New Banking Regulations

The problem is that Obama believes in capitalism for all not just the poor and middle class. He has said that he will not all ow banks to be come so big and to get into businesses that are so far afield from banking that they could once gain hold the American people and the world for that matter for hostage. I know that is a crazy notion to some, making banks, which depend on government guarantees etc, have to actually make money from banking and not from proprietary trading etc. Crazy.

Clearly you don't understand his proposal (which would have no affect on the size of BofA, Citi, JPMC, Wells or the other large US banks) or the banking industry.... other than that you're the perfect person to comment.

As you'll see, the big guys (well, except for the car companies) have paid back their TARP money: http://bailout.propublica.org/main/list/refunds while those small banks Obama is supporting have not....

In addition to getting it's money back from the large FSI firms the US government has also made money (16 Billion in dividends and profits from warrants): http://bailout.propublica.org/main/list/dividends

Apparently, bailing out banks is one of the few things the US government can do efficiently and at little cost....

OTB
 
Clearly you don't understand his proposal (which would have no affect on the size of BofA, Citi, JPMC, Wells or the other large US banks) or the banking industry.... other than that you're the perfect person to comment.

As you'll see, the big guys (well, except for the car companies) have paid back their TARP money: http://bailout.propublica.org/main/list/refunds while those small banks Obama is supporting have not....

In addition to getting it's money back from the large FSI firms the US government has also made money (16 Billion in dividends and profits from warrants): http://bailout.propublica.org/main/list/dividends

Apparently, bailing out banks is one of the few things the US government can do efficiently and at little cost....

OTB

Your missing the point. each of the institutions you mentioned received TARP money, without which they would be broke and would have brought down the world credit markets. Whats the difference if they paid back the TARP money. they wouldn't exist without that bailout. where is the bailout for main-street. the car companies received money but the unions and all workers made huge concessions.. What concessions did the bankers make.
 
Your missing the point. each of the institutions you mentioned received TARP money, without which they would be broke and would have brought down the world credit markets. Whats the difference if they paid back the TARP money. they wouldn't exist without that bailout. where is the bailout for main-street. the car companies received money but the unions and all workers made huge concessions.. What concessions did the bankers make.

No, your missing the point.

The TARP program saved the financial system AND made money in the process. The fundamentals of the banking system were sound, they have sound business models.... unlike the car companies. What they needed was a bridge to get them through the panic phase. The Unions have unsustainable work rules and compensation packages and they are slowly (or not so slowly any longer) bleeding their host to death.

Set aside your university freshman class struggle view for a second and look at the facts.

OTB
 
Banking industry lobbyists are preparing to do battle, buoyed by a landmark US Supreme Court ruling striking down limits on corporations’ political spending, against the ambitious and agressive plans laid on Thursday by President Obama.

http://business.timesonline.co.uk/t...ectors/banking_and_finance/article6999197.ece

Despite the pointed attacks made by the President on the “army of industry lobbyists from Wall Street”, the Financial Services Roundtable, a body which represents 100 of the largest financial firms, said that Mr Obama’s proposal would do little to protect consumers.

“The proposal will restrict lending, increase risk, decrease stability in the system, and limit our ability to help create jobs,” said Steve Bartlett, chief executive of the roundtable.

Individual bankers by and large kept quiet, preferring to weigh up the best response in private. As they did so, Mr Obama flew to the struggling rust-belt state of Ohio in hope that the attack would re-energise his popularity in middle America.

In Washington the attack on bankers was seen as a “policy pivot” designed to accommodate voters’ populist rage after the Democrats’ loss of Edward Kennedy’s Senate seat in Massachusetts. “I’ll never stop fighting for you. I’ll take my lumps, too,” Mr Obama told an audience in Elyria, at the start of a day of campaign-style events aimed at reinvigorating the Democrats before the November mid-term elections.

The President has become increasingly strident about what he calls the “fat cats” in the big banks as the American public has reacted with revulsion to big bonuses being handed out in Wall Street. Mr Obama’s political capital is dwindling, however, after the Democrats’ loss on Tuesday of the 60-seat “super-majority” that enables them to overcome a Republican filibuster in the Senate.

Yesterday, the Senate was forced to postpone the confirmation of Ben Bernanke for a new term as Federal Reserve chairman after two more Democratic senators said that they would join a revolt against him.

The proposed banking restrictions are just the latest round of populist measures aimed at the financial sector in recent months, such as levying a tax on banks to recoup the cost of government bail-outs and setting up a consumer protection agency. The earlier ideas are already facing resistance in Congress, however.

Democrats in the House of Representatives are pushing for a fee on banks to pay back government bail-out money and establish a fund for future crises. Chris Van Hollen, a member of the Democratic leadership, predicted yesterday that the fee would pass the House of Representatives but he would only say it had a “decent chance” in the Senate. Republicans are also sceptical of creating a consumer watchdog, preferring to strengthen existing oversight agencies.

Now the Democrats no longer have a “super-majority”, banking reform, like healthcare, will depend on attracting Republican votes in the Senate.

John McCain, the former Republican presidential candidate, is pushing to restore Depression-era restrictions on banks, known as Glass-Steagall, that were repealed in the late 1990s. Other Republican senators, however, voiced scepticism at Mr Obama’s plans. “Let’s solve problems,” said Senator Jon Kyl of Arizona.

“Let’s not be finding a bogeyman so that we can turn public attention away from what they’re doing wrong in the Administration,” he added.


Q&A:

What is Obama’s point exactly? He wants to ban banks from taking the huge risks that led them to be bailed out by taxpayers and brought on the credit crunch.

Will Britain follow? George Osborne, the Shadow Chancellor, rushed to support President Obama, but said that Britain would not follow unless it was a worldwide initiative. Labour also indicated that it was in broad support. Legal and practical complexities mean that Mr Obama’s words may fall on deaf ears. The best chance of success may be if banks do it of their own accord.

Will the crackdown change the way UK bank accounts operate? Since all the government initiatives are designed to force banks to behave more cautiously, their chances to make profits could be reduced and if profits from commercial banking fall, customers may find that they get less or have to pay more for personal banking.

Does it also mean that small businesses may find it even harder to get loans? Yes.

Will bankers’ jobs be lost? If banks are subjected to new curbs fewer bankers will be required.

Won’t some of these big institutions we now call banks just reinvent themsleves and carry on? Yes, but they may well find life much more difficult.

But London might benefit from all this, if American clamps down and we don’t, right? There is a huge opporutnity for the City, but only if our politicians fail to introduce the similar reforms that they say they want. Financial centres in other parts of Europe, or farther afield in Asia or in offshiore tax havens, may be rubbing their hands.

Does this spell the end of banker’s bonuses? That is one of the clear aims, but bankers are a crafty breed: don’t bet against them winning in the end.

Will it stop future crises? Probably not. If financial institutions of the future are really determined to take the risks that landed them in so much trouble, they may well find a way. And when the credit crunch is a distant memory, they may find justifications too. But if future banking crises are to be avoided, some extra controls may be inevitable.

Katherine Griffiths
 
No, your missing the point.

The TARP program saved the financial system AND made money in the process. The fundamentals of the banking system were sound, they have sound business models.... unlike the car companies. What they needed was a bridge to get them through the panic phase. The Unions have unsustainable work rules and compensation packages and they are slowly (or not so slowly any longer) bleeding their host to death.

Set aside your university freshman class struggle view for a second and look at the facts.

OTB

LOL

Well either one of us is missing the point or we are making different points. Do you agree that without the TARP money most of the institutions you named would be broke and the world would have been dragged into a credit crisis? Do you agree that the instability of the institutions was caused by poor credit risk analysis and the creation and sale of exotic instruments and derivatives? Do you agree that the US and other countries had no choice but to support the institutions with TARP or analogous programs?

The purpose of TARP was not to make money so that fact that it did was entirely beside the point. The point was to avoid a greater crisis and to promote lending. If you look at the earnings of what are now big banks (ie GS etc) it is coming from trading not banking. So those companies created a crisis which drove down the value of stocks, received bail out money from the government to promote lending and then used the money to trade and make big profits and pay big bonuses to the traders not the bankers. if you are involved in the credit markets in the US (and I am) you would know that commercial lending is still very, very tight and access to money is difficult.

Smaller banks have been allowed to fail because the loss of any one of them does not threaten the system. that was not true of AIG or GS etc. therefore those institutions can ignore sound business and do whatever they like for short term gain with impunity because they know that in a crunch they will be bailed out because they are "too big to fail".
 
LOL

Well either one of us is missing the point or we are making different points. Do you agree that without the TARP money most of the institutions you named would be broke and the world would have been dragged into a credit crisis?

Clearly, that credit crisis as you will recall was securities (MBS) that were devalued because of the dramatic fall of the housing market AND the inability to mark them to market (the crisis part). TARP injected capital and liquidity for a short period of time (less than 18 months in most cases.

Do you agree that the instability of the institutions was caused by poor credit risk analysis and the creation and sale of exotic instruments and derivatives?

Yes and no.

The real culprit here is excess liquidity. This surge of liquidity was caused by: government agencies insuring loans (via political policies to encourage home ownership), credit agencies rating bonds in such a way that people with poor credit could receive low interest loans and people/institutions who purchased those bonds earned above market returns. This alchemy of turning weak borrowers into A bonds with significant returns (via the rating process - which in this case is your "poor credit risk analysis" which should more properly be called poor underwriting) created a bubble that burst.

Much of this lending was not done by the big banks that you're focused on - some of them got into trouble by purchasing these mortgage companies and buying the bonds.

Do you agree that the US and other countries had no choice but to support the institutions with TARP or analogous programs?

Yes, letting the system fail would have caused economic catastrophe.

The purpose of TARP was not to make money so that fact that it did was entirely beside the point.

Here you are wrong. The fact that it's making money demonstrates that the industry that was supported is fundamentally healthy and needed support for a short period of time. The amount of money is less important to the US Treasury than the point that all these firms were able to repay the governments assistance with a healthy return AND raise capital in the open market.


The point was to avoid a greater crisis and to promote lending. If you look at the earnings of what are now big banks (ie GS etc) it is coming from trading not banking. So those companies created a crisis which drove down the value of stocks, received bail out money from the government to promote lending and then used the money to trade and make big profits and pay big bonuses to the traders not the bankers. if you are involved in the credit markets in the US (and I am) you would know that commercial lending is still very, very tight and access to money is difficult.

This is both a confused and inaccurate point.

First, Goldman Sachs isn't really a bank (yes, they have a bank charter, I've talked to them about it, they have it so they can take deposits - almost free money today).

Go to the websites of your least favorite banks, look at their loan volume, you will find that they ARE lending. What you will also find is that they are being VERY conservative about WHO they lend money to (remember your "poor credit risk analysis" point earlier). You can't have it both ways, you can't be asking banks to be prudent AND pump money into the economy - the latter is what caused the bubble - the LAST organization you want making underwriting decisions is the federal government. There is an old banking saying, never lend money to anyone who really needs it.

You shouldn't focus on the bonuses - yes it's crazy, yes there is a huge moral hazard (and I've not found a single person who knows a sensible way to regulate this - and I work with these people and those who regulate them). I'm profoundly unsympathetic to them, but all the noise about it in Washington is populist poppycock.

Smaller banks have been allowed to fail because the loss of any one of them does not threaten the system. that was not true of AIG or GS etc. therefore those institutions can ignore sound business and do whatever they like for short term gain with impunity because they know that in a crunch they will be bailed out because they are "too big to fail".

Yes and no.

Neither AIG or GS are really banks, so talking about them on a banking thread is a bit off topic, AIG is a special case.

While the big banks are not allowed to fail, their owners are punished substantially. If you owned shares in Wachovia (top 5 bank in the US) you'll know what I mean. The institutions are bailed out to support the system (this happened even to a larger extent in Europe) but the shareholders are allowed to fail. The moral hazard I mentioned above is that the officers/traders have already made the money, the risk/reward is one sided.

When small institutions fail, it cost the US Treasury money as well, they are broken up, their assets sold off..... not much different from being bailed out really.

OTB
 
Anybody here familiar with the new banking regulations proposed by President Obama?
As is typical of most proposals of the Obama Administration, no one including the President seemingly really knows the details of the proposal rather it is a broad and sweeping outline.

These include broad outlines include:
- banks that take federally insured deposits or have the right to borrow from the Fed would be prohibited from owning, investing in or sponsoring hedge funds or private-equity firms.
- banks would be forbidden from acquiring another bank if the deal would give it more than 10% of the nation’s insured deposits including short-term borrowing from financial markets
- capping the share of assets any one firm could hold.

The Devil is entirely in the details. Further it should be mentioned that the House Banking Committee is already working on a Bill of its own.
 
As is typical of most proposals of the Obama Administration, no one including the President seemingly really knows the details of the proposal rather it is a broad and sweeping outline.

These include broad outlines include:
- banks that take federally insured deposits or have the right to borrow from the Fed would be prohibited from owning, investing in or sponsoring hedge funds or private-equity firms.
- banks would be forbidden from acquiring another bank if the deal would give it more than 10% of the nation’s insured deposits including short-term borrowing from financial markets
- capping the share of assets any one firm could hold.

The Devil is entirely in the details. Further it should be mentioned that the House Banking Committee is already working on a Bill of its own.

He needed to create some new headlines......

Brooks actually busted him for dropping his "g"s at a town hall meeting in OH - a Harvard Law grad who grew up in Hawaii dropping his "g"s when he's in trouble..... classic.


OTB
 
Banning proprietary trading would benefit all the banks except Goldman Sachs. For every dollar made by a trader, that same dollar is lost by another trader and the winning trader is usually with Goldman Sachs.
 
First, Goldman Sachs isn't really a bank

One of the things that the financial crisis highlighted was that most of the entities that FUNCTIONED as banks were not legally banks. When you expand and look at all the institutions that were accepting money from investors and then lending it out, in other words, functioning as banks, you find that the US financial system suffered a massive, widespread collapse.

When you restrict yourself to the legal definition of a chartered bank things don't look too bad, but those non-bank banks had taken away a lot of the actual banking business from the legal banks.

Whether you think the US banking system weathered the storm, or essentially collapsed, thus depends on what you consider to be a "bank".
 
Banning proprietary trading would benefit all the banks except Goldman Sachs. For every dollar made by a trader, that same dollar is lost by another trader and the winning trader is usually with Goldman Sachs.

That is a far too simplistic view of how prop trading works
Goldman Sachs has profitable prop trading operations, but there are many others who are also profitable.

This will be a big mistake as other foreign firms will step up & fill the void if US firms are regulated out of this business
Jobs, revenue & taxes will move offshore
 
Has the auction rate securities market recovered?

No, but what does that have to do with the core business of banking?

I don't think it's this market that is giving the large bank earnings pressure.

OTB
 
No, but what does that have to do with the core business of banking?

I don't think it's this market that is giving the large bank earnings pressure.

OTB

It was a de facto bank, until it went bust, one of many, many so called "shadow banks". You're right, it isn't giving the large banks earning pressure any more!
 
More Government control.
I love that Obama and Congress think they can do such a better job of controlling risk while they vote to increase the national debt ceiling another $1.9 trillion on a credit limit of $12.104 trillion which they exceeded in mid December with a balance of $12.135 trillion.

And the Government is supposed to be responsible enough to manage the dealings of banks when they can't even control their own balance sheets.

How ironic!

I think you'll find in the administration a relationship between how well someone understands the FSI industry and how much they support these moves.

Don't get me wrong, we need a regulatory overhaul of the FSI industry - we need to regulate some of the currently unregulated activities AND consolidate and rationalize the regulatory bodies. What we don't need is phony populist distractions from election losses.

OTB
 
American banks were heavily regulated in the 1950's and 1960's and I don't see any evidence that such regulation held back progress or impeded capitalism.
 
More Government control.
I love that Obama and Congress think they can do such a better job of controlling risk while they vote to increase the national debt ceiling another $1.9 trillion on a credit limit of $12.104 trillion which they exceeded in mid December with a balance of $12.135 trillion.

And the Government is supposed to be responsible enough to manage the dealings of banks when they can't even control their own balance sheets.

How ironic!

Did it escape you that the financial system collapsed (i.e. had to be bailed out by the government)?
 
American banks were heavily regulated in the 1950's and 1960's and I don't see any evidence that such regulation held back progress or impeded capitalism.

American banks are among the worlds most regulated banks today.... the issue isn't the amount of regulation, it's the effectiveness of that regulation.

OTB
 
American banks are among the worlds most regulated banks today.... the issue isn't the amount of regulation, it's the effectiveness of that regulation.

OTB

Exactly!
When real competent regulators are removed like Team 'w' did the last 8 yrs and replaced with political inept hacks like 'heck-of-a-job' Brownie things tend to go into the toilet BIGTIME like you fav DICK used to mutter under his breath on occasion!...:rolleyes: