H1N1 Cost overruns

"Regardless, this is exactly what the government wants..."

Out of curiousity, why do you think the gov't wants the cost of h1n1 distribution to spiral out of control?

Simple... but not specifically the cost of the pig flu virus... no.

They just love the hype surrounding these sorts of things because it gives them lots of excuses to steal more of our money, and/ or gives them plenty of excuses when they go over budget... And we all know they can't stick to a budget. :rolleyes:
 
That's the problem... THERE IS NO END! They just keep taking and taking and this sorta thing makes it "justifiable"...
***

They just love the hype surrounding these sorts of things because it gives them lots of excuses to steal more of our money, and/ or gives them plenty of excuses when they go over budget.

***

This and the original statement simply make no sense.

Are you trying to say the government is actually using the flu bug as an excuse to go over budget in a recession that has us already well over a non budget????:confused:
 
This and the original statement simply make no sense.

Are you trying to say the government is actually using the flu bug as an excuse to go over budget in a recession that has us already well over a non budget????

I wish you could (sometime soon) learn how to do quotes properly toughb... And I'm not saying this to give you a hard time, it just makes it difficult to follow your posts sometimes...

To answer your question, no, I am not saying this is the only excuse... they have MANY... just add this one to the already HUGE pile. And because the media has blown this whole pig flu hype to ASTRONOMICAL heights, and because it IS a "hot button" issue, no one will question it.
 
I wish you could (sometime soon) learn how to do quotes properly toughb... And I'm not saying this to give you a hard time, it just makes it difficult to follow your posts sometimes...

To answer your question, no, I am not saying this is the only excuse... they have MANY... just add this one to the already HUGE pile. And because the media has blown this whole pig flu hype to ASTRONOMICAL heights, and because it IS a "hot button" issue, no one will question it.
***

With all due respect, you could never give me a hard time. I'm not that type of guy...:p
 
"I wish you could (sometime soon) learn how to do quotes properly toughb"

Ah shucks CG. I hope this isn't bothering you too much. It's, what, the 101 time you've mentioned it.

Looks more like a deversionary tactic to me but hey I'm just a humble poster. Chuckle

...:)
 
20,000?????? Is that what the medical "experts" were predicting?? (More hype I suppose...)

Since you are such a firm believer of FACTS.... Please show me 1 report that says we would be expecting that many dead from ONLY pig flu... And by that I mean without underlying medical issues and would have died anyway if they just got some other disease.

The last time we faced an H1N1 pandemic, the 1918 pig flu epidemic, it killed between 50 and 100 million people.

Pig flu is capable of that. Easily capable of that. THIS particular strain isn't that virulent, but it looked like it was when it first broke out.

Supposing we followed your advice and back when the data said it had a 2-3% kill rate, similar to 1918, we just all said hey the govt. is full of shit let's not vaccinate anybody.

Then it turned out to be similar to the 1918 strain, and then hundreds of millions die, some 300k of them in Canada.

How costly is that?

I'm quite happy to pay $30/person or whatever you claim it is every time there is a chance of that happening to make sure that it doesn't happen ever again.

Just because it didn't happen in your lifetime doesn't mean it isn't going to happen again: It WILL happen again, it is only a matter of time. The question is will we be prepared for it, and stop it?

Even in this case of a much milder virus than the 1918 one it's well worth $1.5 billion to stop it. All you have to do is prevent around 600 otherwise healthy people from dying and you've saved the economy more than $1.5 billion, assuming a healthy 30 year old life is worth around 2.5 million.

I think I finally clued into your situation... You work for a drug company don't you? :rolleyes: (Or are at least heavily invested in the market with them...)

No, I do not work for a drug company nor do I have any investment in any drug company.

What I am is technically literate and I am able to read published research and comprehend the actual risks.
 
I will go further:

It is GREAT that this strain is as lethal as it is. First of all it's lethal enough to justify a $1.5 billion spend, and secondly, and more importantly, it gave us a trial run of our pandemic response plan--and that plan was found SERIOUSLY wanting.

Hopefully we learn and fix the problems and the next time we have to do a mass vaccination it doesn't go as horribly off the rails as this time round.

The lessons we are learning right now potentially represent a few hundred million lives lost versus saved, should we next face a 1918 style H1N1 outbreak.
 
With all due respect, you could never give me a hard time. I'm not that type of guy...
Now you're just bein silly... that remark was obviously meant in the figurative sense not the physical sense. I know your disappointed with my repeated refusal of your advances, but I'm sorry toughb... I'm just not interested in a sexual relationship with you. I'm strictly interested in female companionship when it comes to that sort of thing.

Ah shucks CG. I hope this isn't bothering you too much. It's, what, the 101 time you've mentioned it.
It's only been 22 times... but I do admit to once writing a thread with step by step instructions for you as well. And you STILL can't get it right! **shakes head in disbelief**

Looks more like a diversionary tactic to me but hey I'm just a humble poster.

Not at all... I answered all your questions clearly and accurately based on my own "sometimes twisted" perspective of course.

Oh, and notice how nicely all the quotes have been formatted? (23 times...) :p
 
the 1918 flu pandemic was not H1N1 nobody is sure just what varient it was there have been a number of attempts to determine that . It was called the spanish flu because it apparantly came back from the war theater after it ended.

The last time we had swine flu was in the 70's it was much ado about not much vaccine rolled out media did what the media usually does and it petered out jsut like most flu variants. It appeared in the mid to late 50's which is why people over 55 are not on the first up list for vaccinations they are likely allready immune.

This flu varient has so far turned out to be a mild variety of the flu. It has challenges for a specific subset of the human race but generally it is less damaging than the ussual flu which is due to hit after Christmas.

It would perhaps behove everybody to just possible settle down a little and

NOT END THE HUMAN RACE JUST YET
 
the 1918 flu pandemic was not H1N1 nobody is sure just what varient it was there have been a number of attempts to determine that.

Do you have a source, or are you making this up as you go along? The 1918 H1N1 has been isolated from frozen tissue samples and its RNA sequenced.

For example of one of a zillion articles you could have found using google if you had tried:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2701943/

The last time we had swine flu was in the 70's it was much ado about not much vaccine rolled out media did what the media usually does and it petered out jsut like most flu variants.

Wrong again. The 1976 outbreak occurred at Fort Dix and everyone who had it was quarantined. It never spread into the community and never became a pandemic. People were widely vaccinated just in case but there is no evidence that there was ever community transmission of that strain.

At this point I have to think you just make stuff up...

There are indeed seasonal variants of H1N1 in circulation but they are not pandemics as they are common strains for which most people have some level of immunity.
 
I'd like to see a citation on this claim please... :confused:

He's actually wrong this time the deaths caused by that varieant were in that range but nobody actually knows what strain it was. They have exhumed bodies of people who die from the " spanish flu" who were buried in permafrost to try and recover sample but it did not work.

Although the mindset of somebody who would activly look for one of the more dangerous viruses the planet has ever produced is something I think needs to be studied, preferably under a microscope one thin section at a time.
 
Has the cost accounting subtracted the money saved by not having to treat people in ICU, and not having them die?

My understanding is that it's enormously expensive to put someone on a ventilator in an ICU for a week, and even more expensive when, after all that, they die.

Could we include the lost productivity in the cost so that people off work for a few days because they are sick or have to take care of their kids? Anyways, of that $500, much of it goes to workers and therefore ends up back in the economy.
 
He's actually wrong this time the deaths caused by that varieant were in that range but nobody actually knows what strain it was. They have exhumed bodies of people who die from the " spanish flu" who were buried in permafrost to try and recover sample but it did not work.
...

I have also heard that a significant number of the deaths may have had something to do with TB or that it was a contributing factor. No idea of how much basis there is for this though.
 
I'd like to see a citation on this claim please... :confused:

Sure, here's one:

http://muse.jhu.edu/login?uri=/journals/bulletin_of_the_history_of_medicine/v076/76.1johnson.html

See the link I provided to landscaper which discusses the sequencing of that strain in terms of his ridiculous questions about whether it was H1N1 or not.

So many people died that it turned out there were various bodies frozen in ice in some colder countries and the virus has been recovered from them. The actual virus exists today in labs, there are no fucking questions about what it is.
 
Sure, here's one:

http://muse.jhu.edu/login?uri=/journals/bulletin_of_the_history_of_medicine/v076/76.1johnson.html

See the link I provided to landscaper which discusses the sequencing of that strain in terms of his ridiculous questions about whether it was H1N1 or not.

So many people died that it turned out there were various bodies frozen in ice in some colder countries and the virus has been recovered from them. The actual virus exists today in labs, there are no fucking questions about what it is.
I'm confused... That report says :

21.5 million over 3 years, then revises it to somewhere between 24.7-39.3 million, then changes it again to 50 million and goes on to suggest that even THAT could be wrong and suggests that it may be understated by as much as much as 100 percent.

Not exactly a definitive answer now is it? In other words... no one fucking knows for sure...

Regardless, this is a world wide total isn't it? Also, I'll bet ya dollars to doughnuts that there were insurmountable mitigating factors that compounded the problem that don't exist today. Comparing the 1918 pandemic to present day situation is just ludicrous. The only reason it is done is to create hype.

Anyway, my only beef is how the Canadian government is handling the problem... I'm still waiting for a report from some medical experts to support Fuji's claim that the death toll could be in the neighbourhood of 20,000 lives for Canada.

What's the cost of 20k dead?
 
...
Not exactly a definitive answer now is it?
...

Sure, you go back almost 100 years and get reliable numbers for worldwide deaths from the Spanish Flu. You probably couldn't even come close to an accurate number for the total number of deaths for any reason during that time period let alone have the ability to diagnose specific causes.