It's Election Day in Canada.

oldjones

CanBarelyRe Member
Aug 18, 2001
24,458
12
38
Thanks to the fixed election date law our PM passed back in 2006, today is Canada's first-ever election date fixed in advance to "stop leaders from trying to manipulate the calendar" for partisan advantage. "Fixed election dates…level the playing field for all parties".

You will note a fixed election date is different from a fixed election. That's what he tried for when he ignored his own words and called that useless election back in 2008. Instead of a fix he got almost the same result he started with, and charged us $350 mil to do it.

If the polls are anything to go by, he'd have been way better off waiting till today. But Stevie never saw a promise without seeing the 'advantage' that breaking it would offer. Nor a playing field he couldn't wait to slant his way.

If only he was as smart as he thinks he is.
 
Were the other parties not screaming to overthrow the governing party to the point that it was nearly impossible to govern?

At that time, the other parties were getting it up the ass for supporting and passing all of Harpo's bills. They had no money with which to fight an election so they complained a lot while they passed every bill Harpo threw at them. That excuse about being unable to govern was just a smoke screen.
 
I'm not a Harper supporter but you can't have a fixed election day with a minority government, it's already been dealt with in court.
Right after the last election we saw the parties gang up to overthrow the results only to be slapped down by the Governor General, talk about not respecting the views of the people. :rolleyes:
 
Right after the last election we saw the parties gang up to overthrow the results only to be slapped down by the Governor General, talk about not respecting the views of the people. :rolleyes:

OJ only remembers what suits him. Being the slightest bit balanced was never part of his act.
 
Were the other parties not screaming to overthrow the governing party to the point that it was nearly impossible to govern?
Certainly that was his excuse for ignoring what he'd said and proving his 'law' was a sham by calling that useless election.

Cost us $350 mil for him to find out all his best efforts had impressed only an additional couple of percent of voters.

If he had actually tried to govern, instead of always looking for partisan advantage, and kept his word about election dates, he'd likely be celebrating a landslide tonight.

But like calling the election he almost lost—he just isn't that smart.
 
If he had actually tried to govern, instead of always looking for partisan advantage, and kept his word about election dates, he'd likely be celebrating a landslide tonight.

But like calling the election he almost lost—he just isn't that smart.
Hindsight is 20/20.
He was facing a weak Liberal leader, a French guy who wasn't liked in Quebec - the election could easily have tipped into a Conservative majority. Some of the reasons it didn't was Harper's arts cuts which didn't go over well in Quebec and because of strategic voting from the Left.
I don't sense that Canadians were angry at going to the polls, sure the voter turnout was low but overall we like democracy.

Isn't it good that we tested Dion for the Liberals?
 
I'm not a Harper supporter but you can't have a fixed election day with a minority government, it's already been dealt with in court.
Right after the last election we saw the parties gang up to overthrow the results only to be slapped down by the Governor General, talk about not respecting the views of the people. :rolleyes:

You're dead wrong on your first point: The law itself said that an election would be triggered when and if a government lost a confidence vote. The Court dealt with Harper calling an election without being defeated. They said nothing in the law actually fixed election dates.

Your second point shows you completely misunderstand our parliamentary system. All MP's are equal, they all get one vote. If you can assure the GG you'll get more of them to vote with you than against you, then you get to be PM. Until you lose that majority.

Perhaps you missed that Harper's party has only a plurality, not a majority. So he only gets to stay PM as long as one of the other parties lets him. Which they have, but at a price he resents. The coalition was simply a notice to him that they now had a different idea, and a serious proposal to the GG that she consider someone who could do what Harper couldn't. Govern.

As she had every right to, she gave him (and herself) time, to see what this coalition was made of, and it melted like the snow. But had it held, and defeated the minority Cons, it would have been most sensible of her to ask them—representing roughly two-thirds of the voters—to form a government.

Which might even have lasted until Harper's fixed election date, so-called.
 
The coalition would have been led by Dion. The Liberals wanted to ditch him as leader at that point, how could he get support from other parties for more than a few weeks?

Parliament had several opportunities to bring down Harper over the last few months but each party always backed away for various reasons. Seems like they're fine with him after all! :p
 
Hindsight is 20/20.
He was facing a weak Liberal leader, a French guy who wasn't liked in Quebec - the election could easily have tipped into a Conservative majority. Some of the reasons it didn't was Harper's arts cuts which didn't go over well in Quebec and because of strategic voting from the Left.
I don't sense that Canadians were angry at going to the polls, sure the voter turnout was low but overall we like democracy.

Isn't it good that we tested Dion for the Liberals?
Well he thought the election he promised he wouldn't call for partisan advantage would tip his way, didn't he? Two thirds of the voters disagreed. Then he claimed he didn't really want a majority, which made calling one even more stupid.

I'm curious why you ignore the mendacity of wasting Parliament's time to pass a law you then flout, in order to do exacly what you claimed your law would prevent?

For all that the clown show on the other side has been spectacularly inept, I'd doubt anyone of them could pull off such barefaced duplicity.
 
OJ only remembers what suits him. Being the slightest bit balanced was never part of his act.

Which must mean that you've forgotten Harpo's blather about how special his Fixed Election law was. Always happy to remind you.
 
Is this just to deflect from the fact that polls show most Canadians currently disagree strongly with your views. :D
 
Is this just to deflect from the fact that polls show most Canadians currently disagree strongly with your views. :D
So presumably you blundered past the first post
…edit…If the polls are anything to go by, he'd have been way better off waiting till today.
Try reading. And do cite your source for most Canadians strongly disagreeing on Harper's duplicitousness; I've only seen the ones showing they pick him as the best of a bad lot.

How do such polls make Harpo honest, or less of a scheming hypocrite for touting his Fixed Elections law as a democratic reform, only to ignore it because he'd written it so he could?

In fact, as he has so often, Stevie was suckered by what he saw as easy, immediate partisan advantage, when hanging in for the honest long term would better have served both him and the country he's pretends to govern between Machiavelli Masquerades.

Even if every percent of today's polls turned into Commons seats in an instant election, he'd still have to justify calling that last election which gained him almost nothing and cost us more than $350 million, after vainly crowing his law had made such calls illegal.

Anyway, it's deflecting you isn't it? But then you never were one for facts. Perhaps using a brighter bulb might improve your focus. Obsessing on the least leader leaves you in the dark.
 
So presumably you blundered past the first post
Try reading.

How do the polls make Harpo honest, or less of a scheming hypocrite for touting his Fixed Elections law as a democratic reform, only to ignore it because he'd written it so he could?

In fact, as he has so often, Stevie was suckered by what he saw as easy, immediate partisan advantage, when hanging in for the honest long term would better have served both him and the country he's pretends to govern between Machiavelli Masquerades.

Even if every percent of today's polls turned into Commons seats in an instant election, he'd still have to justify calling that last election which gained him almost nothing and cost us more than $350 million, after vainly crowing his law had made such calls illegal.

Anyway, it's deflecting you isn't it? But then you never were one for facts.

I laughed at it the first 50 times but its lost its comedic value now. Learn a few different tunes for awhile.
 
So presumably you blundered past the first post
Try reading. And do cite your source for most Canadians strongly disagreeing on Harper's duplicitousness; I've only seen the ones showing they pick him as the best of a bad lot.

How do such polls make Harpo honest, or less of a scheming hypocrite for touting his Fixed Elections law as a democratic reform, only to ignore it because he'd written it so he could?

In fact, as he has so often, Stevie was suckered by what he saw as easy, immediate partisan advantage, when hanging in for the honest long term would better have served both him and the country he's pretends to govern between Machiavelli Masquerades.

Even if every percent of today's polls turned into Commons seats in an instant election, he'd still have to justify calling that last election which gained him almost nothing and cost us more than $350 million, after vainly crowing his law had made such calls illegal.

Anyway, it's deflecting you isn't it? But then you never were one for facts. Perhaps using a brighter bulb might improve your focus. Obsessing on the least leader leaves you in the dark.

I don't seem to recall any of the pols that had a question " who is the least duplicitous leader" in any of them.

Your 1 trick pony is headed for the glue factory try another mount
 
OK Train! The 3 quotes below are the sum total of your "contribution" to this thread. FWIW, they are sequenced from first to last but they are so irrelevant that it wouldn't make the slightest difference if they were upside down and all the words were scrambled like the eggs in any omelette. All are pointless ad hominem attacks intended only to discredit your opponent without ever addressing a single thing he's said.

OJ has a valid point. Harper wasted everyones' time and money passing a completely useless and empty law about fixed election dates. His law contains so many loopholes that it's a complete waste of electricity just posting about it. It is NOT unreasonable to question the quality and the intent of this legislation. So if you can't find a few relevant factoids or at least an excuse for posting anything at all about this subject, why don't you step away from your keyboard, walk to the nearest mirror and ask yourself why it was so important for you to inflict yourself on this thread when you really have nothing but personal animosity and empty rhetoric to contribute. It is a fair question and one that you really ought to deal with.

This is all you've managed to contribute:

1) "OJ only remembers what suits him. Being the slightest bit balanced was never part of his act."

2) "Is this just to deflect from the fact that polls show most Canadians currently disagree strongly with your views."

3) "I laughed at it the first 50 times but its lost its comedic value now. Learn a few different tunes for awhile.

When you want to make sense you do a very good job. But when you get lazy or you lose your focus, you're just another
heavily biased asshole who can't stay on point.
 
The law, in its preamble made explicitly clear that nothing in that Act took away from the Prerogative of the Governor General (as the Queen's Representative in Canada) to call an election on any date of her choosing.

At the time, the Liberals were promising to force an election. That the PM took them at their word served to save taxpayers money, because byelections which were scheduled to take place were no longer necessary.
 
When you want to make sense you do a very good job. But when you get lazy or you lose your focus, you're just another
heavily biased asshole who can't stay on point.

The point has been that OJ has about three songs that he keeps playing in these lame threads of his

1. This one which is about last years election and the "election date". As far as making a contribution to it - how can you? The whole premise is so anal retentive and devoid of substance that all one can do is hope end it mecifully;

2. EI supluses or shortfalls and how all surpluses should be saved - with a secondary point about any increase or decrease in premiums being a secret tax increase or decrease plot launched by that arch-villan Harpo;

3. That Flaherty didn't forecast the correct deficit number in January and that Harper promised no deficit 18 months ago.

That's what causes one to lose focus. It's like listening to Celine Dion over and over again. Christ if he wants to critisize the Conservatives there is plenty of material, why pick these inane topics over and over again ?

While I am prepared to admit to being an asshole on occasion, the being biased accusation part is particularly amusing considering the source. Do you own a mirror? Woody at least posts some decent pictures of naked women ;)
 
Last edited:
The law, in its preamble made explicitly clear that nothing in that Act took away from the Prerogative of the Governor General (as the Queen's Representative in Canada) to call an election on any date of her choosing.

At the time, the Liberals were promising to force an election. That the PM took them at their word served to save taxpayers money, because byelections which were scheduled to take place were no longer necessary.

We have two issues here so lets try to keep them separate shall we?

The first issue is the efficacy of Harper's fixed election date act or whatever it was actually called.

The second issue is why he circumvented the spirit of his newly minted act to call the unnecessary election. You say he called an election to save the costs of a couple of by-elections. I think that's pretty weak but my post is aimed at the efficacy issue so I'm not going to argue about Harper's justification for that election.

If nothing in Harper's act takes away the GG's prerogative to call an election, what exactly was the point of creating it and tying up Canada's parliament to get it passed? A few hours after Harper's act went into effect he turned around and asked the GG to dissolve parliament or whatver the terminology is for causing an election to happen. He hadn't been defeated in a confidence vote so he was voluntarily causing an election to happen at a time of his choosing. Wasn't that precisely what his bill was supposed to prevent?

Never mind why he called the election. I'm concerned about the fact that he crafted a bill which was supposed to prevent event X from happening but, hours later, event x happened anyway. Am I the only one who doesn't like slippery little weasels who dick around with Canada's parliament? I have no idea how much this absurd exercise cost us but I'd be willing to bet it wasn't cheap. I'd also be willing to bet there were umpteen other important issues they could have been working on but they were too busy playing Harper's silly little games. That parliament was Harper's golden opportunity to get things done but he pissed it away. His bills were getting passed. He was clearly in the driver's seat with such a weak opposition but he was too busy being clever to actually drive the bus.