Both, consumption only and flat taxes place too much of a burden on low income earners.
How on earth do you figure that Compromised? Is that not part of the determination of what if any deductions will be allowed and the rate?A flat tax is simply not powerful enough to fill the government coffers.
How on earth do you figure that Compromised? Is that not part of the determination of what if any deductions will be allowed and the rate?
For fuck sake. When did those bastards pass a constipation tax .
Misterme your poll gives no flat tax or fair tax options
How about a graduated system of consumption tax?
If you are buying food in a grocery store (or McDonald's), clothes at Wal-Mart, etc., you pay little or no tax.
If you are eating at fancy restaurants, buying clothes at high-end department stores, etc. you pay maximum tax.
i find it funny that people on an escort review board would recommend solely consumption tax (it is one of the choices on the poll) as a way to ensure healthy fiscal policy...
can i get a show of hands of hobbyists who forsee themselves paying gst/pst/hst when going on "dates" and agencies that will charge such taxes?
pure consumption taxes will just drive the underground economy or move things more to a cash basis. think about the $3 dvds you pay at p-mall; you think those guys are remitting all the appropriate taxes to the govt?
The flat tax idea has been around a long time. Various provincial governments have looked at it and it always dies a slow quiet death. While I have never bothered to actually read the numbers, I have been told by members of both the academic community and a senior ministry official that a flat tax would not bring in enough revenue or it would be too punishing to low and low-middle income earners.