Why can't we have ideas like this here?

Zam

Banned
Mar 20, 2002
414
0
0
Are there bright people, smart thinkers in this city?

I mean people that have cool ideas that make this city better and more advanced.
It seems we settle for the 'safe' idea that isn't really a solution. Boring.

I saw this:
1206415038_7f419d96a1_b.jpg


And wondered, How come this wasn't thought of for the island airport?

I feel we need to get the bureaucratic ninkampoops out of the way and get innovative people with fresh ideas.

More:
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/207/477213383_c3700cb019.jpg
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/189/477213405_ccf12e2a19.jpg
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/201/477213389_65523a779d.jpg
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/204/477213387_2a2731b02a.jpg
http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1320/1206420002_cad15fdd57_b.jpg

http://googlesightseeing.com/2009/01/22/slauerhoffbrug/
 
It is not the engineering that is keeping a bridge from the Island, it is the desire of local residents to try to reduce the noise impact of the airport. Less traffic means less planes taking off and landing.
 
Thanks LadyTY2Uall. It feels soooo good too.

Compromised, I understand its the residents and city council. However, if such forward ideas were brought to the table perhaps those on the other side of the issue would be wowed and excited they would take up the cause.

Also, there is so much new infrastructure need that some new perspective would stimulate better projects.
 
Compromised, I understand its the residents and city council. However, if such forward ideas were brought to the table perhaps those on the other side of the issue would be wowed and excited they would take up the cause.

You don't seem to have grasped what is opposed.
 
You don't seem to have grasped what is opposed.

Not so. The airport is what is not wanted. They don't want it expanded. I got it.

I was trying to use the airport link as an example of the small thinking in the city planning. The fixed link, the tunnel, and the ferry surely the planners could have presented more innovative ideas. Like the one I posted.

Same with the TTC expansion, Gardiner proposal, the Don lands, all the vacant lots etc., etc.
 
I was trying to use the airport link as an example of the small thinking in the city planning. The fixed link, the tunnel, and the ferry surely the planners could have presented more innovative ideas. Like the one I posted.

I guess they could have presented more innovative ideas, but since the opposition is 100% opposed to any modification that will make it easier to reach the islands the end result will still be the same.


Same with the TTC expansion, Gardiner proposal, the Don lands, all the vacant lots etc., etc.

So why aren't you pitching these innovative ideas to city council?
 
a couple of things:

1) I think the image in the pic is fricken ugly as sin
2) the catilever is about 1.5 times the "bridging section". SInce the western gap is about 100 yds wide, that means the cantilever would need to be about 150 yds long. Do you propose tearing down the ontario subsidized housing that's there?
3) The simplest solution would be to install a bridge like the london bridge where the surface is raised 100% vertically.

As stated, the problem isn't what kind of bridge to install, but whether there should be a bridge at all......
 
1) I think the image in the pic is fricken ugly as sin.

I agree. The photo reminds me of the ugly ROM addition and the foolish looking OCA building. The first time you see them you might think 'well, that's different.' After that it's 'ugly as sin.' They don't wear well.

jwm
 
It wasn't my intention to debate the island airport.
It was to talk about why other ideas where/are not presented to better the city.

jwmorrice, tboy, The Dutch could have put in a metal lift bridge but they didn't. It may not be the prettiest sight but, it was the innovative construction that I was trying to put forward. Then again, everyone has different tastes and not everyone can be pleased.

Moraff, Well, I'm not an engineer or have a construction company that will benefit from the pitch. Also, I don't get paid six figures like those that make the ultimate decision and take the credit like those on council.
 
It wasn't my intention to debate the island airport.
It was to talk about why other ideas where/are not presented to better the city.
I have no doubt that the city employees who have looked at the question have looked at a variety of options. They may have even looked at a "drawbridge" design.

They may also have looked at a "floating bridge" design: think of a couple long ferryboats connected end-to-end and connected shore-to-shore. If traffic needs to pass, they simply disengage.

Operational costs would be higher, but construction costs would probably be lower than the lift bridge design.

Still, the very idea of a link to the island is anathema to the left-wing politicians at Toronto City Hall, and it's a no-go.
 
The only problem with the floating bridge design is the western gap has to be open to marine traffic and this would put an end to that.

I agree, that innovative designs/ideas should be looked at but not just simply because they are "different", they have to be "better" than existing methods.

That one in the original post while unique, doesn't appear to be practical and I bet it wasn't a cheap proposition either. Often things that are pretty as well as functional end up costing much much more......
 
The only problem with the floating bridge design is the western gap has to be open to marine traffic and this would put an end to that.
You may wish to read what I wrote before responding to it: you'll find that my comment already addressed what you claim to be a problem with it.
 
We do have a bascule bridge on Cherry St. over the Ship Channel to the Turning Basin. Nothing new in what you propose. But it takes a lot longer to close the gates and raise and lower the bridge than the present ferry takes to cross. And just about every dinky little boat in the harbour would be big enough to need the bridge raised, unless you mutilated the shoreside areas to build serious, raised access ramps at both ends.
 
The big problem is the tiny people on council in toronto. They do not have the best interests of the " City" at heart. They have the best interests of their re-election campaign on their tiny little minds. There could have been an almost majical transformation of the city over the years but the massive public minded intellectual councilors pander to their core constituancies and nothing of not gets done.
 
just read a note from paul henderson, the olympic boater not teh hockey player. He points out that the western gap is actually a hazard to boats due to its design, his solution close the western gap bring everything in the eastern gap, this is one of those innovative ideas that won't get off the ground .
 
just read a note from paul henderson, the olympic boater not teh hockey player. He points out that the western gap is actually a hazard to boats due to its design, his solution close the western gap bring everything in the eastern gap, this is one of those innovative ideas that won't get off the ground .

Ummmmm what kind of boat? I've travelled through there hundreds of times with NO problem whatsoever. Now you have to watch for the little ferry cuz when it blasts its horn, it doesn't stop for anyone......but hey, if one was to study and pass and get their harbour licence, they'd know this......

Anonym: I did read your post and disengaging and reengaging a floating bridge is ludicrous at best.....hence why I ignored it.....
 
the article was concerned more with site lines and access , Beyond the article I would be hard pressed to know the actual details of his complaints. Canoes,Kyaks and rivers are more my speed. It was more along the lines of demonstrating the shallow end of the gene pool that run for public office around here