Passchendaele- The Movie

Bear669

New member
Apr 9, 2006
2,301
3
0
Wilds of the GTA
OMFG!

Get it off your cable! I had been procrastinating- Canadian flick about a sea of mud? I like my history 'straight' thanks, and I didnt think much good would come of this.

BUT

Oscar calibre cinematography & writing, brilliant use of CGI and supporting cast. Paul Gross is a pretty boy, but DAMN he can act.
Canadians are not just portrayed as poor schmucks at Dieppe, but very good brutal killers, smart officers, REMF, racist cowards, pompous pricks, funny and caring.... and fools.

Last 5 minutes are rather HEAVY on the symbolism, but WTF I would still rate it in the top 10 war flicks and for SURE top 5 about WWI.
 
Canucks and Aussies were considered the shocktroops of the Allied forces in WW1. The term "devil-dogs" which became a nickname of the US Marines based on what Germans supposedly called them for their ferocity was actually coined by a US source after the war ended......the reputation of the Canadians, fighting for the first time under Canadian command, really shook the Germans as the war progressed. Germany really took notice when Canadians took the field, and on more than one occasion, the Germans, having repulsed attacks by other Allied troops on long-held positions, lost the position to Canucks and decided counterattacks just weren't worth it. Withstanding a gas attack with a piss-soaked hankie over your nose & mouth? Incredible!
 
In the later part of WWI, there was a standing order from German High Command, fight where the Canadians aren't. Kind of says it all.
 
History Television had one of their episodes of (I think it was) Turning Points of History today focused on the battle at Paschendale.
 
It's interesting because although the Germans did consider the Canadians "storm troops" (and to some degree this carried over to WWII), the Germans had a less than stellar opinion of Canadian battlefield tactics and organization in WWII. Particularly during the battles of Normandy they considered the Canadian attacks poorly planned, poorly led, uncoordinated, and failed to utilize combined arms properly. The closing of the Falaise Gap in particular was not a gold star moment for the Canadians.

Vimy Ridge in WWI being an exception, I tend to agree that Canadian soldiers have traditionally excelled at the smaller unit levels whereas at higher levels Canadian leadership has suffered. Probably not all that surprising if you consider Canada isn't a military power and generally only mobilizes to a large degree in times of war.

This movie was okay. From what I remember, which isn't much (and that should tell you something right there...), some of the battle scenes were ridiculous Rambo-style affairs.

I found some of the subplots more interesting than the "war movie" aspect of the film.

Beware, if you're looking for a good "war movie", this isn't it...
 
It gives an idea of the scope of the fighting and the heroism involved that at Hill 70, members of the 10th Battalion CEF recieved a V.C., three Distinguished Service Orders, seven Military Crosses, nine Distinguished Conduct Medals and sixty Military Medals.
 
I saw the movie when it first came out and was really impressed.

While it was a little heavy on melodrama at times all in all it was well worth my time.

7/10
 
the Germans had a less than stellar opinion of Canadian battlefield tactics and organization in WWII. Particularly during the battles of Normandy they considered the Canadian attacks poorly planned, poorly led, uncoordinated, and failed to utilize combined arms properly. The closing of the Falaise Gap in particular was not a gold star moment for the Canadians.
However, might that be because the fighting between Canadian and German troops in Normandy was particularly bloodly. The Germans had no love for the Canadian Army in Normandy.

Also of course there were the larger problems of the 21st Army Group in Normandy which affected the First Canadian Army
 
I was out of the country when the movie came out and only rented it a couple of months ago. Given all the bad reviews and the fact that I have never been impressed with Paul Gross, I was pleasantly surprised. I thought it was a pretty good movie.
 
A very interesting book on WW1 is titled "Three Day Road". It is written from the perspective of a native Canadian soldier from northern Ontario.
 
However, might that be because the fighting between Canadian and German troops in Normandy was particularly bloodly. The Germans had no love for the Canadian Army in Normandy.

Also of course there were the larger problems of the 21st Army Group in Normandy which affected the First Canadian Army

No. German after-action reports indicated that the Canadian attacks were poorly launched and conducted. They weren't as bad as the British (who were always overly cautious and conservative) but they weren't as good as the Americans (not so much for their individual fighting ability, which was generally poorer, but for the much better planning and coordination of arms).

If you're referring to atrocities between the Canadians and Germans (yes, they were committed by both sides), that wasn't the context of the analysis.
 
They weren't as bad as the British (who were always overly cautious and conservative).
It always has to be remembered that by 1944 the British had largely run out of troops and draftable men, this wasn't quite as true of Canada - but then again remember the Quebec Draft Crisis, this definately reinforced Field Marshall Montgomery's already set piece nature. This of course was not at all the case for U.S. commanders.
 
No. German after-action reports indicated that the Canadian attacks were poorly launched and conducted. They weren't as bad as the British (who were always overly cautious and conservative) but they weren't as good as the Americans (not so much for their individual fighting ability, which was generally poorer, but for the much better planning and coordination of arms).

If you're referring to atrocities between the Canadians and Germans (yes, they were committed by both sides), that wasn't the context of the analysis.

I would throw in a couple of notes of caution. The Canadians in Normandy generally fought SS formations who were particularly skilled and had been at war since 1939. As well, those Germans were extremely arrogant about themselves and their abilities and highly racist. All 3 Canadian divisions in Normandy were very green and the 2 divisions which arrived after the campaign was underway - 2nd Infantry and 4th Armoured - were not that competently led at the regimental level. As well, the campaign generally featured the Allies assaulting and the Germans defending. It's easier to defend than asault.

Given a little more experience, the Canadians would have been as technically skilled as the Germans.
 
It always has to be remembered that by 1944 the British had largely run out of troops and draftable men...

Yes, but the conservatism went much deeper than from running out of manpower... at least in 1944. British military doctrine post-WWI focused on being conservative and expending munitions not lives. This was a direct lesson learned from the lost generation of WWI. The British did not want another Somme.

The conservatism runs throughout the British approach to WWII. It was right in their infantry training manuals. One of the best examples is Montgomery in North Africa. He sat in Egypt watching his material and manpower grow and grow and would not attack until he vastly outnumbered the Germans in everything. When the attack finally came, it was overwhelming. This approach continued in Western Europe (with the possible exception of the Arnhem debacle... interestigly, when the British finally took a big gamble it blew up in their face).

It's interesting because the Americans were similar in that they relied on their massive material superiority (often to the point that American units would "hang back" longer than they should have, wanting the artillery/air force to do their job for them) but the conservatism was bottom-up (from the average grunt) rather than top-down (from the British military doctrine). And the Soviets were another beast entirely. They ended up with massive material superiority but despite that they were still overly aggressive to the point of stupidity. Unlike the Americans and British, the Soviets would shoot front line solders who would not advance. And that scene in Enemy at the Gates where the Soviets mow down their advancing infantry when they start to falter... based on reality. Soviet political commissars and special pre-KGB units would advance behind infantry formations and shoot anyone who tried to turn back. No charge, no trial, just a bullet in the neck (if you got that close).
 
I would throw in a couple of notes of caution. The Canadians in Normandy generally fought SS formations who were particularly skilled and had been at war since 1939. As well, those Germans were extremely arrogant about themselves and their abilities and highly racist.

Excuses and inaccuracies.

No German formations in 1944 had been fighting since 1939. Those soldiers were mostly dead or incapacitated, mostly a result of the Eastern Front. German military formations (whereever they fought) in 1944 were a mere shadow of the 1939 versions. The SS were generally more motivated than regular infantry formations and also received better equipment. That superiority didn't necessarily flow up into their leadership. Generally speaking, German infantry formations (overall) had superior leadership. In the SS, your Nazi pedigree was as important as your leadership ability. In the army, not so much (especially pre-assassination attempt on Hitler).

The Hitlerjugend of the 12th SS Panzer Division were fanatical but they were also boys (or young men, if you want to be generous). They were not the tactical technicians of 1939, as evidenced by repeated "human wave" assaults against Allied positions where they were gunned down like target practice.

The whole "Waffen SS were arrogant, racist, merciless war criminals" thing is largely a myth. They were elite divisions and, just like the American 82nd Airborne and Big Red One, the Waffen SS considered themselves superior to regular infantry divisions. And when you're a better equipped, elite unit that is utilized for the most dangerous and important missions, it's probably justified. There's a reason the Waffen SS divisions were often referred to as "Hitler's fire brigades"... they were asked to do what regular infantry/panzer formations could not.

People love to think of the Waffen SS as the most evil of evil. But it's generally not true. Note, I say generally. Yes, Waffen SS were involved in atrocities. But so were the Soviets. And so were the Americans and British. And... GASP!, the Canadians (in fact, the Canadians were particularly known for their "brutality" and not taking prisoners, especially Waffen SS). Kurt Meyer, commander of the Hitlerjugend, went on to become good friends with Canadian soldiers after WWII. This is the same commander who was in charge of the units who massacred the Canadians at an abbey in France.

It being easier to defend than assault is a true, but meaningless statement in this context. The British and Americans were attacking as well so that factor applied equally to them. And the British were fighting the same SS troops the Canadians were. Yet the Canadians were cited for their particularly poor tactical leadership during the battles in Normandy. The truth is probably that Canadian senior leadership had not been developed as much as one would have hoped (largely due to Canada not being a military power post WWI) and it was reflected on the battlefield. That and the "green" nature of the units. Don't get me wrong, joe average Canadian soldier was as tough, if not tougher, than any other soldier out there. But in terms of being military tacticians, not so much.

One thing the Germans had going for them was their aggressiveness. It was bred into their bones. German military doctrine was all about seizing the initiative and being aggressive. But the Germans were on the defensive post 1943 you say? Doesn't matter. Even on the defense the Germans were always trying to take the initiative and be aggressive. To the point that vastly outnumbered battle groups (kampfgruppen) would attack in the hopes of disrupting offensives and causing them to lose momentum. I'll tell ya, when you're involved in a long war, being on the side that's particularly aggressive means your number is going to come up sooner or late. Which is reflected in that the soldiers of 1941 (let alone 1939) by and large weren't around by 1944. By the end of the war in Western Europe, the degradation of German units was particularly acute. Many were incapable of even limited offensive actions due to their insufficient training (not to mention age and/or capability for military service). German counteroffensives in the battles along the Siegfried Line that would have been successful with 1939-1941 troops failed miserably due largely to the calibre of the troops available in 1944 (many of whom were in Volksgrenadier or Volkssturm units).
 
It's interesting because the Americans were similar in that they relied on their massive material superiority (often to the point that American units would "hang back" longer than they should have, wanting the artillery/air force to do their job for them) but the conservatism was bottom-up (from the average grunt) rather than top-down (from the British military doctrine).
You, I believe over emphasize this point Keebler Elf. Certainly from General Grant forward to the present (in conventional warfare) the U.S. Army has emphasized the use of material to save lives.

Also, again I point out that American commanders did not need to cannibalize and disband Battalions and even Divisions the way the British Army had to.
 
The whole "Waffen SS were arrogant, racist, merciless war criminals" thing is largely a myth. They were elite divisions . . .

People love to think of the Waffen SS as the most evil of evil. But it's generally not true. Note, I say generally. Yes, Waffen SS were involved in atrocities.
I don't have my books on the Battle of Normandy at hand to cite the particular units, but you don't mention that a number of the Waffen SS units in Normandy fighting the First Canadian Army had in the previous few months been involved in atrocities in France. It was not merely that they were elite units, although some were much more so than others, it was also that many of the Waffen SS units in Normandy were fanatics.