Is China headed toward collapse?

His most famous call came in 2001, when Chanos was one of the first to figure out that the accounting numbers presented to the public by Enron were pure fiction.

Wait 'til Google is caught. LOL. Super billions, everything for free, copied and stolen. Much like massive construction all over China, no one to occupy a single room. No difference.
Another government cooking the books are the DPJ in Japan. I'm shorting Japan like mad.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Yep, those mainland Chinese Banks such as ICBC, CCB, BOC and Agricultural Bank of China were in big mess 10 years ago. The percentage of Non-performance loans (NPL) for these "Big Four" were skyrocketed, dwarfed those S&L crisis in the early 90s, maybe even the credit crunch nowadays.

Thanks to the Communist comrades in provinces, cities and local conties, they created these messes by elaborate scheme of kickbacks, cronyism, rebates, money laundering, briberies. Those banks were technically in default/under receivership until the Mandarins in Beijing injected/pumped trillions of taxpayer dollars (maybe some in T-bills?) to fix/bail out the banks before the IPOs in HKSE and Shanghai Stock Exchange few years ago.

Think of those banks are convicted but reformed drug dealers coming clean after 2006 and preaching "prudence"/"moderation". And they seem to have insight and be "nice", read without provoking or making fun on their counterparts at Citibank, Bank of America, Merrill Lynch, Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers and AIG when the latter group are in distress.:rolleyes:

The world is flat when it comes to confict of interest and stealing taxpayers money legally via bailout. It doesn't matter whether you have your ex-i banking buddies running SEC, Treasury or even Fed, like those in America. Or the comrades in cahoots to game the system as routine, like those in China.

At one point the Economist reported that 40% of loans in China were non-performing !

OTB
 
If it is too good to be true, usually it is. China's growth has been called a miracle. I am sure there is a lot of growth, but I am not sure I trust those numbers. Just a case in point, food production in most western countries is measured by tonnes of grains (wheat, rice etc). China's statistics includes potatoes in that list. If you do some tweaking like this, you can show miraculous growth on paper.

Another point - the point from a third word country to a developed country is never linear. There is a period of stagnation/low growth, followed by rapid growth. In this phase, there is an illusion that the rapid growth will go on forever. But that is not the case. At some point, the growth reaches its maturity and the nation enters a stagnant/low growth phase again. Malaysia, Singapore, Japan - all have followed the same patter, although at different times. 1973 Oil shock, put a break on Japan's high growth story. Asian currency crisis did the same to Malaysia. Usually property boom precedes any bust. Malaysia built the Petronas just before its bust. For China it could be the bird nest stadium.
 
We do, just not the things an uneducated workforce can make....
https://terb.cc/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=260778
OTB

I hate to tell you the truth, OTB, but Apple **IS** an uneducated workforce. And a price target for their stock at $300.00 is a bubble for a serious, fast, intense collapse to hell. As for Microsoft, they are laying off workers. And Google is stealing copyrights at catastrophic levels. I like America with this information. Maybe some American girls will actually fuck for once.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
I hate to tell you the truth, OTB, but Apple **IS** an uneducated workforce. And a price target for their stock at $300.00 is a bubble for a serious, fast, intense collapse to hell. As for Microsoft, they are laying off workers. And Google is stealing copyrights at catastrophic levels. I like America with this information. Maybe some American girls will actually fuck for once.

Gyaos Baltar.

While I won't comment on the forward value of Apple stock the rest of the above is either wrong or mis-directed.

OTB
 
in my case Lenovo came out cheaper and, on top of that, I find Lenovo delivers a higher quality product--you can't throw your dell out of a moving vehicle or drive over it, and expect it to work.

Seems like that is only one aspect of the quality of a notebook and not a particularly important one at that.
 
While I won't comment on the forward value of Apple stock the rest of the above is either wrong or mis-directed. OTB

-- Microsoft is laying off workers. You know this. In fact they announced an additional 800 to the 5000 getting thrown out by 2011. FOR THE US ONLY.
-- Apple is loaded with uneducated workers. They are a small percentage of the markets. Over valued stock based on the existence of Steve Jobs. When he croaks, Apple is back to boxed Macs. Let's get real, Ipods are just for blasting music (mostly free music), Iphone is at the end of Moore's Law and competitors are coming in droves, NO ONE buys their PCs (an equivalent of Sun's Solaris in market share and we know what Sun is financially with or without Oracle), and there is nothing else Apple can really make from this point, except a Steve Jobs endorsement. Apple only has their hard-core fans that will collapse their credit card and look good for financial TV stock footage, but there is no market share with a handful of maniacal fans.
-- Google steals copyrights at catastrophic levels to create a demand for search, refer to my thread on that. Their numbers are all bogus and their stock runs in tandem with Apple, because of the same investor laundering nonsense of valuation, when Google doesn't make any money in anything "else" except search ad placement. And again, to get the demand for search, they break copyrights at catastrophic levels. And a large chunk of their clicks are from users making money for their own click accounts, or the ads are BLOCKED.
-- American girls don't fuck. If they did, jobs wouldn't go to China or India so fast. Be careful of Dalian, China. Too close for a bus from North Korea.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
The great thing about being a bear (or bull for that matter) is that you have a 50% chance of being correct. China has a growing middle class and consumption is growing. Most people do not have access to the same kinds of credit as we do and so there is not the same danger of a consumer or credit bubble forming. The biggest risk that the Chinese have is their exposure to US dollar denominated debt and assets. The risk to the Chinese economy is not that it is not on a solid foundation but that as the economy matures they will not be able to sustain the same pace of growth.
 
-- Microsoft is laying off workers. You know this. In fact they announced an additional 800 to the 5000 getting thrown out by 2011. FOR THE US ONLY.

Yes, but that's not the point, the point is they "make" something that is quite popular and profitable.

-- Apple is loaded with uneducated workers. They are a small percentage of the markets. Over valued stock based on the existence of Steve Jobs. When he croaks, Apple is back to boxed Macs. Let's get real, Ipods are just for blasting music (mostly free music), Iphone is at the end of Moore's Law and competitors are coming in droves, NO ONE buys their PCs (an equivalent of Sun's Solaris in market share and we know what Sun is financially with or without Oracle), and there is nothing else Apple can really make from this point, except a Steve Jobs endorsement. Apple only has their hard-core fans that will collapse their credit card and look good for financial TV stock footage, but there is no market share with a handful of maniacal fans.

I'm not sure how you quantify "loaded" but it's clearly a company making massive amounts of money on intellectual property and design.

Mac market share is small but up: http://www.appleinsider.com/article...in_europe_as_apples_competitors_struggle.html

Itunes is the worlds largest music store.

I think your predictions will ring about as true as your Hillary predictions.... look for a tablet in early 2010.
.......

-- American girls don't fuck. If they did, jobs wouldn't go to China or India so fast. Be careful of Dalian, China. Too close for a bus from North Korea.

Gyaos Baltar.

They do, they just don't fuck you.....

OTB
 
The Economist online wrote a brief on the chinese miracle economy some time ago that drew similar conclusions about how the stimulus cash was being spent there...ie: wrongly favouring exports at the expense of raising the living standards of the common man and/or giving them more security in sickness and old age.

Instead, they're stilling pushing on the old string of keeping the Yuan too cheap while subsidizing exporters. Chanos also apparently made some good bets during the mortgage meltdown. Being a short seller sounds like a fun way to make money.
 
The Economist online wrote a brief on the chinese miracle economy some time ago that drew similar conclusions about how the stimulus cash was being spent there...ie: wrongly favouring exports at the expense of raising the living standards of the common man and/or giving them more security in sickness and old age.

Instead, they're stilling pushing on the old string of keeping the Yuan too cheap while subsidizing exporters. Chanos also apparently made some good bets during the mortgage meltdown. Being a short seller sounds like a fun way to make money.

As it happens the Chines government announced today that it may allow the yuan to appreciate against the dollar. This would obviously be a positive development for the US which has been pushing this for several years. The Chinese have a vested interest in assisting the US with its own recovery and insuring that the greenback does not collapse.
 
At one point the Economist reported that 40% of loans in China were non-performing !OTB

Pretty close. They have their version of Resolution Trust Corporation in Beijing in charge to liquidate and manage those toxic asset, aka non-performance loans.

Don't be surprise i bankers from Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are working very hard to get pieces of actions by persuading and advising the Mandarins to let them performing proprietary trades on a portion of their assets. :rolleyes:

BTW, other than the Chinese central government, Goldman Sachs is the 2nd largest shareholder at ICBC, while the Chinese government is 2nd largest shareholder of Morgan Stanley, right after Mitsubishi UFJ.
 
The Economist online wrote a brief on the chinese miracle economy some time ago that drew similar conclusions about how the stimulus cash was being spent there...ie: wrongly favouring exports at the expense of raising the living standards of the common man and/or giving them more security in sickness and old age.

Sounds like the Chinese could not trust themselves, meaning cronies/comrades take a cut/trailer fee/rebate/kickback from the top to the very bottom out of the trillions dollars that are destined to provide minimum, not expensive and generous social security to the average Huang and Chens over there.

Instead, they're stilling pushing on the old string of keeping the Yuan too cheap while subsidizing exporters. Chanos also apparently made some good bets during the mortgage meltdown. Being a short seller sounds like a fun way to make money.

Or you could do it the cheapest way by speculating on FXP listed in NYSE.

Nevertheless there are significant downside, mainly,

-it's 2x leverage on the downside, not a buy and hold strategy for a year, maybe a couple of weeks at most as the volatility could kill you before the strategy could be proven right or not.

-the index the product track is mainly on H-shares listed in Hong Kong and/or those listed as ADR, meaning you are shorting 2x a basket of mainly large caps financial and energy sectors over there. This could be a challenge since you would get more bang for a buck if you short A-shares listed in Shanghai. Regretably no selling shorts are allowed in China and A-shares are not available for foreign investors, including those from Hong Kong or Taiwan.

-FX risk for CAD investors

Still it's better than investing in Nortel :rolleyes:
 
They do, they just don't fuck you.....
OTB

ROTFLMAO!! :D
Apparently, they don't fuck you either! Oh man, where's the fish bowl, time for a BJ. Cathay Pacific here I come....Poseidon, where is Mamasan Nut?

I think your predictions will ring about as true as your Hillary predictions.... look for a tablet in early 2010.

You mean the one where I said she would be Secretary of State?
Or the one where she came out within 24 hours of my post, that she has no plans to run in 2012? She's running.

Gyaos Baltar
 
The Chinese have a vested interest in assisting the US with its own recovery and insuring that the greenback does not collapse.

Just imagine the Chinese government officials shiver and red face (mad)/pale white (fear) when the American counterparts look cocky like George W. Bush and give a "friendly reminder" by saying,

"Gentleman, our money is your problem". :eek:
 
The author makes some excellent points. He may be right. I think that China will experience some “bumps” along the way but in the end, the phenomenal growth will continue.
The growth numbers are unsustainable in the long run. When the growth declines there will certainly be some over supply. I imagine that there is corruption and distortion of the economic performance similar to the distortions that existed in the Soviet era. There may be some reconciling of fantasy vs. reality in the coming years.
Still, I think that China has a bright future. I would be more worried about the disasterous consequences of Oh Bummer’s economic plan before I start worrying about China.
 
I would be more worried about the disasterous consequences of Oh Bummer’s economic plan before I start worrying about China.
Guess you missed the disastrous consequences of 8 yrs of bushinomics, eh. Or do you parrot along with bottie calling that 'Real Economic Performance'?...:rolleyes:
 
I think it will be interesting to see what pressure China comes under to loosen it's currency tie to the USD.....

OTB
 
The author makes some excellent points. He may be right. I think that China will experience some “bumps” along the way but in the end, the phenomenal growth will continue.

I don't think so. Those Beijing malls are only 50% full. They used to be 100%. China's economy is only 10% of the country. And that 10% of fake numbers will experience a 50% collapse. Maybe there will be a population call for a democracy, that's the only reason this fake "growth" continues, keeping everyone in check with a little bribery of jobs that belong to Americans and Canadians. And that help comes from American communist, slave master, greedy executives that speak English like a next door neighbor.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Wonder if KBR taught them how to 'cut corners'?....:eek: