women's hockey....

tboy

resident smartass
Aug 18, 2001
15,966
2
0
65
way out in left field
Ok, so I'm watching Canada kick slovakia's ass and with a score of 16-0, wtf is their coach thinking?

The IOC is already considering cancelling Women's Hockey due to Canada's dominance so are they TRYING to run up the score?

I'm embarassed.

The coach should a) tell them to back off a bit, don't insult the other team, but hold up. and b) that when entering into the other team's end, they must past the puck at LEAST 5 times before taking a shot.

Now I know it is hard to rein in a thoroughbred, but when I used to shoot pool with this guy that was easily 10x better than me, we'd make it that he had to bank a ball in, can't shoot it straight in. That made HIM a better player for having to take harder shots, and made me a better player by having to consider that when directing the cue ball.

Running up the score to 20 is NOT going to benefit anyone.....
 
Running up the score to 20 is NOT going to benefit anyone.....

Eighteen (and counting) okay for you?

Funny I was just thinking the same thing about the point and/or future of women's hockey at the olympics. If it suppossed to be about competition, what is the point, if besides two teams, the others are merely there as 'sparring partners'? Yes, I reme,ber what happened last time...
 
Until goal differential is not used as a tie-breaker, it is necessary to run up the score. You never know if you'll need those goals later.

But I agree, 16, 18, 20, etc. is a tad outrageous.
 
Yes, but does anybody remember how bad the Russian men were in hockey in 1942? Got to give the other countries time to improve. Besides, if they drop women's hockey, the women will sue (see you in court).
 
1. Point differential can stop at plus 10 to avoid the requirement of running up the score.

2. The five pass rule is a great suggestion. However, it is really just another means of rubbing it in. I've coached basketball for over 20 years, and always had my teams use the 5 pass rule when appropriate; however, at a coaching clinic, this was raised. Shoot as quickly as possible and give the other team the chance to play offence; this also employs the dominant team to work on defence. Players could also move into other positions, I've employed this and seen it done in several sports. I don't believe that would be a good idea at the olympic level.

3. What about having two divisions for women's hockey? 4-6 top teams in pool A, and the next 4-6 teams in pool B. Yes, two sets of gold medals, etc. It is more about competition for some. Until the other countries put the effort and money into women's hockey, it will be lopsided.

JMO
 
good idea about the two divisions a and b. I played quite a few mixed baseball tourneys and everyone played in the first round against everyone. All the teams who lost in the first round, went to b, the winners to a. It was based on standings like the playoffs, top seeded teams played the bottom teams.

It always made for some great competition and once in a while (like what happened to my team on more than one occasion) we beat out a top seeded team and made it to the semi final in A. That makes for great upsets because even a top seeded team can have a brain fart (like sweden did in Tourin).
 
Until goal differential is not used as a tie-breaker, it is necessary to run up the score. You never know if you'll need those goals later.

But I agree, 16, 18, 20, etc. is a tad outrageous.

Goal differential only matters for getting to the medal round. It's a given that Canada will make it to the medal round in this tournament. Thus running up the score isn't important.
 
I disagree with most of whats been said here. You get some lopsided scores in other Olympic sports as well.

There are only 2 teams that can win women's hockey. Canada and USA. Laying down or easing up may, in the coach's mind, lead to bad habits. We need to be on our best come the finals.

If you don't want to be embarassed get better, or stay home.
 
You forgot Sweden who beat the US in the last Olympics. But I agree that Canada needed a strong showing in the beginning as they'be been losing to the States in the last few world championships and need to build up their confidence and work out all the kinks before the Gold Medal show down.
 
Yes, but does anybody remember how bad the Russian men were in hockey in 1942? Got to give the other countries time to improve. Besides, if they drop women's hockey, the women will sue (see you in court).

Sure the Russian men were bad in hockey in 1942. They were busy fighting Nazi Germany. :D
 
I disagree with most of whats been said here. You get some lopsided scores in other Olympic sports as well.

There are only 2 teams that can win women's hockey. Canada and USA. Laying down or easing up may, in the coach's mind, lead to bad habits. We need to be on our best come the finals.

If you don't want to be embarassed get better, or stay home.

Care to post any of those other lopsided scores? I'm not talking 6-1, 16 or 17 - 1.....

Easing up: Formula 1, if the leader is 2 laps ahead, he's not going to push it to the limit and risk wrecking a million dollar car. He's going to go smooth and steady and win with an intact car.

Well, if this keeps up, even Canada and the US WILL stay home....with everyone else. This could be the last time you see women's hockey in the Olympics and running up the score is a prime example of that.

After watching the complete game, really, the slovaks looked like a rookie team compared to Canada. They were totally outskated.

One thing I found funny about team Canada? The girls were wearing eye makeup lol.....I bet if they went to a mascara company they could start a campaign around "stands up to even the harshest conditions, if it doesn't run during a hockey game, it isn't going to run during red hot monkey sex" lol.....
 
They did the same thing in 2006. They ran up the score against some country. And the coach and team scoffed at the criticism, saying they only know one way to play and they are not going to pass up scoring chances staring them in the face. It is bad sportsmanship IMHO
 
They did the same thing in 2006. They ran up the score against some country.

Maybe. they should have a "mercy" rule like they do in boxing. The referee can stop the game when one team is getting killed.
 
Care to post any of those other lopsided scores? I'm not talking 6-1, 16 or 17 - 1.....

Does Olympic qualifying count?
Same team-other side of the score!

Slovakia made the field via a qualification tournament in September 2008, where it got to know the other side of blowouts. They smashed Bulgaria 82-0, notching 139 shots while allowing none.
 
Being a referee in competitive hockey...its a hard one to call! I dont think IIHF is going to ever use the 5 goal spread run time rule. So, I guess we dont have a choice but to let them play. However, when I get into games that get a little lopsided..(eg 8-0, etc). If I see any player on the winning team even remotely do anything to start shit...aka...minor celebrations after a goal, or a coach yelling at the players to "pour it on". They get misconduct penalties for "inciting". This usually keeps them in line.
 
Slovakia's team was not much for our Canadian gals.
I can just imagine what the Slovakian coach said to his team when they received word:
"Ok girls, I have good news and bad news for you;
The good news: You qualified for the Olympics!!!
The bad news: You play Team Canada your first game"
 
Does Olympic qualifying count?
Same team-other side of the score!

Slovakia made the field via a qualification tournament in September 2008, where it got to know the other side of blowouts. They smashed Bulgaria 82-0, notching 139 shots while allowing none.

I read that today....Now I don't feel so bad for the slovaks.......
 
Being a referee in competitive hockey...its a hard one to call! I dont think IIHF is going to ever use the 5 goal spread run time rule. So, I guess we dont have a choice but to let them play. However, when I get into games that get a little lopsided..(eg 8-0, etc). If I see any player on the winning team even remotely do anything to start shit...aka...minor celebrations after a goal, or a coach yelling at the players to "pour it on". They get misconduct penalties for "inciting". This usually keeps them in line.

I noticed that last night. Canada got a hooking penalty and the Canadian player's stick never left the ice (but she did knock the slovak down)......

I know this wouldn't fly but, how about a permanant 5 on 4 or 3?

Team Canada would certainly get a workout lol......
 
* Putting Women's hockey into to the Olympics before there was a legitimate pool of at least 5 or 6 contenders was a huge mistake and it
wouldn't bother me if they gave it a 4 or 8 year time out.

* In theory, goal differential can be important. But in this tournament? Yeah right, as if the Canadian women are going to go .500 in the round robin and miss the medal round on goal differential ...

Even the men's draw is configured in a way that virtually goarantees the top 6 teams a berth in the Quarterfinalsm - goal deifferential might determine placement - but by the time you;re in the Semis, it really doesn't matter who you draw anymore -either way you're gonna have to beat a couple of teams who hve at least a 50/50 chance of beating you.

The damage of running up the score is most evident in Baseball - I'd say 8 times out of 10 when a team scores 14 or more runs AND the game is blowout, that same team has a hard time scoring in the next couple of games.

I think it's dangerous for players both individually and collectively to loose respect for the basic difficulty of scoring. Or the even the difficulty of creating textbook scoring chances at will. Put together 2 or 3 such games without real challenege and I think it can take the edge off a team just as much as "holding back" would.

I think the Canadian men's Junior team this year suffered a little form this effect. The total lack of challenge from opponents made imperfections their game too easy to live with and there was general "party time" feel to the games.
 
I am all for equal opportunity.
but i watched part of the USA/CHINA womens hockey today. and if you were to watch it you cant tell that this should be an olympic sport. the godamn sport is so new, its like watching toddlers play, they can barely fucking skate.
these are supposed to be elite athletes. there is absolutely NO competition, canada will obviously win. its atrocious.
im not saying it should never be an olympic sport, but not now, its in its infancy.