor.
 
Does sweeping even make a cunt hair of a difference?
Make it a single person sport just like darts, shuffleboard or crokinole. And yes, make it unisex - strength isn't a factor.

Sorry VR, sweeping can make as much as 4 to 5 feet difference on the curl of the shot and as much as 7 to 8 feet in the length of the shot, especially on club ice as opposed to arena ice. It's a team sport. I'll repeat, it a team sport each position has its part to play.
 
I asked this question already.
1) Those rocks are heavy so strength is important, or not.
2) The greater strength of men gives them an advantage in sweeping the ice.

The weight of the rocks is not really a factor or you wouldn't 70 and 80 years old men and women curling.
 
Sorry VR, sweeping can make as much as 4 to 5 feet difference on the curl of the shot and as much as 7 to 8 feet in the length of the shot, especially on club ice as opposed to arena ice. It's a team sport. I'll repeat, it a team sport each position has its part to play.

Men can also throw with more weight behind the stone.

Jennifer Jones was a guest on McCowan's show a couple of months back and he asked her the same question - Her response was the men have much more strength in throwing the take out weight and being able to sweep more effectively. She did mention that some of the younger female teams are in better physical condition, but you need to be in great shape to curl at the world level.
 
Men can also throw with more weight behind the stone.

Jennifer Jones was a guest on McCowan's show a couple of months back and he asked her the same question - Her response was the men have much more strength in throwing the take out weight and being able to sweep more effectively. She did mention that some of the younger female teams are in better physical condition, but you need to be in great shape to curl at the world level.

With the recent change in the rules you don't see as much of the heavy weight takeout shots as in the day of The Richardson brothers and Don Dugood. The heavy takeout was a staple of the prairie provinces representatives. Just think of the number of heavy shots you saw this Olympics that removed more than two stones or 'prang' one off the backboard. There was a time when some shots had the sweepers running/sliding down the sheet trying to keep up with the stone
 
Ok, why don't we have a friendly exhibition match between our women and our men's teams. Loser buys the beer.